In What Adolescents Ought to Know: Sexual Health Texts in Early Twentieth-Century America, Jennifer Burek Pierce—an assistant professor of library and information science at the University of Iowa—traces a Progressive Era “transnational print culture dedicated to disseminating sexual health information for adolescent readers” (3). More specifically, she identifies and analyzes a large catalog of early twentieth-century hygiene literature targeting young adults, as well as the organizational papers and behind-the-scenes correspondence that went into bringing these publications to a variety of audiences. Pierce's attention to the dissemination, circulation, and replication of these primary texts lends considerable force to her claims, the most central of which highlights the roles that emerging ideas about literacy and adolescence played in the establishment of Progressive Era efforts to create a level of public sexual health. What makes Pierce's work a particularly valuable addition to the burgeoning scholarship on the early-twentieth-century social hygiene movement is her analysis of the international origins of the movement in light of the diverse technical and lay discourses that influenced the “information dissemination” process that is her focus (4).
Pierce's work is grounded in the argument that the writings of French physician Alfred Fournier, founder of the French Society for Sanitary and Moral Prophylaxis, were a catalyst for the widespread emergence of sexual health texts targeting lay readers directly. Until this time, the vast majority of texts discussing sexual health issues were aimed at professional or elite audiences, but Fournier's arguments in favor of providing young adults in particular with information about reproduction and venereal diseases gained traction when combined with turn-of-the-century increases in literacy rates and advances in printing technology. With the translation of Fournier's publications into over nine languages and distribution throughout at least fourteen countries, Pierce argues that “the first mass readership of sexual and reproductive health information” emerged, as did “a continuing series of international conversations among physicians and reformers about health, sexuality, and adolescence” (36).
An early vehicle for informing lay audiences about the dangers of venereal diseases left untreated was the French play Les avariés. Rather than engaging in a close analysis of the play's content, Pierce details the play's many different iterations as it was translated into several languages and performed throughout Europe and the United States. The play ultimately served as the basis for novels distributed and produced by the Connecticut Society of Social Hygiene, and the novel Damaged Goods by the social reformer Upton Sinclair. Pierce claims that the last iteration, Sinclair's novel, highlighted literacy as both the potential inspiration for sexual vice and as an important tool for fighting against public health problems, thereby evincing the perceived power of print in the emerging direct-to-consumer print culture.
In the United States, a market for sexual health texts targeting adolescents began to emerge as widespread attention was generated by the communications of individuals such as Prince A. Morrow, founder of the American Society for Sanitary and Moral Prophylaxis, and John N. Hurty, founder of the Indiana Society for Social Hygiene and president of the American Public Health Association in 1912. Much has been written about Morrow's work to build a social hygiene movement in the United States, but considerably less has been said about Hurty, who shared with Morrow both a commitment to eugenic ideology and a belief in the educational and preventative value of sexual-health texts targeting adolescents. Drawing from Hurty's professional correspondence and other primary sources discussing his 1908 pamphlet Social Hygiene vs. the Sexual Plague, Pierce demonstrates that there was a huge demand for sexual-health literature targeting young people, not only in Indiana and throughout the United States but also internationally. She also analyzes Hurty's innovative arguments concerning the potential economic gains in preventing the transmission of venereal diseases via sexual-health texts, suggesting in the last few chapters of her book that discourse about social hygiene became increasingly likely to include economic appeals in the years that followed.
Pierce offers up the Lutheran pastor and publisher Sylvanus Stall's Self and Sex series as an example of the role that economics came to play in the creation and distribution of Progressive Era social-hygiene texts. Combining medically accepted facts with what Pierce describes as a conservative, moralistic world view, Stall published relatively lengthy books about sexual health that were segmented according to readers’ gender and age. The major contribution in this chapter is not Pierce's evaluation of the books’ content—as similar texts from this time period have been widely discussed—but in her analysis of Stall's decisions surrounding and framing of the production of these texts. Ultimately, Stall's systematic marketing techniques, which included door-to-door sales, bookstore window displays, and international missionary outreach efforts, were touted in his The Successful Selling of the Sex and Life Series. Coupled with his appeals to divinely inspired technological progress, Pierce demonstrates that Stall's attention to the business of selling social hygiene resulted in consistent and widespread sales.
The book concludes with an exploration of post-Stall hygiene texts whose authors—particularly Winfield Scott Hall—worked to capitalize on the international market created by Stall. Throughout the book, Pierce poses compelling questions about why these early social hygiene texts were created and shared. Although her focus on information delivery may not sit well with communication and history scholars invested in multilateral models of discourse, ultimately these scholars will find that her orientation toward literary replication makes this framing a bit less problematic. Pierce's theoretical conclusions return to Fournier and his attempts to ignite what Pierce—drawing from Thomas Kuhn—describes as a social scientific revolution concerning public understandings of venereal disease. Pierce's book identifies this revolution, delineates how it came to be, and thereby offers new insight into how many early-twentieth-century adolescents were encouraged to obtain and read social hygiene texts in an age of Comstockian censorship.
