Revising the mythologized history of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) has become a global trend in the field of China studies. China specialists in Japan have been excavating unknown material hidden in archives all over the world like miners looking for gold. This book written by Yoshihiro Ishikawa, a Professor at Kyoto University and a well-known archival researcher in Japan, takes us back to the early twentieth century and reveals the backstage of the CCP's formation.
Ishikawa's discussion reaches out to some of the most unknown figures, organizations, meetings, and documents, which have been buried behind the orthodox narration of modern Chinese history. By carefully digging out minor pieces of history from materials written in a variety of languages (Chinese, Russian, Japanese, English) and using them to fill in the gaps of the existing puzzle, Ishikawa has recreated the history of the CCP's formation in extreme detail. He has devoted 503 pages to deal just with the events, which took place between 1919 and 1921!
It is a common understanding that the Soviet Union along with the Comintern were the main conductors in the formation of a Communist Party in the Republic of China, where industrial capitalism and urbanization had just taken off. But any conductor needs musicians to form an orchestra. In this case, the Russians needed Chinese intellectuals who nurtured a passion for Marxism.
How were such intellectuals created? This is one of the main questions Ishikawa's book deals with in great detail. Marxism started to flourish in Chinese newspapers and magazines during the May Fourth Movement, which started in 1919. The Russian Revolution of 1917 definitely gave spark to this boom. According to Ishikawa, however, the main provider of Marxist materials during this period was not Russia as many might expect, but actually Japan.
The revival of studies on Marxism in Japan during the Taisho Democracy Movement (1910s−1920s) had a huge impact on many Chinese intellectuals who were studying in Japan at that time. It was mainly these Chinese intellectuals, who constantly travelled in and out of Japan, who provided most of the material dealing with Marxism, which then spread rapidly throughout China during the May Fourth Movement.
Quite a few of the founding fathers of the CCP, such as Chen Duxiu, Li Dazhao, Li Hanjun, Li Da, Zhou Fohai, and Dong Biwu had studied in Japan, so it was quite natural that they deepened their understanding of Marxism through Marxist literature coming out of Japan. The influence of Hajime Kawakami's work on Li Dazhao's thinking, is one example that Ishikawa extracts from the range of material written in Japanese and Chinese. Ishikawa also discovers that a figure named Chen Puxian, who graduated from Waseda University and worked closely with Li Dazhao as a journalist, was one of the pioneers that introduced Japanese Marxist thinking to China.
This introduction of Marxism via Japan was crucial for the early development of the Marxist movement in China. However, since publications regarding the Soviet Union were under strict censorship in Japan, the Chinese Marxists soon started to rely on English material published in the United States and in Briton for understanding Bolshevism. Ishikawa presents abundant evidence indicating that the Marxist intellectuals in Shanghai led by Chen Duxiu heavily relied on American Marxist literature.
Due to this, when the Bolsheviks, or the Russian Communist Party (RCP), and the Comintern sent Grigory Voitinsky, a young member of the RCP who had lived in the United States for several years, to China in order to form a stronghold of Communist activity there, it was quite easy for him to come across trustworthy figures such as Li Dazhao in Beijing and Chen Duxiu in Shanghai.
Interestingly, Ishikawa uncovers the fact that there were other groups in China, later labeled as ‘fake CCPs’, which were trying to gain acknowledgment through the various personal networks of the Comintern. According to Ishikawa, Soviet Russia actually took one of those groups quite seriously. There was also a Communist organization composed of the Chinese who were living in Russia. These episodes tell us that the CCP founded by Chen Duxiu and Li Dazhao was not necessarily the only option for the Russians.
The actual process of the CCP's formation is a topic which many scholars have dealt with. However, there are many differences of opinion. This situation gave space for Ishikawa to reinvestigate evidence regarding the formation of the CCP. Through carefully examining a variety of documents, Ishikawa figures out that an organization in Shanghai called the Socialist-Communist Party, which was created in June 1920, became the foundation of the CCP. The process of the creation of early stage Communist organizations in Shanghai, Beijing, Guangzhou, and other places was a process of breaking away from the Anarchists who originally were quite involved in Communist activities in those cities.
