The cover photo of Kim Solga's blog, “The Activist Classroom,” shows a close-up of a car mirror displaying that famous phrase “objects in mirror are closer than they appear.” Indeed, Solga's Theatre & Feminism looks small at first, but it is a little book that rapidly grows as you read it. A crucial volume in Jen Harvie and Dan Rebellato's ambitious “Theatre And” series, Solga's book is a careful guide to feminist performance studies that remains “readable in one sitting by anyone with a curiosity about the subject” (viii) without leaving out the finer points. Considering what it means for female-identified bodies to appear and disappear from theatre space in the late twentieth and early twenty-first century, Solga offers the personal alongside the theoretical to explore both what theatre can offer feminism and why we still need feminism today. Moving through an analysis of the spectator, the performer and performance, and finally the feminist politics of hope and loss, Solga's book is a call to action in feminist theatre studies. The immediacy of the text rests on Solga's notion that “because many more women are ‘doing’ feminism than merely identifying with it, we need to pay attention to feminist practice” (14; original emphasis). This call to react to action, to do in response to doing, is the feminist performance of Solga's work itself.
Organized theoretically and chronologically, the core of Solga's book (entitled “Three Ways to Understand a Movement”) begins with some heavier performance theory from 1988 and 1989, when Sue Ellen Case, Lynda Hart, and Jill Dolan published their first books and TDR published important feminist content, including work by Peggy Phelan and pieces on Karen Finley and Rachel Rosenthal. Solga orchestrates feminist voices so we hear them collaborating on problems together. In the initial section on “Looking/Watching/Spectating,” Solga surveys the feminist politics of “looking” (18) in theatre, carefully curating Dolan's, Phelan's, and Elin Diamond's work. In doing so, she demonstrates connections between psychoanalysis and performance theory and between Marxist thought and theatre studies. Assuming the reader has some knowledge of these paradigms, Solga keeps these forays brief. Her contemporary examples, such as Young Jean Lee's Untitled Feminist Show, foreground the theoretical as practice, reminding us once again that “objects in mirror are closer than they appear.” But how close are they? Reiterating Dolan, Solga asks “where is a woman at the theatre to look? And how might her different context for looking … be used to empower other spectators to see, and to question, what can otherwise seem to be no more than ‘natural’ or ‘inevitable’ gender differences on stage?” (23; original emphasis). In a short discussion of Phelan's controversial notions of “‘active vanishing’” (25; original emphasis) and Diamond's “‘gestic’ feminist criticism” (26), Solga illustrates how major feminist theatre theorists of the late twentieth century explored this very problem.
If theatre holds the mirror up to nature, what violence is being committed against the socially marginalized? In the next section, “Being versus Acting,” Solga considers how feminist theatre criticism has continued to challenge realism within theatrical paradigms. Using Bertolt Brecht as a starting point to move to a discussion of Judith Butler's notion of gender performativity, she explains that feminist theatre makers engaged with “practices that sought to stage gender as a performance that might be staged differently, rather than with practices that encouraged actors to live a gendered role” (38; original emphasis). Solga differentiates between types of resistance to theatrical realism that occurred in the US, Canada, and the UK and emphasizes the LGBTQ work that this resistance also provoked. She swiftly moves to our present moment, citing again the ability of feminists to think through ideas together and anew. As she moves toward a second case study, Carrie Cracknell's production of A Doll's House, Solga shows how Western feminist thought has shifted in the twenty-first century to reflect on its past. Drawing on feminist theatre critics’ self-reflexivity foregrounds the notion that pairing theatre and feminism results in a mode of thinking fraught with its own past trauma yet also hope for a promising future.
The final section of this part of Solga's book, “Hope and Loss,” addresses feminist theatre in the present moment—a moment of globalization, terror, and trauma; a moment when things certainly feel “closer than they appear.” They are so close, in fact, that Solga comes full circle, revisiting the idea that women are “doing” feminism by arguing they are “feeling” feminism. The different strands of these feelings take on various forms, including hope and loss. Solga allows her reader to listen in on a soft argument between Dolan and Elaine Aston, one that grapples with a hope for feminism but also a belief that we may have lost any feminism altogether. There is difficulty in finding and mobilizing a movement that is marked by “‘impression[s]’” of not only trauma but also now “‘redundan[cy]’” (62). Before her final case study, on The Famous Lauren Barri Holstein's How to Become a Cupcake, Solga asks: “Can we articulate a feminist politics of doing on the stage that also accounts for feminism's losses? Might that shift begin to transform the loss of feminist feeling into a fresh hope… ?” (66; original emphasis).
Certainly, Solga's text is hopeful. Her concluding notes on Peggy Shaw's Ruff do illustrate that we are all “in it … together” (75) through her discussion of those affective feminist communities forged between audience and performer; yet there is a lack of “togetherness” in the text in how heavily Solga relies on Western theoretical paradigms. Nevertheless, Solga does address this at the beginning of the book, in a well-crafted and sincere note claiming that the canonical works of theatre and feminism are only now becoming more inclusive. She mitigates this problem remarkably well by providing examples of theatre makers from racialized groups as well as a section on further reading devoted predominantly to those working outside of Anglo-American contexts. Reading Theatre & Feminism invites the reader to be “in it … together” (75) with those other feminist theorists, practitioners, and scholars who may seem inaccessible on their own. As our world becomes a closer one, Solga's call for us to “come together” (77) is not only felt but also mobilized in her little, but truly big, book.
