Justices of the Peace, or magistrates as they are commonly known, have been an important part of the English legal system for over six hundred and fifty years. Exclusively a male preserve until the early twentieth century, the magistracy was made up of men of wealth and influence appointed by the Lord Lieutenant of each county in England to enforce the law at the local level. They dealt with a wide range of offences, referring only the most serious to the higher courts, and in addition oversaw many of the functions of local government.Footnote 1 For about a century, from the mid-eighteenth century to the mid-nineteenth, the parish clergy of the Church of England became a dominant group within the magistracy, and their engagement in this role created a significant level of debate and controversy within and outside the church. The sharp decline in the numbers of clerical magistrates at the end of this period has been attributed to several factors, including a growing moral conscience uneasy with the combined roles of pastor and magistrate. However, there is evidence to suggest that the role of the clerical magistrate gave some clergy direct insight into the lives of people beyond their usual congregation, and thus a wider interaction with local society, which was lost when clergy began to concentrate more on ecclesial duties. This study, which focuses on the county of Staffordshire, suggests that the decline of the clerical magistracy was the result of a process of secularization within English society, as the clergy (and thus the church) withdrew from this formal and statutory involvement in local affairs.Footnote 2 It provides an early indication of the reduction of the influence of the church in the secular sphere, particularly in urban and industrialized areas at first, but spreading to the rural areas by the end of the period. Staffordshire included a wide spectrum of natural and human environments: heavily industrialized and urban areas, upland moors and rich lowland pastures. It united features from the north and south of England, and as such may be taken as representative for the purpose of this study.
In the mid-eighteenth century, the landed property requirement for Justices of the Peace was lowered to an annual income of £100, which enabled many clergy who held benefices, and therefore freeholds, to become magistrates. In 1760 around 11 per cent of magistrates were clergy, but in the decades that followed, increased wealth from agricultural improvement, reform of the tithe system and widespread parliamentary enclosure raised the income and social status of many beneficed clergy, making them, in the view of those who made the appointments, more suitable as magistrates.Footnote 3 About the same time the gentry, the traditional holders of this role, were becoming less inclined to serve as magistrates as they became more detached from the communities associated with their landed estates.Footnote 4 There are significant regional differences in these factors, but there was a general trend for beneficed clergy to rise in wealth and social standing until the mid-nineteenth century which is matched by an increase in the size of the clerical magistracy. In England and Wales, the proportion of magistrates who were clergy rose steadily to a peak of over 25 per cent in the 1830s, followed by a sharp decline to around 6 per cent in the 1870s, only two generations or so of clergy later.Footnote 5 For Staffordshire, the figures show a similar decline after the 1830s, albeit less precipitous and from a higher peak: 35 per cent in the 1830s, 23 per cent in the 1860s, 12 per cent in the 1890s and 6 per cent in the 1920s.Footnote 6 Other county studies show some variation from the national pattern of decline, and the key factors have been identified as the urban or rural character of local communities, the diminishing wealth and social status of clergy, and the presence of other suitable groups to take up the role.Footnote 7
In considering clergy as magistrates, it is important to distinguish between the different types of parish clergy. Those who were freeholders of the wealthier parishes and had landed family connections were much more likely to be appointed as magistrates than clergy serving in poorer parishes or as non-beneficed perpetual curates. A correlation has been found between the number of clerical magistrates in a county and the extent of land that had been granted to clergy in lieu of tithe.Footnote 8 In Staffordshire, a clergyman who was a member of one of the influential county families could expect to be presented to a significant parish and be put forward as a magistrate, not least because members of his family made such appointments.Footnote 9
Generally, clergy made up a much smaller percentage of the magistracy in urban and industrial areas, and from this low level declined at a similar rate to the national average. In England and Wales in 1841 the clergy made up less than 1 per cent of magistrates in the urban boroughs, and by 1885 this had fallen to 0.2 per cent.Footnote 10 However, local variations from the national figures were significant. For instance, in 1832 clerical magistrates in the urban and industrial town of Wolverhampton (then in Staffordshire), made up over 18 per cent of the total, due in part to the notable reluctance of the Lord Lieutenant to accept candidates from other groups, a prejudice which could not be sustained in the following decade.Footnote 11 There was a particular need to increase the number of magistrates after the Chartist disturbances but there were insufficient numbers of suitable clergy to take up the role. At a steady pace, first in the industrial towns and later in the rural areas, the clergy were replaced by others as magistrates, largely those described at the time as ‘gentlemen’ or ‘middle class’, or more pejoratively as ‘men of trade’.Footnote 12
