James Nye's title is enticingly vague, giving little away as to his book's content. The reader who delves into it will find an absorbing exploration and explanation of the history of Smiths Group, a British industrial company that is presently “one of the hundred most valued listed companies” on the London Stock Exchange, having “sixteen decades” of manufacturing behind it (p. 323). Smiths has, at different times, produced a variegated mixture of products. Beginning as a small store retailing jewelry, the business first expanded and then diversified into the manufacture of jewelry and watches, followed by automobile, aeronautical, and marine instruments. For much of its history, through to the mid-1970s, the firm was heavily involved in supplying automotive products to vehicle manufacturers and in the manufacture of clocks and watches, but by the 1980s it was shedding its old activities and moving into fields such as medical devices and aerospace industries. Then, in the 1990s, it again transformed its interests, adding telecommunications components to its existing products. The early 2000s saw still more radical changes with a move to internationalization and involvement in new areas of technology, such as equipment for the detection of explosives and narcotics and products for the oil and gas industries.
The Smiths story is, Nye proposes, one of survival through adaptation and metamorphosis, where what began as a small entrepreneurial family firm evolved in distinct stages, first separating ownership from control and then introducing professional managers, until it ultimately evolved into an international business presently employing twenty-three thousand people. Key to the process were the successive adoptions of different business models, resulting from both prior experience and novel thinking.
The author has set himself a hard task in producing a book that will satisfy the needs of a potentially diverse audience. Written to coincide with the centenary of the firm's flotation on the London Stock Exchange in 1914, but looking back much further to its inception in 1851, the book looks to cater simultaneously to readers familiar with the firm, to a larger general readership, and not least—but possibly most problematically—to an academic community of business historians. Nye makes clear that the latter audience is an important one but also acknowledges the problems in appealing also to a wider lay readership (p. ix). His book inevitably falls into the category of “jubilee volume,” a genre perhaps associated with companies’ self-congratulatory depictions of success and, for the business historian, carrying the risk that it might “descend into anecdote” (p. 301). Bridging the gap between the historian's desire for detail, analysis, and the investigation of the applicability of theory, on the one hand, and the entirely reasonable wish of a broader market for the proverbial “good read,” on the other, is a challenge that Nye takes on with considerable success—even if the balance of the book perhaps tilts slightly toward those outside academia.
The book is commendably well researched. The author had the substantial benefit of unfettered access to the firm's extensive archive material without, so the foreword by a former chairman assures us, the company seeking in any way to influence his thinking or writing. Nye has made the most of the opportunity and certainly has not produced a company hagiography. He has not only dug deeply into Smiths's own material but also spread his search for other primary source material further afield in order to fill gaps and provide essential context. His narrative chronological account of Smiths's evolution, which he describes as essentially a management history, slices up the time into variable periods characterized by significant changes in, or substantial problems faced by, the company.
The nature and periodization of these time periods influence the way the chapters are written and their impact on the reader. The earlier periods, for which the firm's own records are more sparse, paint a more broad-brush picture with a greater leavening of (sometimes highly entertaining) anecdote and context relevant to the company's fields of activity. The reader is treated, for instance, to some fascinating vignettes relating to automobile lighting and the reasons for the development of the speedometer as well as an intriguing account of the extreme problems to be found in high-end jewelry manufacturing. Following the firm's flotation in 1914, the tone of the narrative changes slightly as the story draws more heavily on Smiths's increasing archival coverage, becoming more detailed in its recording of change and the reasons for the evolution of the business. This trend continues with evidence, as opposed to anecdote, becoming increasingly substantial, but Nye continues to provide context for events—and some detailing of what he calls Smiths's “culture”—to prevent the chronology becoming indigestible.
These tone changes continue as the increasing complexity and pace of change in the affairs of the business, particularly after the mid-1970s, become clear. It is to the author's credit that despite the growing numbers of new actors—both individuals and companies—entering and leaving the story, he manages to keep his text focused and readable. Explanations, and the occasional vignette, are woven into the account neatly. In short, he tells the tale well.
Given the disparate nature of the likely audience(s), it should be no surprise that Nye does not apply any particular theory of business or management history to account for Smiths's survival. Nor should it disappoint that he does not propose or provide any new theoretical underpinning for the firm's longevity. But that should not be taken to mean that he eschews the value and applicability of theory to business history. Rather, he invites readers to draw on their own thinking in reflecting on and engaging with his own interpretations, which are brought neatly together in the book's concluding chapter. Altogether, Nye makes a strong case to support the continuing value of the single company monograph to the business historian, and the book is well worth exploring by both academic and general readers.
