This is a work of impressive scholarship dealing with a subject that has not previously been explored. It is based on research carried out in Lithuania in three different types of state secondary schools: a comprehensive school, an arts gymnasium and a choral singing music school. The pupils were all aged 15–19 and the amount of music studied each week ranged from one hour to seven hours. The sample from the combined schools was 390 pupils, with girls outnumbering boys by about 2 : 1.
Moral education, Girdzijauskas explains, is seen in Lithuania as being ‘inseparable from the context of specific cultural surroundings, values and traditions’ (p. 1). He quotes the General Educational Programmes and Educational Standards as saying:
the purpose of moral education is to help pupils to create [a] basis of moral culture, revealing general human values, developing [the] ability to decide and behave with responsibility and wisdom while establishing their moral consciousness. (p. 1)
The question is therefore: is it possible to find some measurable relationships between musical activity and moral development?
Girdzijauskas investigates this question using diagnostic research which aimed to ‘disclose [the] peculiarities of moral culture and character of musical activity’ of the chosen cohort (p. 45). More specifically he aims to identify and evaluate four particular areas that might influence moral culture: ‘1) stimulation of independent involvement of students in musical activity, 2) harmonization of employment of musical modes, 3) stimulation of more profound aesthetic emotions, 4) development of abilities to interpret music in [its] cultural context’.
In analysing his data Girdzijauskas defines three components as the most significant factors of moral culture: notional-evaluative, emotional and practical creative. He interprets these in the following way:
The level of notional-evaluative component manifests itself through perception and substantiation of moral values, alongside . . . evaluation of behaviour; [the] emotional component – through emotional experiences; [the] practical-creative – through moral decisions, moral behaviour and its motives. (p. 162)
Girdzijauskas concludes that in all schools the notional-evaluative component is not high in that most of the pupils based their evaluations on what would be best for themselves. Experiences related to emotional situations appear to be higher but Girdzijauskas considers these to have weaker links with moral values. The practical-creative component of moral culture is also not very high. Breaking these down a little further he acknowledges that the pupils from the choral singing school appear to show a little more maturity in their approach to moral culture. In addition, more girls than boys recognise, and can explain, the significance of moral values, and these are also recognised by pupils of higher academic ability. His explanation for this is that in these cases the students tend to show more stable moral behaviour.
Girdzijauskas also suggests that musical activity in senior students can affect their moral culture. He highlights the social significance of musical activity in promoting values such as respect, responsibility and the ability to create a harmonious cultural setting. Also of importance is the ability of musical activity to provide aesthetic gratification to others. A further consideration is that there are connections between the cognitive goals of musical activity, illustrated by a personal desire from the students to evaluate themselves, and recognise the values of respect and altruism. However the personal significance and purposefulness of musical activity was of more importance to the pupils than any social significance.
From these results Girdzijauskas makes suggestions as to how moral awareness, and therefore moral culture, can be encouraged in music education. These recommendations can be implemented under five headings: the social significance of musical activity should focus around: ‘providing aesthetic gratification’ (p. 163) to others; the cognitive goals of music activity could include the desire to evaluate oneself and thus discover new insights related to moral culture; the direction of musical activities focuses on such things as participation in concerts; the intensity of musical activity can create a significant relationship between the emotions felt when performing and independence of activity; and personal significance and purposefulness suggest a need to focus on the relationships between the students and the music teachers since ‘less than half of the students dare to show their feelings, and the same number of pupils feel that a teacher cares for them as individuals’ (p. 164).
I am glad that I have had the opportunity to review this publication because it is doubtful whether I would have had the chance to read it otherwise. It is published by VDM publishing house who provide an opportunity for academic research papers and theses to be published free of charge. And herein lie my difficulties: to obtain a printed copy of the thesis is very expensive; much of the finer detail of the thesis would not be relevant to music educators interested in the substantive issues; and although the work is published in English it is difficult to read because it is the stilted English of a second language speaker. Since there is much of value in this work my suggestion is that Girdzijauskas should try to publish some of this material in a more user-friendly form, either on its own or as a chapter within another publication.
