This chapter begins with an overview of homelessness in the United States and in Canada. It discusses certain definitions of homelessness in both countries. It provides statistics regarding homelessness in these jurisdictions, including fluctuations in these unhoused populations over time. It also explains how certain individuals and groups are overrepresented in the unhoused population and explores the risk factors associated with homelessness.
The later parts of this chapter discuss the emergence and decline of vagrancy law, and the rise to prominence of municipal ordinances (or bylaws) that regulate public property in the United States and in Canada. These ordinances govern basic human acts that are done on public property, such as sleeping, sheltering oneself, sitting, urinating, and defecating. Its concluding parts offer an overview of studies that demonstrate how laws that govern public property impact unhoused persons disparately.
1.1 Homelessness in Canada and the United States
1.1.1 Estimates of the Number of Unhoused Persons in the United States and Canada
The definition of homelessness varies between jurisdictions. The US Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) defines a person experiencing homelessness (or unhoused person, the terms are used interchangeably) as “a person who lacks a fixed, regular, and adequate nighttime residence.”Footnote 1 The definition encompasses unsheltered persons who live in places that are not intended for human habitation (for instance, who sleep on the street or in a tent in a public park) as well as individuals who stay in shelters, transitional housing, or safe havens (meaning facilities that provide temporary services to individuals with severe mental illness).Footnote 2
According to the 2022 Homeless Point in Time count compiled by the HUD, roughly 582,500 people experienced homelessness on a single night in the United States during that year.Footnote 3 The HUD notes that the unhoused population increased by less than 1 percent between 2020 and 2022.Footnote 4 The figure is, however, a significant decrease from the 2006 statistics, where it was estimated that roughly 759,100 people experienced homelessness on a given night in the United States in January 2006.Footnote 5
Certain US states have relatively high unhoused populations.Footnote 6 In 2022, the state of California’s unhoused population was approximately 171,521 persons (or 30 percent of the total number of unhoused persons in the United States), while the state of New York was estimated to have an unhoused population of roughly 74,178 persons (or 13 percent of the total number of unhoused persons in the United States).Footnote 7 Furthermore, approximately half of unsheltered persons in the United States in 2022 were in the state of California.Footnote 8 In 2022, roughly 67 percent of unhoused persons in California were unsheltered, whereas over 95 percent of unhoused persons in Vermont, Maine, and New York were sheltered.Footnote 9 Other states have high proportions of unsheltered people experiencing homelessness. In 2022, unsheltered persons constituted between 50 and 65 percent of the unhoused population in Mississippi, Hawaii, Oregon, Arizona, Tennessee, Georgia, and Washington.Footnote 10
The Government of Canada, for its part, employs the following definition of homelessness that is adapted from the Canadian Observatory on Homelessness (COH):
Homelessness is the situation of an individual or family who does not have a permanent address or residence; the living situation of an individual or family who does not have stable, permanent, appropriate housing, or the immediate prospect, means and ability of acquiring it. It is often the result of what are known as systemic or societal barriers, including a lack of affordable and appropriate housing, the individual/household’s financial, mental, cognitive, behavioural or physical challenges, and/or racism and discrimination.Footnote 11
The most recent national statistics compiled by the COH estimate that approximately 235,000 people experienced homelessness in Canada in 2016.Footnote 12 Furthermore, the COH estimates that roughly 35,000 individuals experienced homelessness on a given night during that year.Footnote 13 According to the 2018 Canadian Housing Survey (CHS), “3% of Canadians responsible for housing decisions within their household reported experiencing unsheltered homelessness at some point in their lives.”Footnote 14
The number of unhoused persons in the United States and Canada may be significantly higher due to the reality of hidden homelessness.Footnote 15 The term “hidden homelessness” refers to unhoused persons who may not be identified in official Point-In-Time counts because they are staying with friends or family, in their cars, in hospitals, or in other provisional accommodation.Footnote 16
