A new experimental philosophy spread across Europe and to North America during the eighteenth century in tandem with the popularization of Newtonian philosophy. University chairs were created, treatises of experimental physics were published and dedicated collections of scientific instruments – the cabinets of this volume's title – were put together in public, private, academic and courtly contexts. Scientific instruments had an important role in the rise of experimental philosophy, therefore, making the subject a fertile one for instrument historians.
In their introduction, the volume's editors set out some of the questions it seeks to address. These concern the reasons why so many collections were founded across Europe, what drove consensus as to their contents, and the role of instrument-makers. They are also keen to acknowledge and explain the differences arising from local dynamics, as well as evident changes over a substantial timeframe.
The volume commences with Huib Zuidervaart's survey of the Netherlands, which identifies over five hundred collections, most now vanished, to create an impressive overview of the rise of the cabinet there. Zuidervaart traces his narrative from the late seventeenth-century cabinet of curiosity, through the cabinet of experimental philosophy proper, to its demise around 1870, by which time the laboratory was becoming a more significant scientific space. Staying in the Netherlands, Hans Hooijmaijers and Ad Maas describe the University of Leiden's teaching cabinet, which was founded in 1675. They highlight its debt to British Newtonianism, through Jacob 's Gravesande, and uncover the significance of local factors, exemplified by the instruments acquired. These included ‘useful’ models such as windmills, which reflected 's Gravesande's religious convictions far more than his Newtonianism, and eye-catching apparatus to attract audiences. Staying within the academic context, Sofia Talas examines Padua, where Venetian government interests underpinned the formation of a university collection. In Oxford, by contrast, Jim Bennett reveals, the collection grew primarily from the personal interests of successive professors before its closure by the university authorities. Tiemen Cocquyt then offers further insight into the Leiden cabinet, examining the apparatus assembled in the context of the public and commercial projects in which some of the professors became involved, including the water-pumping schemes on which 's Gravesande advised the States of Holland.
The remaining chapters look away from the universities. Inga Elmqvist Söderlund explores the cabinet in the Riddarhuset (House of the Nobility) in Stockholm, formed by private endowment and later taken over by the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences. Paola Bertucci describes the collection founded by Ferdinando Spinelli, prince of Tarsia, but made available to the public. As she argues, there was an evident tension as to whether the cabinet/museum should be seen as a space of representation or of knowledge production. By contrast, the cabinet created in 1769 at the Palace of Ajuda in Lisbon was unquestionably a private space, as Marta Lourenço and David Felismino explain, since it was created for the edification of two princes. Nonetheless, they show, it was recognizably similar to more public cabinets. That of the Garoza family of Verona, which Ivano Dal Prete describes, was made available to visitors and acted as a vehicle for promoting the cultural and political agendas of its founders, notably their desire to renovate the Italian urban aristocracies of the late 1700s. Ewa Wyka provides another survey, of the cabinets established in Poland from the mid-eighteenth century as experimental philosophy replaced scholasticism. The new cabinets included aristocratic, university and religious foundations, and, while many followed European trends, local contingencies often defined how they developed.
While a number of the cabinets described no longer survive, the last two chapters describe two that are still open as museums, taking the narrative well beyond the eighteenth century. Martin Weiss examines the evolution of Teylers Museum, Haarlem, which was set up as a working collection and only survived thanks to later changes of emphasis, particularly the growth of interest in historic instruments in the late nineteenth century. The chapter illustrates well the vagaries, contingencies and omissions that underpin the history of science and its material representation in museums today. In the final chapter, Paolo Brenni explores the history of the Istituto Tecnico Toscano in Florence, founded in the mid-nineteenth century, some decades after the failure of an earlier Royal Museum of Physics.
While the different chapters take in six countries across Europe, continuities are evident. The wide commercial reach of particular instrument-makers, for instance, comes across in the survival of items by Jesse Ramsden as far afield as Portugal, Italy and Poland (not to mention his native England). Yet any apparent homogenization – created, for instance, through the unifying potential of Newtonianism – was frequently moderated by contingent local factors. Familiar historiographic issues also crop up, such as the difficulty of pinning down exactly how the instruments in particular cabinets were used and understood at the time – a perennial problem for curators and historians today. It also becomes painfully clear just how ephemeral these material assemblages have been.
As is usual with the Scientific Instruments and Collections series, of which this is the third volume, the book is well illustrated and includes a number of colour plates. If one ignores the cover price, it nicely supplements previous work on the rise of public science, as well as studies of scientific instruments and the history of collections.
