Roselyne Hurel's work, of which the first two volumes have now appeared, is the first to systematically evaluate the 2,500 and more paintings that the National Library of France has accumulated since the eighteenth century. It will stand with similar works such as Linda Leach's catalogue of the Chester Beatty collection as an indispensable book for the students, collectors and others interested in the field of Indian painting for at least a generation and probably longer. We are fortunate that this little studied collection came to be catalogued by a meticulous scholar and at a time when it has become economic for high quality colour printing to be used for every illustration. The work is further remarkable for having been produced by someone who spent her professional life dedicated to European Art as a curator at the Carnavalet Museum in Paris.
The introductory 50 pages give an invaluable account of the development of the collection during three centuries through purchases, donations and theft, namely Napoleon's plunder of Europe. The most notable part of the collection by volume and value is probably the donation by Colonel Gentil, an eighteenth-century soldier in Pondicherry, Deccan and later in Oudh. Other important sources were purchases from Paris and London dealers in the nineteenth century. A most interesting note in the introduction tells us that numbers of high quality paintings also arrived in Europe as part of the second Abdul Hamid sale in Paris in 1909 and with waves of fleeing Qajar notables and nobles during the convulsions that afflicted Persia during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. These paintings had been in Persia since the looting of Delhi in 1739. Some are now in public collections such as the Louvre and Guimet but alas not in the Bibliotheque Nationale. So they are not described here.
The introduction also covers the technique of the miniature painter and recounts the biographies of the collectors.
As far as possible there are short biographical notes about the subjects, mostly from Maathir ul Umara, the nearest thing we have to a Dictionary of National Biography of Mughal India.
The catalogue is arranged by schools of art and chronologically starting with 149 Mughal paintings. It is striking that there are no Hamza Nama pages in the collection, perhaps an indication that the Hamza Nama began to be picked apart in Iran after the greater part of the Paris collection had been formed.
The catalogue of Mughal paintings is followed by a description of 70 paintings of post-Mughal north India, notably Murshidabad, Oudh and the less known Furrukhabad School.
Examples of the attention to detail given by the author is the note to a painting of Zain Khan Kokah, (p. 57) noting that he was the son of Akbar's wet nurse. Another example of the high standard maintained throughout the text is the analysis of no. 1, “Murder in a Landscape’’. The other paintings in the series to which this painting belongs are mentioned as well as its passage through the Oudh and Rampur libraries.
An extraordinary example of Mme. Hurel's erudition is the note to painting 38, (p. 73), dated to 1620, where two Portuguese are looking at three hares tied together by their ears. The motif is traced to Sassanian sixth to seventh century origins, it is noted that it can be seen in cave 407 in Dunhuang and it is noted that the motif was adopted as a symbol of the Trinity, and hence is being shown with the Portuguese.
There are 32 paintings from various Deccani schools, 12 from Rajashthani schools and 21 from various North Indian Company Schools. The paucity of Rajasthani paintings is explained in the preface as being because the dispersals of the great Rajput libraries mainly occurred in the mid to late twentieth centuries, after the formation of the bulk of the Bibliothèque Nationale's collection.
At the end of Volume 2 there is a valuable list of people from the Mughal period who are mentioned in this catalogue.
This second volume covers the South Indian schools. The paintings described in it lack the highly finished and jewel like quality of the products of the Mughals and those influenced by them in the north. Few are of court scenes and courtiers. It is notable that only some six paintings are from Pondicherry. These paintings are very rare and of great ethnographic interest, Roselyne Hurel has brought her almost encyclopaedic knowledge of Hindu iconography to explain the scenes depicted in them and there is an invaluable list of names from the Hindu Pantheon at the end of this volume.
These catalogues with their excellent references and indexes will open many doors to future students of the Indian art and this particular collection. It will now be far easier to consider, for example, the trade in paintings, copying, influences on various schools, the evolution of borders and an examination of the decorative arts as seen in the paintings.
The wealth of knowledge here makes this catalogue, (and a knowledge of French!), an indispensable source for anyone interested in Indian art. Roselyne Hurel has rendered us all an immense service.
There are more Indian paintings in another section of the Bibliothѐque Nationale the Département des Manuscrits. We await Mme Hurel's third volume to become acquainted with these.