Homelessness tends to be classified into three principal typologies: transitional, episodic, and chronic.Footnote 17 Transitional (or temporary) homelessness refers to one-off situations where individuals are unhoused for a short period of time as they transition to more stable forms of housing.Footnote 18 Episodic homelessness connotes that individuals are periodically unhoused and experience repeated short-term cycles of homelessness.Footnote 19 Chronic homelessness refers to individuals who experience long-term homelessness that lasts months or years.Footnote 20 Research demonstrates that most unhoused persons experience transitory or periodic homelessness rather than chronic homelessness.Footnote 21
1.1.2 The Overrepresentation of Certain Groups in the Unhoused Population
Certain individuals and groups are more likely to experience homelessness compared to the general population. Indigenous persons are overrepresented in the Canadian unhoused population,Footnote 22 and Native Americans are overrepresented in the US unhoused population.Footnote 23 For instance, Indigenous persons represented 2.5 percent of the city of Toronto’s population in 2021 but comprised 15 percent of the total number of unhoused persons in the city.Footnote 24 Similarly, Indigenous persons represented approximately 0.6 percent of Montreal’s population in 2018 yet comprised roughly 16 percent of the total number of unhoused persons.Footnote 25
Racialized persons – meaning individuals who are nonwhite and non-Indigenous – are also overrepresented in the US and Canadian unhoused population.Footnote 26 Racialized persons comprised roughly 23 percent of Canada’s population in 2016 yet represented 28.2 percent of individuals who experienced homelessness within the country.Footnote 27 In the city of Toronto in 2021, nearly 60 percent of people experiencing homelessness identified as racialized persons, 31 percent of whom identified as Black persons.Footnote 28 In the United States in 2022, Black persons represented 12 percent of the country’s population yet made up 37 percent of the total number of unhoused persons.Footnote 29
Individuals who identify as members of the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer (LGBTQ) community are more likely to experience homelessness compared to individuals who do not.Footnote 30 Transgender persons face especially high rates of homelessness. Some studies estimate that transgender adults constituted roughly 0.39 percent of the US population in 2016.Footnote 31 Yet the 2015 US Transgender Survey indicates that 30 percent of transgender persons reported that they experienced homelessness at some point of their lives, while 12 percent experienced homelessness in the year prior to the survey.Footnote 32
Survivors of domestic violence (DV) are also overrepresented in the unhoused population.Footnote 33 Domestic violence is an important cause of homelessness for women.Footnote 34 Dessie Lee Clark, Leila Wood, and Cris Sullivan note that “One in four homeless women have cited DV as being a major contributor to their current homelessness” and “DV survivors are four times more likely than other women to experience housing instability.”Footnote 35 Unhoused women are disproportionately subject to physical and sexual violence compared to women with access to housing.Footnote 36 Moreover, some studies demonstrate that women who experience homelessness are more likely to be victims of violence compared to unhoused men.Footnote 37
Veterans, for their part, are also overrepresented in the unhoused population.Footnote 38 The HUD reports that in 2022, roughly 20 per 10,000 veterans experienced homelessness compared to 18 per 10,000 civilians.Footnote 39 The number of unhoused veterans in the United States has continued to decline steadily since 2010.Footnote 40 While approximately 74,087 veterans experienced homelessness in 2010, roughly 33,129 veterans were unhoused in 2022.Footnote 41
Certain youth populations are overrepresented in the total number of unhoused persons. In Canada, Indigenous youth are more likely to experience homelessness than non-Indigenous youth.Footnote 42 In the United States, Black youth experience higher rates of homelessness compared to white persons and compared to members of other racialized communities.Footnote 43 Young persons who self-identify as members of the LGBTQ community are also more likely to experience homelessness than the general youth population.Footnote 44 As John Ecker, Tim Aubry, and John Sylvestre note, studies suggest that between 15–30 percent of unhoused youth identify as members of the LGBTQ community.Footnote 45
1.1.3 Risk Factors and Consequences Associated with Homelessness
The risk factors associated with homelessness are generally divided into two categories, both of which can overlap and are not mutually exclusive: individual (or micro) and structural (or macro).Footnote 46 Individual risk factors include mental illness, substance use disorder, poverty, self-identification as a member of the LGBTQ community, prior experience in foster care, having a criminal record, and a history of physical and/or sexual violence.Footnote 47 Various studies highlight how certain individual risk factors are associated with homelessness. For instance, individuals who suffer from mental illness or substance use disorder are overrepresented in the unhoused population.Footnote 48 Some studies suggest that unhoused persons are roughly ten times more likely to have an alcohol-related or drug-related substance use disorder compared to the general population.Footnote 49 Other research notes that individuals who have suffered physical or sexual violence are more likely to experience homelessness compared to individuals who have not.Footnote 50 Placement in foster care is also a risk factor associated with an increased likelihood of homelessness, especially at the time when individuals transition out of foster care.Footnote 51
