In the mid-1970s Allentown, Pennsylvania and Youngstown, Ohio possessed similar industrial characteristics. Almost half of their labor forces worked in manufacturing, principally in steel, automobile, textile, apparel, and cement firms. By 2000 their shares of workers in manufacturing employment had declined to 20 percent. Allentown switched into newer industrial sectors—electronics, instruments, and specialty chemicals—and into higher-end service jobs. In contrast, Youngstown retained the old industries, and its growing sectors were low-skilled service jobs and lesser white-collar jobs such as working in call centers. Today, Allentown is hailed as a postindustrial success story, whereas Youngstown is a failure, mired in corruption and divisive politics.
Sean Safford proposes a three-part institutionalist explanation of this puzzling divergence in reactions to challenges of industrial restructuring. First, he argues roles, rules, routines, and identities of individuals and of organizations in a mature industrial region must adapt to realities of the global economy. Allentown made this transition, but Youngstown did not. Second, business leaders must be central actors in the economy's transformation. In Allentown old and new business elite were engaged, whereas in Youngstown the business leadership disengaged. Finally, the social structure of civic interactions must connect key constituencies across the spectrum of nonprofit, religious, business, and labor in order for them to cooperate in transforming the region. Allentown's civic groups bridged across divides, whereas in Youngstown constituencies fought and failed to reach consensus about regional direction.
The first chapter sets out the puzzle, and the subsequent one dismisses alternative explanations for the divergence of Allentown and Youngstown. In the next chapter, Safford establishes the historical divergence of social structures between 1743 and 1945. In the Lehigh Valley region of Allentown, individual communities housed mixed ethnic groups, and competing civic elites emerged across the valley. Successful industrial leaders shifted to civic investments (e.g., colleges, hospitals) and turned over their firms to professional managers. In the Mahoning Valley housing Youngstown, ethnic fragmentation emerged, the business elite maintained tight control of their firms, and they developed cohesion within a residential enclave where they concentrated their civic investments.
In the next two chapters, Safford shows how social structural differences between the regions led to different responses to the crisis of industrial restructuring in the late twentieth century. In Allentown, competing civic elite built bridging ties across the region, and key organizations brought civic and business people together. In these crucibles, leaders forged plans to transform the economy. New business leaders were brought into the civic leadership, providing insights about how to respond to globalization. In contrast, in Youngstown the old business elite continued to dominate the economy and civic organizations. They were closed to competing ideas about transforming the economy. Failure of major firms led the business elite to withdraw from civic leadership, and the civic elite split into competing factions. This hindered collaboration to respond to the crisis of industrial restructuring. Safford uses network analyses of boards to support these interpretations.
In the final chapter, Safford draws conclusions and implications for cities that face industrial restructuring challenges. He argues that diverse social networks generate different ways for decision makers to form coalitions and take collective action. Actors, with dissimilar access to knowledge and involved in networks that do not fully overlap, can acquire diverse insights, and more actors have opportunities for leadership. Both civic and economic actors are essential to formulating strategies to reenergize a region's economy to compete effectively in the global economy. In contrast, overlapping, redundant networks fail to provide diverse insights required to respond to complex social and economic changes. Absence of business leadership leaves the region with a critical missing component.
This tightly argued book constitutes one of the best available analyses of industrial restructuring to date. Safford carefully weaves theory and systematically examines evidence. His time line from the mid-eighteenth century to the end of the twentieth century constitutes a challenge. This historical sweep requires him to select the few events directly related to his theoretical argument. The weakest evidence relates to the degree that population settlement of the valleys produced a complex ethnic and religious mosaic in the Lehigh Valley versus a fragmented residential structure in the Mahoning Valley. Implications of these differences are articulated well, but the supporting evidence link remains weak. Nevertheless, documentation of the approaches of different elites to investment in civic life supports his argument. The combination of network analyses and institutional archival evidence allows Safford to bring a behavioral interpretation to bear which enriches his interpretation.
Safford convincingly interprets the reasons for divergent economic-civic trajectories of Allentown and Youngstown. City and metropolitan organizations should take his policy prescriptions seriously. Arguably, the best single advice to economic and civic elites is for them avoid to monolithic entities which think with one mind; instead, they should build collaborative organizations. These must overlap some in their memberships to allow key players to be represented in decision making. All of them—politicians, business leaders, labor leaders, and heads of major nonprofits—need to work together, drawing on the best ideas, to respond to challenges of engaging with the global economy. Safford successfully demonstrates that integrated historical, social, and economic analysis can illuminate a complex issue—postindustrial restructuring. His results should be tested further by academics who can subject his findings to verification or revision with new case studies.
