“Was there ever a time in history when religious differences were not essential to an understanding of the daily lives of the individuals and groups who lived in the Iberian Peninsula?” asks Ana Echevarría in this book's introduction. Although many historians would argue that such interfaith harmony did not exist after the 13th century, Echevarría believes that she has found evidence of it 200 years later, among the so-called “Moorish knights” who served as the private guard for the kings of Castile. Her book describes and analyzes the creation, functions, and dissolution of this seemingly anomalous group.
Echevarría opens with a chapter introducing the three main players in her story: the Castilian Christians, the Castilian Muslims (Mudejars), and the Granadans. This chapter traces political developments in 15th-century Spain, including the complex alliances that led to the rise and fall of ten different sultans in Granada during the period coinciding with the reigns of two kings (Juan II and Enrique IV) in Castile. Chapter 1 also argues that a relatively generous Castilian policy toward the Mudejars, combined with turmoil and uncertainty in Granada, contributed to the defection of a steady stream of Muslim knights to Castile from 1410 to 1467.
In Chapter 2, Echevarría discusses conditions along the frontier between Granada and Castile, including the nature of frontier warfare, the use of truces, vassal relationships between Castilian kings and Granadan sultans, and the roles played by frontier nobility and by Muslims who switched sides to join the Castilians during sieges or who otherwise assisted in the Castilian conquest of Granadan fortresses. The latter had usually converted to Christianity and were recruited into military service for Castile. It was this process that led to the initial establishment of the Moorish guard.
How did the Moorish knights actually function in the Castilian army? In Chapter 3, Echevarría addresses this subject by perusing royal allowances and other primary sources that shed light on the conditions of the Moors who served in the king's guard. These sources reveal such information as the various ranks of and duties undertaken by these Moors, the types of militias in which they functioned, the approximate numbers in the guard, their roles on the battlefield, the amounts they were paid in money and goods, their ages and the length of time they served, the ceremonies through which they were initiated into the king's guard, and even the types of clothes they wore. It was apparently common practice, for instance, for the knights to dress in traditional Moorish clothes, even when serving the Castilian monarch.
However, the majority of the Moors who entered the king's service as Muslims eventually abandoned their original faith, so much so that the author states, “the Moorish guard served as a vehicle for the conversion of Muslims to Christianity” (p. 138). In Chapter 4, Echevarría provides short sketches of several families of Moorish knights that converted to Christianity during their period of service, as well as some that chose to remain Muslim. Whether they converted or not, all of these knights served as intermediaries between Christian and Muslim societies as well as between the kingdoms of Castile, Aragón, and Granada. The author demonstrates the ease with which these men, who straddled two different religious traditions, moved between societies.
The institution of the Moorish guard was not to last, however. In Chapter 5, Echevarría describes events leading up to the civil war between King Enrique IV and his brother Alfonso from 1465 to 1468. Alfonso's claims were backed by the league of nobles, who were dissatisfied with Enrique's rule. In January 1465, the league attempted to forcibly shut down the Moorish guard, ordering that all Jews and Muslims associated with the court be expelled from Castile within fifty days. Echevarría points out that this action was politically, not religiously, motivated because most of the Moorish guard had already converted to Christianity. The king's enemies wished to disband a group of his most loyal supporters, and they used religion as an excuse to do so. Enrique was ultimately victorious but paid a price in the disbanding of the Moorish guard unit during the war.
Although the Moorish guard ended only half a century after it was formed, Echevarría sees this unit as a late example of religious coexistence in Spain. She additionally argues that the guard served as an effective vehicle for converting a highly skilled warrior elite from Islam to Christianity, with the result that the descendants of the Moorish guard could successfully integrate into Christian society. This is in stark contrast to the large-scale failure of the forced conversions of Muslims following the 1502 edict outlawing Islam in Castile, including the newly conquered region of Granada. The sorry legacy that followed this edict, including inquisition, rebellion, persecution, the underground practice of Islam, and ultimately the expulsion of the Moriscos, is well known. In her conclusion, Echevarría discusses reasons for why the conversions of the Moorish knights in her case study had results different from those of the forced conversions that took place after the 1502 edict.
Echevarría's study is well documented, including footnotes, a bibliography, and an index that are extensive. The author's scholarship is sound and her argument persuasive. The book represents a venture into an area that has not previously been well studied. It is filled with information, including 117 pages of documentary appendix that will be of great interest to the specialist. However, some features make it difficult reading for the nonspecialist. For example, many Spanish terms are used for military ranks and formations, monetary denominations, and the like. They are usually defined the first time they appear, but a short glossary of the most frequently used terms would have improved the book's accessibility to the generalist. The book is of use to anyone interested in Spain during the 15th and 16th centuries, conversion from Islam to Christianity, and the Morisco and converso problems.