Ishikawa considers the drafting of the ‘Chinese Communist Party Manifesto’ along with the publishing of the magazine Chinese Communist Party as important evidence indicating the de facto formation of the CCP. These both happened in November 1920. Hence, Ishikawa argues that the formation of the CCP should be recognized as November 1920, not July 1921, when the First National Congress of the CCP was held.
Members of this newly formed CCP attended the Third Congress of the Comintern in June 1921. Ishikawa stresses the significance of this event for two reasons. For one, it marked the first time for a Communist Party created by the Chinese who lived in China to attend the Congress of the Comintern. Secondly, it meant that the CCP formed in November 1920 gained official recognition by the Comintern as the one and only Communist Party of China. This recognition allowed the CCP to avoid serious domestic conflict over legitimacy, which doomed a number of Communist organizations of other countries.
While the Third Congress of the Comintern was being held in Moscow, two members of the Comintern, Maring and Nikolsky, arrived in China. Their main mission was to transform the fragile and as yet ineffective CCP into an effective organization suitable enough to be recognized as ‘a Chinese branch of the Third International’. They were the ones who urged members of the CCP to hold a National Congress in July. This hasty preparation for a National Congress, under foreign initiative, resulted in the absence of Chen Duxiu and Li Dazhao to this important meeting.
Representatives to this Congress held in Shanghai came from Shanghai, Beijing, Wuhan, Guangzhou, Changsha, Jinan, and Japan. The expenses for their trip to Shanghai were provided mostly from the Comintern. Ishikawa carefully re-examines controversial issues related to this meeting. Those are, the number of participants, the time period, the mystery regarding the search for the Congress's meeting place, and items discussed at the Congress.
The CCP members had less than one month to prepare for the First National Congress. They didn't have enough time to introduce their own original set of rules and decisions relating to the social-economic conditions of China at that time. So the ‘Rules’ and ‘Decisions’ ratified at the First National Congress of the CCP were based on the ‘Program of the American Communist Party’ and the ‘Manifesto of the American Communist Party’. According to Ishikawa, this is the reason why the ‘Rules’ and ‘Decisions’ ratified at the First National Congress of the CCP were tinged with a radical tone, which stressed elimination of class discrimination and dictatorship of the proletariat.
Considering the fact that capitalism in China in the 1920s was still at a relatively primitive stage, it was obvious that China was not ready for a full-scale class struggle. Yet the CCP adopted a set of rules based on those of a Communist Party located in a fully developed capitalist state − the United States. By referring to this newly discovered fact, Ishikawa stresses that the formation of the CCP and its activities should be understood mainly in the context of international Communism movement and its development within Asia. In other words, the formation of the CCP should not be understood as an inevitable event that symbolized the rapid change of ‘relations of production’ within Chinese society.
In order to reinforce such arguments, Ishikawa uses the last portion of this book to focus on Shi Cuntong, one of the important members of the CCP during its early stage, and his activities in Japan, which started in June 1920. By uncovering the various personal connections Shi developed during his stay in Japan, Ishikawa once again tries to emphasize the strong international and universal character of the early Communist movement in China.
Ishikawa didn't add a chapter for a conclusion in his book. This indicates his basic academic posture to form an argument strictly linked with archival research. But still, it would have been nice if he had entered into a dialogue with other scholars in his field at the end of his argument.
There were quite a few books prior to 2001 when Ishikawa's book was originally published in Japan which argued that social reform conducted by the CCP through the 1920s to the 1940s faced serious hazards such as stubborn resistance from regional societies within China. How would his research fit in with those kinds of arguments? Or what could be said based on the fact that ‘Communist China’ turned into something not even close to what the founding fathers of the CCP originally expected.
Ishikawa refrained from commenting on such issues in his 2001 publication. He instead presented his overall perception of modern Chinese history in another book; Series of Modern Chinese History ③: Revolution and Nationalism 1925−1945 published from Iwanami Publishers in 2010(『シリーズ中国近現代史③ 革命とナショナリズム 1925—1945』、岩波新書、2010年). Though this new book has yet to be rendered into English by Joshua Fogel's superb translation, Ishikawa deals with the CCP's actual effort on social reform in the rural areas of China and also deals with Japan−China relations during the period of war. So those who would be interested in a more macro discussion by this extraordinary scholar should take a look at this book as well.
