Although the literature on science and religion is vast, the part concerned with developments after the seventeenth century has tended to concentrate on the Protestant churches. Specific reactions to Darwinism have been recorded for Anglicans, evangelicals and Presbyterians but rarely for the Catholic Church. Determining the views of a vast bureaucracy such as the Church on any topic which was not the subject of an official declaration presents considerable difficulties. According to Mariano Artigas, Thomas F. Glick and Rafael Martínez, in the case of evolution the Church appears to have deliberately avoided presenting a clear opinion so as to prevent a second ‘Galileo affair’. Instead, individual authors were dealt with as their books appeared before the Congregation of the Index. The private deliberations of the Congregation were sealed in the Vatican archives and very few books were actually placed on the Index of Prohibited Books. Instead, the authors retracted or withdrew books from circulation in a manner that often remained unknown even to contemporary Catholic scholars and evolutionists.
Negotiating Darwin is not really about Darwin at all, as the versions of evolutionism which it deals with were not exclusively based on natural selection, nor was the Origin of Species itself ever explicitly condemned. However, the new book does provide two valuable services to historians of science. First, it gives a picture of debates surrounding evolution in Italy, Spain and France currently lacking in the English-language literature. Second, it provides a detailed study of the inner workings of the Vatican as it reacted to scientific ideas in the late nineteenth century. What emerges is an image of the Church quite contrary to that presented by Protestant writers and men of science at the time: cautious rather than reactionary, and motivated in its decisions not by any specific views on science, but frequently by internal politics.
The opening of the archives of the Congregation of the Index and the Holy Office has allowed the authors unprecedented insight into the actions of the Church regarding evolutionary tracts. An introductory chapter explaining the inner workings of the Vatican's bureaucracy will be helpful to any historian who wishes to pursue research on the Church and science. The Congregation of the Index has specific responsibility for recommending whether or not to add a work to the Index of Prohibited Books. The majority of Negotiating Darwin describes the process undergone by the Congregation in reference to six different authors. In only one case did the book end up on the Index. Probably the best known of the authors considered is St George Jackson Mivart, whose work engaged directly with Darwinians in Britain. The other five chapters look at Raffaello Caverni, Dalmace Leroy, John A. Zahm, Geremia Bonomelli and John C. Hedley. These five were all priests, while Mivart was simply a layman. Interestingly, Mivart's books on evolution were never condemned; it was his foray into biblical criticism which excited the attention of the Index. Artigas, Glick and Martínez examine the letters condemning the suspect books, the subsequent reports of ‘referees’ commissioned by the Index and the resultant decision.
Caverni, Leroy and Bonomelli are unlikely to be familiar names to most readers. Perhaps the most intriguing revelation of this book is the level of engagement with Darwinian theory that is evident among priest–scientists and priest–philosophers in southern Europe during the late nineteenth century. The engagement of these individuals with European-wide scientific trends contrasts with the generally insular viewpoint of their condemners; Italian editions attracted condemnation, although previous editions existed in other languages. Not surprisingly, the biggest problem for the Catholic evolutionist was the ancestry of man. Each of the works discussed here grappled with how to make exceptions for man and how to allow for an eternal soul given by God. Several were willing to go so far as to allow for the complete evolution of man's body from ape-like ancestors, whereas others found ways to exclude man from the picture.
Several problems remain unresolved for me after reading this book. The authors point out that the six cases which they deal with all occur around the close of the nineteenth century but resist any explanation, other than that the Congregation of the Index dealt with books as they were condemned by members of the Church. While this may be true, it seems strange not to discuss the existing scholarship on the ‘eclipse of Darwinism’, which overlaps in time. Occasionally, those who condemned the books insisted that science was on their side; it would be worthwhile to consider how these condemnations reflected views beyond those of Church officials, including members of the scientific community. The authors are also keen to point out that the views of the Jesuit journal La Civiltà Cattolica have erroneously been taken to represent the views of the Catholic Church. This conflation was in fact propagated by the journal itself, which published articles hinting at the condemnation of evolution at the highest levels in Rome. However, it also seems possible that the hierarchy was having its cake and eating it too. Each edition of the journal was scrutinized within the Vatican and the editor received by the Pope in advance of publication. If the journal was presenting the Holy See as being opposed to evolution, this was, presumably, an image of which the Pope approved, with the aim of discouraging faithful Catholics from embracing evolutionism. On the other hand, the absence of an official written condemnation of evolution allowed the Church to ‘save face’ if scientific evidence for evolution should become overwhelming.
Negotiating Darwin currently offers the only detailed picture based on the Vatican archive of the actions of the Catholic Church towards authors of evolutionary tracts. Although the complex philosophical arguments espoused in an effort to relate evolution to the writings of the Church Fathers are occasionally difficult to follow, the careful descriptions of each of the condemned books give an account of Catholic perspectives rarely found in the historiography of evolution. This book should be read by anyone interested in the reception of Darwinism or the relationship between science and religion.
