The caves at Ajanta are perhaps India's most renowned Buddhist monuments, and they have attracted the attention of Walter Spink for more than fifty years. Ajanta: History and Development: Painting, Sculpture, Architecture—Year by Year is the fourth volume out of a planned six to be published by Brill as part of its Handbook of Oriental Studies series. In the present volume, Spink analyzes Ajanta's artistic achievements according to his “short chronology” (ca. 462–80 ce). Spink takes the reader through each year of activity, carefully explaining the different phases of work across the site. Artistic activity is also analyzed through a lens of imperial patronage as Spink highlights the roles of the Vakataka emperor Harisena (pp. 49–50, 73–81) and two local feudatories associated with the site: the Asmakas and Risikas (pp. 45–48, 53–65).
Regardless of whether one wholeheartedly accepts Spink's precise chronology, this volume is an invaluable source for understanding the day-to-day challenges faced by Ajanta's artists. Many examples can be mentioned here, but among the most interesting are those “corrections” that had to be made on the spot. Predesigned pictorial compositions (initially sketched on cloth to be transferred onto walls) sometimes did not fit their intended location because of the inconsistent dimensions of cell doorways (p. 41). In such cases, stone slabs had to be inserted and secured with mud plaster to “fill in” negative spaces so that the composition would not have to be redone. Entire caves had to be modified at times too as ceilings and floors were often misaligned and had to be leveled or reangled (pp. 19–24).
Modifications made specifically to Ajanta's main shrine Buddha images also reveal important realities of working at the site, especially in regard to getting images finished and dedicated. In what appears to be an exercise of expediency, many of Ajanta's main shrine Buddha images were rushed to completion. Haloes and throne motifs on some images (such as in caves 7, 11, and 15) were painted rather than carved (pp. 36–39). The many “shortcuts” that the artists developed, including painting the Buddha's snail-shell curls rather than carving them (p. 89), do seem to indicate the importance placed on getting the images dedicated, even if the rest of the cave was relatively left unfinished. Indeed, it is through the act of dedication that the vihara becomes an active worship space with its “living” image (pp. 82–83).
Spink's contributions in identifying and describing these processes have a great bearing on our understanding of devotional activities at the site. For example, Spink notes that “intrusive” images (images that were added to preexisting programs) are found only in caves where the main shrine image was dedicated (pp. 82–83). Moreover, these images were not commissioned by the site's imperial elites, but by the local resident monks. The addition of these images (and their donative inscriptions) clearly indicates a dynamic shift in patronage at the site. Spink further addresses the role of monastic participation at Ajanta by examining the shrines and antechambers for evidence of actual worship practices. Such evidence includes the presence of soot or a grimy residue from the use of oil lamps as well as the inclusion of iron hooks for hanging garlands (some of which are still embedded in the shrine and antechamber ceilings). It is through these types of observations that we can begin to understand how these caves were viewed and used by the monks who lived there.
In addition to the written descriptions of the site's development from year to year, this volume provides ample photographs and plans of the caves, which are arranged according to their numerical sequence. The present volume also contains numerous charts and tables that highlight specialized studies at Ajanta, such as a checklist of the sculpted “intrusive” images at the site (figure 44), a count of residential cells for each cave (figure 37), and diagrams of the various doorway types that reveal new and improved systems for hanging wooden doors (figures 34–36). A serious omission in this volume, however, is the absence of a bibliography. Although the text has footnotes, these are only partial citations that become points of frustration for those who want to examine the scholarly work that is being referenced. Apart from that, the volume is a readable synthesis of Spink's many years of work and scholarly publications on the site. It allows a larger audience to experience Ajanta not as a monolithic manmade wonder but as a site that reveals the complexities of Buddhist artistic and devotional practice in the late fifth century ce.