Structural risk factors associated with homelessness, for their part, include increased cost of living, lack of access to affordable housing, unemployment, and housing and employment discrimination, amongst others.Footnote 52 Scholars note that lack of access to affordable housing is one of the principal causes of homelessness – one that partly explains regional variations in the per capita homelessness rate between cities.Footnote 53 Furthermore, as Thomas Byrne and colleagues observe, various studies indicate that high costs of rent and low vacancy rates are associated with a higher rate of homelessness in cities.Footnote 54 Housing discrimination, unemployment, and criminal justice system involvement also contribute to homelessness.Footnote 55 Racialized participants of interview studies report that they were subject to racial discrimination in these areas, and moreover, that they experienced discrimination when using homelessness-related services.Footnote 56
Unhoused persons face worse health disparities and outcomes compared to individuals with access to housing.Footnote 57 The mortality rate for people experiencing homelessness is roughly three to four times higher than the general population.Footnote 58 Unhoused persons have high rates of chronic pain.Footnote 59 They also suffer from high rates of short-term and long-term health problems.Footnote 60 Unhoused persons are also more likely to contract certain infectious diseases, such as tuberculosis.Footnote 61 Compared to the general population, people experiencing homelessness tend to have a lower life expectancy and worse quality of life.Footnote 62 They are also disproportionately likely to experience physical and sexual violence.Footnote 63 Unhoused youth faced particularly adverse health outcomes. Elise Roy and colleagues’ research compared the mortality rates of unhoused youth in Montreal with those of the general youth population.Footnote 64 Their study suggests that the mortality rates for unhoused youth was eleven times higher than the general youth population.Footnote 65
1.2 The Rise and Fall of Vagrancy Law
Historically, vagrancy laws regulated people experiencing homelessness.Footnote 66 These laws are traced back to England’s Statute of Labourers 1351.Footnote 67 The Statute was passed after the bubonic plague swept through the country and killed a significant portion of the country’s working population.Footnote 68 This led to severe labor shortages, especially in agriculture and manual labor.Footnote 69 As feudalism broke down and the working class experienced new freedom and possibilities, people wandered the country seeking better employment and higher wages.Footnote 70 As a response to that phenomenon, the Statute of Labourers was passed in 1351, primarily for economic reasons.Footnote 71 The Statute fixed wages, regulated begging, and prevented workers from roaming throughout the country to seek better remuneration.Footnote 72
The scope of vagrancy law shifted towards the end of the fifteenth century and beginning of the sixteenth century. Vagrancy statutes became “the criminal aspect of the poor laws.”Footnote 73 Since these laws were vague, the State had broad discretion to control different types of conduct, and regulate individuals and groups that were considered to be socially undesirable.Footnote 74 Throughout history, vagrancy laws regulated labor, migration, immigration, poverty, morality, sexuality, prostitution, and criminality.Footnote 75 These laws were thus employed as a form of social control.Footnote 76 Vagrancy statutes classified vagrants into different categories – rogues, vagabonds, and idle and disorderly persons – based on their way of life, occupation, or conduct.Footnote 77 These statutes regulated unhoused persons’ condition and need-alleviating conduct. For instance, vagrancy laws prohibited conduct related to sleeping, wandering, loitering, and being unemployed.Footnote 78
Vagrancy statutes were imported from English law into the United States and Canada and prohibited a variety of acts. In the 1950s, every American state had its own vagrancy statutes.Footnote 79 State laws criminalized acts such as sleeping on public property without permission, loitering, and wandering at night without providing an adequate account of oneself.Footnote 80 Some US courts defined a common law vagrant as an idle person who wandered without visible means of support and refused to work when able.Footnote 81 In Canada, vagrancy statutes were already in force prior to Confederation in 1867.Footnote 82 Before the 1930s, it was a criminal offense in Canada to wander or lodge on public property without providing an adequate account of oneself.Footnote 83 It was also a crime for a person to be unemployed while lacking the visible means to support themselves.Footnote 84
