In three of the four Gospels of the New Testament, Jesus cautions his followers soon before his arrest. As the Gospel of Mark puts his words: “For ye have the poor with you always, and whensoever ye will ye may do them good: but me ye have not always” (Mark 14:7).
This is a contentious passage. In the 1970s and 1980s, it became popular among some American conservatives, used as a club against advocates of welfare, union rights, and social services for the impoverished. Why waste energy and resources to end poverty, they asked, when Jesus tells us the problem is unfixable? Other Christians, less sanguine about such free market rhetoric, pointed out that Jesus in this passage is paraphrasing Deuteronomy 15:11: “The poor shall never cease out of the land: therefore I command thee, saying, Thou shalt open thine hand wide unto thy brother, to thy poor, and to thy needy, in thy land.” They argued that Jesus's point is that he will soon be gone, but the poor must always be helped.Footnote 1
Cantwell, Carter, and Drake offer us a wide-ranging conversation about that second type of Christian—both the poor and working class who sought to better their conditions and those who tried to help them. In his forward, Ken Fones-Wolf makes several observations widely echoed both in the editors' introduction and in several of the essays: that historians have tended to treat labor history and religious history as separate strands of the American experience. The editors ascribe this tendency in part to the influence of Karl Marx, whose suspicion that religion simply made the oppressed tolerate their oppression has been in some cases validated by recent scholarship on the relationship between Christianity and capitalism in the United States. In these works, conservatives and capitalists sought in Christianity metaphysical validation for free market economics and a force to tame their unruly workers, and built a political coalition called the Religious Right. This sort of historiography has tended to read religious history through Marx's paradigm of history, if not his theory of religion: religion is either a tool of the oppressor or a tonic for the oppressed, either a grim tyrant or, in some cases, a motive force for revolution.
Many of the essays in this volume engage with this model, and they usefully complicate the theory that religion is simply a tool for social control or for radical uprisings. Arlene Sanchez-Walsh's essay, for instance, describes a cigar workers' strike in 1938 San Antonio, Texas. Paying close attention to a number of religious groups in the city—the largely Catholic workers and factory owners, the activist Jewish community, and some Pentecostal missionaries—she shows how religion was on all sides in this conflict, as Communist union leader Emma Tecayuna and the owners of the factory invoked Catholicism against one another, while Jews and Pentecostals called upon God's favor on opposing sides of the struggle. Similarly, Matthew Pehl's fascinating exploration of the Detroit Industrial Mission, which sent liberal Protestants to the factory floors of 1950s and 1960s Detroit, shows how the Christianity of the earnest Protestant missionaries and that of the hard-bitten, often Catholic and African American workers bore little resemblance to each other. The utopian egalitarianism of the missionaries wilted somewhat in the face of the hard realities of the automobile plants.
The diversity of religious experience Pahl and Sanchez-Walsh show us, the disjuncture between religious leaders and laity, is a central theme of the story the editors hope to tell. Emerging from many of these essays are Christianities that may seem unfamiliar to many readers, as they were unfamiliar to the ministers, academics, and theologians who are generally the focus of historians’ labors. Dan McKanan describes the esoteric Christian theologies of two late nineteenth-century popular novelists, who presented in the pages of their fiction an economically radical Jesus who owed a great debt to the obscure ideas of the Rosicrucians; McKanan notes, however, that unlike those academics and theologians, they wrote “books that ordinary workers might want to read” (34). It is a point well taken. Similarly, Evelyn Sterne writes of Catholics in nineteenth- and early twentieth-century Rhode Island, showing how Catholic parishes were centers of public life and eventually activism for lay Catholics who were often otherwise disenfranchised. Far from common nineteenth-century stereotypes, her Catholics organize, build communities, get people elected, and occasionally even rebel against their own leadership. Jared Roll uncovers a world of “working class enchantment” in the mining town of Galena, Kansas (77). His miners are simultaneously convinced of the worth of palmistry and prayer, and push the Pentecostal leader Charles Fox Parham toward a sort of proto-prosperity gospel in which God would guide their economic progress.
Other essays focus less on unfamiliar sorts of religiosity and instead center on activism. Alison Collis Greene, Kerry Pimblott, and Erik Gellman use case studies—Greene of Depression-era Tyrell County, North Carolina; Pimblott of Cairo, Illinois; and Gellman of the Urban Training Center, a largely white Protestant mission that sought to work with African American communities in 1960s Chicago—to explore the world of African American Christianity. Greene shows how African Americans and the socialist Fellowship of Southern Churchmen sought to build economic cooperatives; Pimblott and Gellman seek to upend the neat dichotomy many historians have drawn between the seemingly Protestant civil rights movement and the seemingly secular black power movement by illustrating the ways in which religion helped to shape the latter. Finally, Brett Hendrickson documents the theologies and organizations that American Catholics used to protest and attempts to reform the bracero program, which allowed American agricultural industries to bring poorly paid, unorganized workers to the United States from Mexico during the postwar period.
Collectively, these essays are eye-opening, both for the individual stories they tell and for the new paradigms they should offer to scholars interested in both labor and religion. Some struggle with an issue common to those who want to write the history of the working class, or about what is sometimes called “lived religion.” It is far easier to come by source material describing leaders, intellectuals, and the elite than of those these people sought to lead, and these essays, despite the title of the collection, tend to be less about the working class than about those who sought to speak for or to them. Nonetheless, they convincingly demonstrate the value of the editors' introductory claim that we must treat religion as a holistic force that touched the lives of working-class Americans in often unpredictable, but influential ways.
