After a long pause since Carl L. Brown's momentous book, International Politics and the Middle East (Princeton, 1984), in recent years there has been a flurry of scholarly interest in international relations and the Middle East. The new cycle of interest seems to have been generated by the collapse of the Soviet superpower and a direct response to the consequences of the post-Cold War era for the Middle East. A series of studies was devoted to detailed analysis of the post-Cold War, post-Kuwait crisis situation in the region, which proved to be rich in detail but perhaps thinner in theoretical debates. However, new works since the late 1990s point to a much more profound interest in theorizing the Middle East's international politics. In various edited volumes, Telhami and Barnett (2002), Brown (2001), Ehteshami and Hinnebusch (2002), and Fawcett (2005) have all contributed to enriching the theoretical discourse, bringing new ideas and reducing the isolation of Middle Eastern studies in social science research. Hinnebush (2003) and Halliday (2005) have added further weight to the disciplinary-rooted debates with two excellent single-authored books on the international politics/relations of the region. Given that a number of the recent works on these themes are generated in the United Kingdom, Halliday has even gone so far as to suggest that there now exists a flourishing “English School” of Middle East and North Africa (MENA) international relations.
Nonneman's new book is no exception as far as this trend is concerned, and his edited volume adds further depth to the already rich literature on the international relations of the Middle East. His starting point is, how can one better understand the context of foreign policy making in the Middle East? With this mission, he aims to strengthen the bridge between MENA area studies and international relations. He advocates “an approach to studying MENA states' foreign policy that is rooted in an eclectic ‘complex model of international politics’” (p. 7) and that contains multilevel and multicausal, as well as contextual, explanations within the foreign policy analysis tradition. From this starting point, the contributors to the volume busily explore MENA states' foreign policy determinants and refer them to the relationship with Europe—actually the European Union (EU). In case study after case study (Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Morocco, Turkey, Iran, the Gulf Cooperation Council, oil-exporting countries), the conceptual model that emerges in the first two chapters of the book is empirically tested and the debate about relations with the EU tremendously enriched.
The focus of the case studies, however, does vary quite noticeably, largely reflecting the importance of proximity to the EU for that particular state. There is therefore little uniformity in the range of material evidence provided in each chapter, further adding to the richness of the book, in my opinion. Thus, the chapter on Iran by Moshaver of necessity is devoted to the political wrangling between Tehran and the EU since the late 1980s while Gad's study of Egypt's relations with the EU highlights the weight of colonial history on the relationship and the strategic logjam known as the Arab–Israeli conflict. The weight of evidence in each case study thus tells us much about the foreign policy of key MENA actors, as well as the relative power of the EU in its dealings with its own unique “near abroad.”
If I were to suggest an improvement to the book, it would be to include a chapter on Israel that might bring an altogether different dimension to the case studies. Israel's complex relationship with the EU, in the context of its strategic alliance with the United States, would have provided an interesting test for the conceptual framework of the study that locates MENA foreign policymaking in the developing world. If Israel is not a developing-country case study, then how does one evaluate its foreign policy and regional role and relations? Where does it sit vis-à-vis the EU's relations with the region, and what role does it play in shaping other MENA states' foreign policy? But I am digressing, for the meat is already there and the book does reveal a coherent core to its structure.
Thus, we have another excellent book on the ongoing interest in the international relations of MENA states, and as the literature on the outside world's role in this area grows, we have a real opportunity for developing interesting and multifaceted comparative research. As the “English School” in the study of MENA's international relations grows, we wait in anticipation of responses to the methodologies and conceptual frameworks being developed this side of the Atlantic.