The decline in clerical magistrates was more profound when active engagement is considered. It was not uncommon for magistrates to be appointed but not serve in the courts, treating the role as symbolic of a particular social status, or in later life to retire from the function but retain the title as a mark of respect. Nationally, the clerical magistrates in the 1880s were, after the gentry, the least active in terms of involvement in court cases, suggesting that many had retained the status without undertaking the duty, particularly as they grew older.Footnote 13 This pattern of younger clergy not choosing to take up the role has been confirmed in Staffordshire, where those ordained after the 1830s were less likely to be appointed as magistrates.Footnote 14
A range of reasons for the steep decline from the mid-nineteenth century has been put forward. Much of the focus is on the turning point of the 1830s. In this period of societal unrest, when the clerical magistracy was at its strongest, magistrates stood on the front line of the violent consequences of social change, imposing laws which were newly enacted or interpreted in the face of established, if informal, custom. Clerical magistrates had the unique and precarious position of combining innovation, such as the new financial model for tithes and the improvements in agriculture with tradition, as both representatives of the church and dependent on patronage. The clerical magistrates claimed ancient rights for modern purposes, exemplified in the tithe disputes, which were prevalent in the first half of the nineteenth century. These changes were resisted by what has been described as a ‘robust plebeian culture’, expressed in crimes of social protest, such as poaching, arson of hay ricks, animal maiming and illegal gleaning, all in areas of legal enforcement with which clerical magistrates were necessarily heavily involved.Footnote 15 Some clergy, and particularly bishops who had direct political influence, were perceived to stand in the way of political reform and as such were targets for acts of violent agitation, to which magistrates had to respond in defence of law and order. Perhaps a reason why clerical magistrates were so widely criticized in this period was their ambiguous position regarding innovation and tradition.Footnote 16 This may have weakened the role of clergy as agents of social control, formalized in the position of clerical magistrate, which in turn contributed to their decline.Footnote 17
Furthermore, clerical magistrates were an expression of the shift of local power from patriarchal justice to patrician justice, a process that began in the eighteenth century. It has been suggested that clerical magistrates, as a relatively new group within magistracy replacing (in many cases) the gentry, were more willing to implement the national government agenda than to respond to local sensibilities.Footnote 18 However, this was tempered by their personal connections to landed wealth, and to the traditional structures of society upon which they relied.Footnote 19 Additionally, by the nineteenth century the practical concept of the parish as a distinct community was under strain, especially in urban areas, and this particularly affected clergy because they were appointed to this geographical unit.Footnote 20 In due course, social change would sweep the clerical magistrates away as well, to be replaced by the middle class of industrialists; this change came much earlier in the century in the urban and industrial areas, such as Wolverhampton and Stoke-on-Trent in Staffordshire, than in the rural areas.
Infamous incidents involving clerical magistrates in the 1830s were common, although such accounts did not represent the actions of all such clergy and may have been over-emphasized. One example for Staffordshire is recalled in an account entitled ‘The Wolves let loose at Wolverhampton’ in 1835.Footnote 21 After a particularly contentious parliamentary election a crowd gathered outside the Swan Inn in Wolverhampton, and the Revd John Clare, a long-standing magistrate, stood on a balcony in an attempt to calm the crowd. A missile was thrown that hit him on the shoulder; this convinced him of the need to read the Riot Act and send in the Dragoon Guards. Over the next few hours, sporadic violence filled the surrounding streets, four protestors were wounded by gun fire and several buildings were damaged. Clare, who had a reputation for his harsh response to public disorder, came in for some criticism in the local and national press: ‘But who is the author of this outrage? The man who gave the order to fire upon his fellow citizens … in mere personal vengeful feeling for a slight contempt passed upon him …. was a Clergyman. A Minister of Peace sounded the signal for war.’ Footnote 22 Also, in the subsequent public enquiry there was strong criticism of Clare: the Dragoon captain complained that the clerical magistrate was keen to send in the troops even before the Riot Act was read, but then declined to lead the troops out into the streets as would be expected.Footnote 23 The notoriety of the Wolverhampton incident emphasized the rashness and incompetence of the clerical magistrate. Events such as this, although quite rare, served to reinforce the view that the clergy ought not to accept the role of magistrate, and from this time such a view gathered strength for a variety of reasons.