Vagrancy laws declined in the United States following the 1972 US Supreme Court decision Papachristou v. City of Jacksonville.Footnote 85 In Papachristou, several defendants challenged the constitutionality of a Jacksonville vagrancy ordinance that prohibited a litany of acts associated with incivility, immorality, or disorder.Footnote 86 The ordinance proscribed such a sweeping array of conduct that individuals would eventually violate it.Footnote 87 The ordinance stated:
Rogues and vagabonds, or dissolute persons who go about begging, common gamblers, persons who use juggling or unlawful games or plays, common drunkards, common night walkers, thieves, pilferers or pickpockets, traders in stolen property, lewd, wanton and lascivious persons, keepers of gambling places, common railers and brawlers, persons wandering or strolling around from place to place without any lawful purpose or object, habitual loafers, disorderly persons, persons neglecting all lawful business and habitually spending their time by frequenting houses of ill fame, gaming houses, or places where alcoholic beverages are sold or served, persons able to work but habitually living upon the earnings of their wives or minor children shall be deemed vagrants and, upon conviction in the Municipal Court shall be punished as provided for Class D offenses.Footnote 88
The Court unanimously struck down the Jacksonville vagrancy ordinance on the grounds that it was void for vagueness.Footnote 89 The law failed to provide fair warning as to which conduct was illegal and conferred too much discretion to police officers.Footnote 90 The judges were concerned that the law prohibited harmless and innocent acts: going for a walk, relaxing in a park, or simply doing nothing at all.Footnote 91 They worried that the law disproportionately impacted impecunious persons and other marginalized individuals.Footnote 92 The statute placed tremendous power in the hands of law enforcement, who decided whether individuals received full respect for their social condition and lifestyle.Footnote 93
The void for vagueness doctrine was later used to strike down loitering laws. The 1983 US Supreme Court decision Kolender v. Lawson is an example.Footnote 94 In Kolender, the impugned law required individuals who wander or loiter to give an account of themselves and provide identification to police officers.Footnote 95 The Court reasoned that the law failed to adequately inform individuals about how they could comply with the law, and encouraged arbitrary enforcement by the police.Footnote 96 Officers had the authority to interpret terms such as wandering and loitering, and to assess the reliability of an individual’s identification.Footnote 97 For similar reasons, in the 1999 decision Chicago v. Morales, the US Supreme Court decided that a law was unconstitutionally vague because it criminalized gang members who remained “in any one place with no apparent purpose.”Footnote 98
1.3 The Broken Windows Theory and Municipal Ordinances
1.3.1 The Broken Windows Theory
Municipal ordinances rose to prominence following the decline of vagrancy laws.Footnote 99 The increased enforcement of these ordinances is typically associated with the Broken Windows Theory advanced by James Wilson and George Kelling.Footnote 100 Their theory built on an earlier study conducted by the psychologist Philip Zimbardo.Footnote 101 As part of his experiment, Zimbardo placed a car with its hood up in the Bronx in New York, and a similar car in Palo Alto, California.Footnote 102 The car in the Bronx was burglarized within ten minutes of its abandonment.Footnote 103 The other components of the car were stolen within twenty-four hours.Footnote 104 The rest of the car was then vandalized and destroyed.Footnote 105 The car in Palo Alto, on the other hand, sat undamaged for a week until Zimbardo broke one of its windows.Footnote 106 It was then destroyed and flipped upside down within the span of several hours.Footnote 107 Wilson and Kelling posited that the first broken window triggered a cascade of increasingly serious property offenses involving the car.Footnote 108
According to Wilson and Kelling, untended low-level incivilities – much like a broken window – invite more serious crimes.Footnote 109 Such incivilities signal breakdowns of social control within the community.Footnote 110 Individuals may change their behavior as a response to these signals.Footnote 111 They may fear that they will become victims of crime and avoid public spaces.Footnote 112 Eventually, they may not call the police when they witness crimes or are victimized because they believe that law enforcement is ineffective.Footnote 113 Criminals, for their part, will commit more crimes because signs of incivility telegraph that the police do not enforce the law.Footnote 114 And criminals prefer to commit crimes in neighborhoods where their chances of being caught are lower rather than higher.Footnote 115 Like a self-fulfilling prophecy, the appearance of crime and disorder was said to result in greater crime and disorder.Footnote 116
