Pablo Alonso González's Cuban Cultural Heritage: A Rebel Past for a Revolutionary Nation is a welcome complement to the wealth of scholarly studies of recent years that investigate the use of history by the Cuban state government. Drawing on extensive archival research and interviews, this book explores the various ways in which the past has been framed in heritage sites, museums, monuments and other public symbols in Cuba. Alonso González proposes that the country's leaders have used heritage as a means of representing ideas of a Cuban national identity within a broader, post-colonial nation-building process. As many scholars have argued, this process has been at the heart of the revolutionary project since 1959, and is key to understanding its longevity. This meticulously researched book adds much to the discussion, largely through its analysis of previously overlooked material.
The book's five analytical chapters are structured chronologically, tracing developments in debates around the meaning and purpose of heritage in Cuba, as well as the practical application of heritage policies, from 1898 to 2014. Chapter 2 comprises an overview of the competing discourses and attendant practices concerning heritage creation and preservation in the republican era (1898–1959). It reveals that the proliferation of contradictory heritage narratives both reflected and shaped emerging forms of nationalism following independence from Spain. The heated controversy in the 1930s over the design of Havana's Monument to José Martí – eventually erected in 1958, in what would later become known as Plaza de la Revolución – epitomises the complexity of determining what and whom heritage is for, and of aiming to reconcile diverse conceptualisations of the nation within a single monument. The fascinating photographs and plans of heritage sites woven into this chapter and the rest of the book do an excellent job of bringing the discussion to life.
Chapter 3 examines how heritage, in its various forms, was used to reinforce the new master narrative promoted by the revolutionary leadership in the years 1959–73. Predicated on the concept of the ‘hundred years of struggle’, this narrative portrayed the Revolution as a continuation of the independence wars of the late 1800s, and equated the incumbent rebel leaders with the original independentistas. To this end, the commissioning of new monuments celebrating revolutionary heroism occurred simultaneously with the process of ‘resignification of key places of memory’ that were hangovers from the republican era (p. 85). This resignification was partly facilitated, Alonso González suggests, by the attachment of rituals to such sites, which allowed for the transformation of meaning without altering their material composition. The leadership was able to lay claim to the aforementioned Martí monument, for example, by rendering it the focal point of rallies that drew participants in their thousands.
This approach to heritage management was complicated, however, by the gradual rapprochement with the Soviet Union from the late 1960s onwards. Cuba was keen to prove its conformity to Soviet orthodoxy, most evident in the restructuring of its political and military systems in the 1970s. The cultural sphere was also subject to restrictions regarding artistic expression, particularly during the Quinquenio Gris (1971–6), when socialist realism became more prevalent. These changes have frequently been interpreted as signifying a wholesale adoption of the Soviet model. Much of contemporary scholarship on Cuba, however, paints a more nuanced picture of the 1970s, revealing the conflicting discourses and ideas that co-existed and shaped practices in such a way as to allow the very ‘Cubanness’ of the Revolution to be maintained. The realm of cultural heritage, contends Alonso González in Chapter 4, was no exception. He shows how debates around heritage in the 1970s meant that, although the socialist realist aesthetic was certainly adopted in new memorialisation projects, it was often a hybridised version designed to placate artists who rejected the Soviet style, and to retain certain symbols of the Revolution's master narrative. The master narrative itself, however, was re-moulded to accommodate Marxist-Leninist ideas, not the other way around.
Following the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, heritage took on even greater importance as a transmitter of rearticulated notions of ideology and national identity. In place of espousing the rhetoric of a utopian socialist future, the leadership now looked only to Cuba's history to reformulate the national narrative in a desperate attempt to bolster the legitimacy of the Revolution during an acute economic crisis. In Chapter 5, Alonso González explores the pivotal role played by heritage in extricating Marxist-Leninism from the master narrative, while at the same time it placed renewed emphasis on Martí as part of a broader resurgence of the ‘hundred years of struggle’ trope. As a case in point, he cites the example of Havana's Museo de la Revolución, which, during the 1990s, removed all references to the Soviet period, including Communist symbols and pictures of Marx, Engels and Lenin, a practice then rolled out to the country's network of municipal museums (p. 196).
Chapter 6 also covers the period 1990–2014, but shifts its attention to heritage in relation to tourism, highlighting the problems surrounding efforts to create heritage for both external and internal consumption. Specifically, Alonso González outlines how the Office of the City Historian of Havana (the OHCH, from its Spanish initials) has managed the difficult task of restoring Old Havana, the main draw for visitors to the capital. The OHCH enjoys some autonomy from the state through commercial activities and cooperation with external organisations, and is thus able to deviate slightly from the official historical narrative in its heritage practices. As Alonso González asserts, however, this relative freedom has not yet translated into efforts to portray the multi-layered composition of Cuban national identity, nor to engage in any meaningful way with the Spanish cultural legacy. The pressure to transform Old Havana into a magnet for much-needed hard currency has seen it become an aesthetically pleasing but ultimately ‘deterritorialized and symbolically neutral’ space (p. 235). In the final chapter, Alonso González concludes by arguing that it is heritage's capacity to reify symbols and narratives that makes it such a potent conveyor of nationalism, and therefore a tool for legitimising political power. This perspective is particularly relevant to Cuba, where he stresses that heritage must be understood as a ‘terrain of dissonance’ that resists easy categorisation (p. 284).
The book as a whole is ambitious in scope, covering not only a broad timeframe but also numerous complex debates, theoretical approaches and case studies. Consequently, there is insufficient space to explore fully some of the wider issues that it sets out to address, such as how Cuba's heritage practices compare with those of other socialist states. Nonetheless, it raises a number of insightful questions in this and other respects, opening the door for future scholarly study. Overall, this is a thoughtful and engaging book which makes a timely contribution to both Cuban and Cultural Heritage Studies.