One important argument at the time was that to be a magistrate was a distraction from parochial duty. This became more of an issue as such duties became more ecclesiastically defined with the development of the clerical profession in the nineteenth century. The expectations that clergy would be resident in their parishes (to avoid pluralism and absenteeism) and adopt a more self-consciously clerical way of life were features of this development. Over the same period, the role of the magistrate became more focused on the judicial function rather than the wider scope of local government administration.Footnote 24 Gradually the responsibility for, and oversight of, local gaols and asylums, the licensing of ale houses and the regulation of highways and bridges were taken over by elected councils and other bodies.Footnote 25 Thus clerical magistrates found it harder to justify the role of magistrate in terms of the general welfare of the parish. The Justice of the Peace returns to parliament specifically asked whether the clerical magistrate had ‘the cure of souls, or [was] performing other Clerical duty’, implying that this might be an issue.Footnote 26 In 1873 a parliamentary bill was presented to disqualify parish clergy from the office of magistrate, which, although unsuccessful, represented a strong body of opinion.Footnote 27 Some Lord Lieutenants particularly disapproved of clerical magistrates who had parochial duties and in Shropshire, a county adjacent to Staffordshire, there was an official resistance to such appointments.Footnote 28 However, it was recognized that the extent of parochial duties varied greatly between clergy; this allowed some to take up the role, and where they did so the benefits to the local society in maintaining peace and order were tangible to some. The Church Magazine observed in 1840:
A return to the House of Commons has been published, of the names, addresses and residences of the justices of the peace, being ministers of the Established Church, which makes the total number about 2000. In Norfolk there are 102 reverend justices of the peace, and in Suffolk not less than 111. These counties are the best conducted in England.Footnote 29
The view that clergy acting as magistrates provided stability and good governance in the local community was expressed by those who sought to maintain the status quo, but even this viewpoint had to recognize the first call on clerical duty, which was the maintenance of the church. It was natural that, as the clerical role became more professional and specialized as the nineteenth century proceeded, both the availability of, and the inclination for, clergy to be involved in secular legal functions was likely to decline.
Another major reason to oppose clerical magistrates related directly to the special character and role of clergy, which had always been present but became more emphasized in the idea of the cleric as religious professional: it was not fitting for a minster of religion, largely because it involved passing judgment, and in particular passing judgment on others in secular matters. The clergy should not be involved in the business of law enforcement because it was contrary to their vocation. The Wolverhampton Chronicle, a few years before the infamous incident outside the Swan Inn, had declared that ‘the duties of a Christian pastor are utterly incompatible with those of an active justice in populous towns’.Footnote 30 Richard Fryer, MP for Wolverhampton in 1832, who had been turned down for the role of magistrate in his earlier years because he was an industrialist, described the clerical magistrate as having ‘the cross in one hand and the gibbet in the other’.Footnote 31 Obelkevich, in his classic study of the nineteenth-century clergy in Lincolnshire, suggests that many clergy regarded being a magistrate as inconsistent with their ministry, and Evans gives more examples.Footnote 32 Primarily, it was felt that the responsibilities of a magistrate could jeopardize the clergy's pastoral relationships and draw them into disputes that were not just distracting but also damaging to the church. Some clergy, particularly those from the more extreme wings of the church, either evangelical or Oxford Movement, were less likely to aspire to non-ecclesial duties. A recent large-scale study of the Tractarian clergy shows that none of them would have contemplated becoming a magistrate, which is perhaps not surprising, given their attitude to secular authority and their desire for a more distinctively clerical role.Footnote 33 Accepting that from the mid-nineteenth century there was a general trend for clergy, whatever their party, to become more ecclesial in their activities, it would be natural for the number of clerical magistrates to fall.Footnote 34 Furthermore, this was a consequence of ecclesiastical reform that attempted to make the Church of England more accountable, efficient and focused on religious affairs.Footnote 35 However, the opposing view that clergy should take up the magistrate's role so as not to be estranged from society was still being put forward actively at the end of the century. In 1895 an article in The Spectator noted that the controversy over clerical magistracy was an issue that was regularly debated and stated that ministers of the established church ‘often make admirable Magistrates; and to deny them their right to fulfil that function, when it does not interfere with their other duties, is either a folly, or the outcome of ideas which would in the end change all teachers of Christianity into a secluded and inexperienced priestly caste’.Footnote 36