Wilson and Kelling explained that, historically, vagrancy laws controlled public property’s use and helped maintain order in public spaces.Footnote 117 They argued that vagrancy statutes provided the police with crucial legal tools to control crime and incivilities when other informal methods of social control failed.Footnote 118 To be clear, Wilson and Kelling also recognized that vagrancy statutes raised legitimate concerns about discriminatory enforcement practices.Footnote 119 They observed that vagrancy was a charge “with scarcely any legal meaning.”Footnote 120 When they considered how best to prevent discriminatory enforcement, they argued that better police selection, training, and supervision would be effective, even though they conceded that those solutions were not satisfactory.Footnote 121 Although they recognized how vagrancy laws impact civil liberties, they posited that many discounted the criminogenic effects of compounding incivilities over time.Footnote 122
The Broken Windows Theory signaled a major shift in policing and in the regulation of public property.Footnote 123 US cities enacted and enforced narrowly tailored municipal ordinances that prohibited much of what vagrancy law once proscribed.Footnote 124 Some Canadian cities, such as Montreal, did not enact new ordinances, but changed the classification of certain spaces to impose curfews more easily.Footnote 125 Unlike vagrancy laws, municipal ordinances generally withstood vagueness challenges because they were narrow and precise.Footnote 126 These ordinances prohibited a wide range of conduct, such as panhandling, public urination or defecation, sleeping on public property, urban camping, sitting or lying down on streets or sidewalks, littering, graffiti, excessive noise, and more.Footnote 127
Wilson and Kelling’s theory ushered in a new era of policing.Footnote 128 When Rudy Giuliani became New York City’s mayor in 1994, the city adopted a zero-tolerance enforcement policy for low-level incivilities.Footnote 129 The city’s crime rate dropped a reported 40 percent in the four years after the strategy was adopted.Footnote 130 Other US cities – such as Chicago, Los Angeles, and San Francisco – also adopted a Broken Windows policing strategy.Footnote 131 Some Canadian cities adopted a similar approach.Footnote 132
The Broken Windows Theory has been criticized heavily on various grounds.Footnote 133 First, scholars argue that Broken Windows policing did not cause crime rates to decrease.Footnote 134 Some observe that other factors were responsible for lower crime rates during the era of Broken Windows policing, such as the decline of crack cocaine’s popularity, increased police surveillance, favorable economic conditions, and the increased incarceration of violent offenders.Footnote 135 Second, some contend that the crime rate in New York City – the most notable example of Broken Windows policing – was already in decline before the strategy was implemented.Footnote 136 Third, as John Eck and Edward McGuire remark, crime rates dropped in cities that did not adopt Broken Windows policing strategies, such as Boston and San Diego.Footnote 137 Fourth, Broken Windows policing disproportionately impacted racialized and socioeconomically disadvantaged persons, and resulted in increased surveillance, discrimination, and harassment.Footnote 138 Broken Windows policing imposes important costs on individuals and communities. Proactive police encounters can be humiliating and traumatizing.Footnote 139 They may result in physical or psychological harm, violate privacy, and demean human dignity.Footnote 140 Aggressive policing tactics can also decrease individuals’ trust in law enforcement.Footnote 141 The police require individuals’ cooperation to prevent and solve crimes.Footnote 142 However, individuals who distrust the police may be reluctant to report crimes, collaborate with law enforcement, or testify in trials.Footnote 143
1.3.2 An Overview of Municipal Ordinances
Today, municipal ordinances are ubiquitous in US and Canadian cities.Footnote 144 Some of these ordinances govern basic human acts that everyone must do – such as sleeping, urinating, defecating, and sitting – and that take place on public property.Footnote 145 Certain ordinances categorically prohibit certain need-alleviating acts on public property, such as laws that proscribe public urination and defecation.Footnote 146 Cities such as Dallas, Texas, Atlantic City, and New Jersey prohibit sleeping on public property, including in parks, parking lots, streets, alleys, and on sidewalks.Footnote 147
Other municipal ordinances do not comprehensively prohibit certain acts, but instead impose time, place, and manner restrictions.Footnote 148 Some cities – such as Virginia Beach – prohibit people from sleeping on public property between specific hours.Footnote 149 A San Francisco ordinance proscribes sitting or lying on the city’s streets or sidewalks.Footnote 150 A Toronto bylaw prohibits individuals from lying down on any bench, seat, or floor on property owned by the Toronto Transportation Commission, such as subway and bus stations.Footnote 151