A third reason given was that the clergy were not fit for the role. The partisan nature of Anglican clerical magistrates was an issue for Nonconformists, both in the urban areas where many of the new industrialists were not part of the established church and in the countryside where the tithe was considered by non-Anglicans as an unfair denominational tax. The impact of the growth of Nonconformity was twofold: it presented a more congregational model of ministry, focused on the worshipping community and less inclined to be involved in local legal functions, and it demanded a more denominationally diverse representation of leaders in the local community. For urban areas like Wolverhampton and Stoke-on-Trent in Staffordshire, Nonconformity, particularly in the form of the various brands of Methodism, attracted the support of a large proportion of the population by the mid-nineteenth century.Footnote 37 Comments by some of the clergy at the time betray their establishment leanings. The assize judges came to Stafford in October 1842 to try the Chartist leaders, some of whom were convicted of sedition against the Anglican clergy.Footnote 38 The judges attended Salt Church, where the Revd the Hon. Arthur Chetwyn Talbot preached on Psalm 145: 16: ‘Thou openest thine hand, and satisfiest the desire of every living thing’, a pretext for a sermon on how all in society should be content with what they have. Four years earlier the church had been built at considerable expense as a testimonial to the Earl Talbot, Lord Lieutenant of Staffordshire, responsible for the appointment of all magistrates in the county.Footnote 39 The close connection between the established church and the magistracy could not have been made more obvious. Other links were more hidden: a correlation between Freemasonry and the clerical magistracy has also been noted in Staffordshire, where the clergy in the wealthier parishes and from the more influential families were often both magistrates and freemasons.Footnote 40
Some clergy were considered unfit because of their supposed party political allegiances. In Staffordshire from 1835 there is evidence of the government policy of attempting to bring a greater balance to the magistracy in response to the predominance of Anglicans and supporters of the Tory party. As a result, the appointment of clerical magistrates became the exception, and such candidates, although put forward by the Lord Lieutenant, were often turned down by the Lord Chancellor.Footnote 41 However, the charge of political bias continued through to the 1850s, when the MP for Wolverhampton made a direct intervention to ensure more Liberals were appointed as magistrates.Footnote 42 This policy seemed to have had a direct effect on the number of clerical magistrates in Staffordshire.
Some clerical magistrates were criticized for being ineffectual: In Norfolk they were accused of being ‘fearful of acting with the promptitude decision and firmness which is required in a Magistrate’.Footnote 43 Others, such as Clare in Wolverhampton, were criticized for being too firm or overzealous. As a distinct group within the magistracy, and at this stage fairly numerous, the clergy became an easy target for opposing groups, those who wanted to maintain the status quo and those who wanted change. Some research has shown that clerical magistrates cannot be caricatured in either way, as they were not significantly different in their sentencing from other magistrates, and neither more nor less competent.Footnote 44
Beyond these reasons, there has arisen the view, argued by more recent commentators, that clerical magistrates were damaging to the church, creating a poor reputation for the clergy and even a degree of anti-clericalism.Footnote 45 Henry Brougham has been quoted in support of this:
Nothing has a more direct tendency to excite hatred and contempt both towards the men and towards their sacred office. It is also certain that they have not generally shown such discretion, temperance and forbearance in exercising magisterial functions as might either have been expected or desired from men in their station.Footnote 46
It has been suggested that the church was readjusting itself to be less associated with the powerful, and less compromised by involvement in secular affairs.Footnote 47 Certainly there is evidence for a strained relationship between the church and some sections of the community because of the actions of clerical magistrates. In 1830 in Norfolk, following some disturbances, the clerical magistrates were described as in ‘bad Odour with the People’.Footnote 48 Evans argues that clerical magistrates were singled out for attacks in the 1830–1 riots because of their over-enthusiastic strictness in applying the law to maintain the status quo, although often the criticism was that they were ineffectual.Footnote 49 Wallis describes how the clerical magistrate drove a wedge between the church and the people.Footnote 50 Lee contends that ‘whatever the levels of individual culpability, clerical magistrates were seen to operate at the heart of a system that divided, dissembled and discriminated’.Footnote 51 Much of the focus has been on tithe disputes, although this issue was only a part of the conflict between church and society in this period and by no means the burden of the clerical magistrates’ business. The evidence that this conflict led directly to the decline of clerical magistrates is not conclusive, not least because criticism was levelled at clerical and non-clerical magistrates alike.Footnote 52 It does not explain why the decline was general and not directly related to the criticism of particular clergy.