Since 2006, the National Homelessness Law Center (or NHLC) – formerly the National Law Center on Homelessness and Poverty – tracks and analyzes municipal ordinances in 187 American cities.Footnote 152 Their research details the extent to which cities completely or partially ban certain need-alleviating conduct. According to the NHLC’s most recent report on the criminalization of homelessness published in 2019, roughly 21 percent of the American cities they surveyed imposed citywide bans against sleeping on public property, while 37 percent of those cities imposed citywide bans against camping on public property.Footnote 153 The NHLC notes that citywide bans against sleeping on public property increased by roughly 50 percent since 2006, while citywide bans against camping on public property increased by approximately 92 percent since 2006.Footnote 154
With respect to loitering offenses, this same report states that roughly 35 percent of cities they track imposed citywide bans on “loitering, loafing, and/or vagrancy,” whereas approximately 60 percent banned those acts in specific public places.Footnote 155 The NHLC further notes that the number of municipal ordinances that imposed citywide bans on loitering increased by roughly 103 percent since 2006, and that there was a 28 percent increase in ordinances that prohibited loitering in certain public spaces.Footnote 156 These figures represent an increase since the NHLC’s previous annual report in 2016.Footnote 157
Studies demonstrate how municipal ordinances disproportionately impact people experiencing homelessness. A survey study – which combined the results of a 2013 statewide Colorado study and a 2014 local Denver study – explored the extent to which unhoused persons were contacted, cited, or arrested by the police for municipal ordinances.Footnote 158 The study comprised a total of roughly 950 unhoused persons who participated in the statewide and local surveys.Footnote 159 Results indicated that roughly 70 percent of respondents were contacted, cited, or arrested for sleeping in public, 64 percent were subject to such encounters for sitting or lying down on public property, and 50 percent were subject to such encounters for loitering.Footnote 160 Approximately 70 percent of respondents reported that they were ticketed for violating a municipal ordinance, while 36 percent reported that they were incarcerated for doing so.Footnote 161 Roughly 60 percent of respondents who were ticketed were subsequently jailed because they could not pay their fine or failed to appear in court.Footnote 162
A 2015 study in San Francisco surveyed 351 unhoused respondents and analyzed court data regarding municipal ordinance citations.Footnote 163 Although the city issued over 27,000 citations that year, 14,000 of those citations involved laws that govern public property and homelessness.Footnote 164 Approximately 11,900 of the 14,000 citations were issued for sleeping or sitting on public property, unlawful lodging, or obstructing the sidewalk.Footnote 165 Roughly 22 percent of respondents received five or more citations.Footnote 166
Some scholars have conducted empirical studies that examine the rates at which unhoused persons receive municipal ordinance citations. Researchers Céline Bellot and Marie-Eve Sylvestre scrutinized municipal court data from the years 1994–2010 in the city of Montreal.Footnote 167 Their study examined how municipal ordinances and transportation bylaws were enforced against unhoused persons during those years.Footnote 168 Their research showed that the number of fines issued per year in Montreal increased by six-and-a-half times between 1994 and 2010, from 1,054 to 6,562.Footnote 169 Of the total number of citations, unhoused persons were most commonly fined for using public transport without payment (33.7 percent), public intoxication (31.5 percent), consuming alcohol on public property (29.6 percent), sleeping or lying down in a subway station or train (23.3 percent), smoking inside transportation authority facilities (14.6 percent), and loitering (11.8 percent).Footnote 170 Their study also assessed the number of fines issued to each unhoused person within their study between 2006 and 2010.Footnote 171 Although 42.6 percent of unhoused persons received only one fine during that period, 30.6 percent received between two and five fines, while 12 percent received between ten and twenty-five fines.Footnote 172 Approximately 6 percent of unhoused persons in the study received more than twenty-five fines during that period.Footnote 173
1.4 Conclusion
This chapter provided a historical overview of vagrancy law and the rise to prominence of municipal ordinances in Canada and in the United States. It offered examples of ordinances that are in force within these jurisdictions. Its concluding parts described the prevalence of homelessness in these countries, the personal and structural factors that contribute to it, and certain characteristics that are more common amongst unhoused persons compared to the general population. The next chapter explains how US and Canadian constitutional law have approached homelessness and laws that govern public property. It highlights how constitutional safeguards have largely failed to protect unhoused persons against laws that govern public property and their associated consequences.