Moreover, it is clear that involvement in the magistracy provided many clergy with first-hand experience of the lives of the poor in a way that their other clerical duties did not. Involvement in the legal system necessarily involved clergy with key issues that affected local communities in a way that enabled them to exercise a positive influence. During the 1832 cholera epidemic in Staffordshire, the Revd William Leigh in Bilston used his role as magistrate to call for medical assistance from the Board of Health in London.Footnote 53 Even Clare was noted for standing up for workers unreasonably oppressed by their employers in several cases, and other clerical magistrates in Staffordshire were active in opposing the system of truck, strictly illegal, where employees were paid in tokens to be used only at the factory store.Footnote 54 In the coal mining areas of the county, this was in contrast to other magistrates who were often involved in local industry and therefore unable to consider legal action against truck.Footnote 55 The approach of the clergy may have been paternalistic but it has been suggested that such experience of involvement in applying the law helped to instil in clergy a social conscience and to encourage them to ask questions about the social reasons for crime and the inherent injustices of society.Footnote 56 Rather than damaging the church, therefore, it can be argued that the clerical magistracy strengthened its influence and connections in society. This reassessment, based on a more positive view of the role of some clerical magistrates, runs counter to the dominant narrative of clergy embroiled in legal disputes and always seeking to defend the status quo. As clergy of this period represented that ambiguous combination of innovation and tradition, a more balanced narrative is necessary.
The conflicts of the 1830s over clerical magistracy were symptomatic of social change rather than causes of it. The conflicts may have discouraged some of the younger clergy from taking up the role, but the development of the clerical profession and its focus on a more defined ecclesial role was of more significance. At the same time, other candidates who were rising in social status and power through the development of industry and urban areas were willing and keen to serve as magistrates.Footnote 57 In the past, clergy had been appointed because of the perceived lack of other candidates. Thus the marquess of Lansdowne told parliament in 1836: ‘in some counties it was absolutely necessary to appoint clergymen on account of the scarcity of persons qualified for the magisterial station’.Footnote 58 In 1835 there was prejudice against ‘men in trade’ in Staffordshire, where the Lord Lieutenant, Earl Talbot, regarded coal and iron masters as unfit for the role.Footnote 59 However, this attitude had to give way after the Chartist disturbances increased the need for more justices in the Black Country.Footnote 60 Furthermore, these changes were enshrined in law with the introduction of new local government legislation in 1835 which provided for councils in towns to be involved in the selection of magistrates, extended fifty years later to rural areas. By the 1880s, one county, Derbyshire, had no clerical magistrates at all.Footnote 61 Nationally, the steady increase of other groups reduced the clergy to less than 5 per cent of all magistrates by the end of the nineteenth century.
The clerical magistracy in England in this period provides a particular example of the church's direct involvement in society, specifically in enforcing the law in a variety of local contexts at a time of considerable social change and unrest. The reasons for the decline of clerical magistracy from the high point of the 1830s relate to contemporary considerations regarding the appropriate roles and character of clergy, and the fear that it was damaging for the church to be involved so directly in legal enforcement. However, these views were not universally held and there is significant evidence that some clergy, through their work as magistrates, gained a greater awareness of the complexity of society and an appreciation of the societal pressures and injustices that related to crime. It brought clergy into direct contact with people beyond their regular congregations and gave them insight into the lives of the poor and the most disadvantaged. The withdrawal of clergy from the magistracy, particularly amongst men ordained from the 1830s onwards, for a variety of reasons, was a way to avoid conflict and adopt a more distinctively ecclesial role.
The study of the church and the law provides an important insight into the development of secularization in society. The decline of the clerical magistracy that distanced the church from secular authority, requiring clergy to be less formally involved in a key aspect of local society, can be seen as evidence for a process of secularization. Until now the clerical magistracy has not been considered as a measure of secularization in this important period of church history. Such studies have tended to focus on internal features such as church attendance, rather than on the ways in which clergy interacted with people in their communities, perhaps because this is harder to quantify. It has been argued that the clerical magistracy created conflict between clergy and many people, particularly non-Anglicans and the poor, and ultimately damaged the church, adding weight to a process of secularization. However, it is clear that acting as a magistrate brought clergy into a direct relationship with their communities, and in particular with people who were not necessarily members of their congregations. Whether the role was constructive or not, involvement in secular law by clergy gave them a place in secular society beyond the church, a counter-current to any trend of secularization in which clergy were encouraged to be more professional in their outlook and more specialized in their religious duties. Further research into this aspect of the relationship between the church and the law would provide an important indication of how clergy engaged with the local communities beyond their congregations, and thus of how the relationship between church and society developed and changed during the nineteenth century.
