Since the 1980s, the field of Ottoman studies has been one of the most dynamic and productive grounds of historical research. Yet within this ever-flourishing literature a more systematic and comprehensive analysis of the issues pertaining to the crucial question of legitimacy was long due. In this respect, Legitimizing the Order is the first book-length contribution to the field and no doubt an achievement in itself. The editors should be congratulated for bringing together ten essays in a collection that explores various problems, sources, and subperiods in the light of the problem of how and to what extent the Ottoman rulers and political elites formulated, maintained, and redefined legitimacy, order, and authority.
After a brief introduction by the editors, the book opens with Hakan Karateke's “framework for historical analysis,” which makes a theoretical discussion of the “normative” and “factual” aspects of Ottoman legitimacy. Karateke's piece is lucid, and his assumptions and generalizations are highly suggestive; yet, as he notes, they all need to be tested for validity by further empirical studies. The edition is then divided into three parts of three articles each, ending with a cumulative bibliography. The first part (“The Well-Founded Order”) begins with Gottfried Hagen's “Legitimacy and World Order,” which discusses the notion of nizam-ı ʿalem (the universally valid order of the world) as the central idea and rhetoric underlying the Ottoman ruling elites' discourses of legitimacy until the 18th century. Through a detailed reading of selected early modern political, ethical, and legal texts, Hagen concludes that this notion both “helped to justify political rule in general against all those who found worldly power detrimental to individual and collective salvation,” and as it “endorsed justice and reined in the injustice inherent in human nature, it co-opted the moral standards of the critics” (p. 81). However, this key concept, he argues, lost its relevance in the early 1700s, at a time when contemporary needs for reform called for a different social and political discourse.
In “Murad III and the Historians: Representations of Ottoman Imperial Authority in Late 16th-Century Historiography,” Christine Woodhead turns our attention to the details of dynastic rhetoric as reflected in the texts written by court historiographers (şehnameci) during the reign of the “secluded” and “sedentary” Sultan Murad III (1574–95). She observes that the historiographers of this period, Lokman and Talikizade, reworked the representations of the sultan and reformulated the achievements of the Ottoman dynasty in order to counter criticisms against Murad III's style of rule while the image of the sultan as active military leader was overtaken by “that of the padişah, the emperor, a more elevated and less tangible figure” (p. 91). As Hagen and Woodhead both illuminate and deepen our understanding of how premodern Ottoman discourses of legitimacy changed over time, the last contribution in this section, Colin Imber's “Frozen Legitimacy,” is less satisfactory. Imber contends that, by the mid-17th century, “the changing nature of warfare together with the unwarlike temperaments of the successors to Süleyman I had changed the role of the Sultan from an active to a symbolic warrior” (p. 103). This image of “warrior-sultan” was then frozen in history to be revived and reconceptualized as “warrior-nation” by the Turkish nationalist elites in the early 20th century. This is a highly problematic generalization, as Imber makes a sudden jump from the 1600s to the 1900s for his argument and thus ignores generations of Ottoman rulers and discussions with respect to numerous sultanic and dynastic images.
In the next part (“Religiosity and Orthodoxy”), Karateke's second essay discusses how religion and religious devotion worked in the formulation of sultanic legitimacy and image in the 19th century. The next two articles by Nabil al-Tikriti and Markus Dressler focus on the evolving conceptualizations of religious ideology, imperial identity, and legitimacy within the context of 16th-century Ottoman–Safavid relations. Al-Tikriti reads the neglected contemporary Ottoman kalam (theological disputation) literature as a reflection of the expanding imperial hegemonic control over the definition of apostasy, which helped the Ottoman court in Istanbul to reinforce its legitimacy by denouncing enemies of the state as enemies of the Muslim religion and thus served as a justification for the mass persecution of kızılbaş. Similarly, Dressler sees the Ottoman–Safavid rivalry as politically and economically driven and observes that the institutionalization of orthodox and legalistic Sunni Islam in the Ottoman Empire and of Twelver Shiʿi Islam in Safavid Iran was a by-product of this imperial competition that shared an almost similar symbolic order of legitimacy and discursive field. Both authors offer a rich discussion of texts and terminologies while they analyze how these two political entities legitimized themselves by reconstructing their “self-identity” through defining “orthodoxy” and “orthopraxy” as well as their “other” by ascribing “heterodoxy” and “heteropraxy.”
The final section of the book is on the “crisis” of Ottoman legitimacy. On this problem, Suraiya Faroqhi's article looks into the Ottoman bureaucracy's new recording practices of petitions submitted by artisans in the mid-18th century. By using the records concerning the guilds in Istanbul as a case study, Faroqhi speculates about the central administration's attempt for “legitimation through increased interference” as part of the exigencies of premodern Ottoman state centralization. Next comes Maurus Reinkowski's “The State's Security and the Subjects' Prosperity: Notions of Order in Ottoman Bureaucratic Correspondence (19th Century),” which is perhaps the most innovative contribution to the book. By utilizing archival documents on Mirdites in Albania, he examines the Tanzimat terminology in terms of its rhetoric of order and contends that, by the 1860s, the old ideal of security-cum-prosperity fundamentally changed as the Ottomans attempted to regain control of peripheral regions that were under the threat of European imperialism. Reinkowski's meticulous reading of official texts reveals that the Ottoman Tanzimat policy began to include a new mission of “disciplining” and “civilizing” those “unruly” subjects while still embodying some older forms of convalescent concepts. Finally, the edition is closed by Teyfur Erdoğdu's informative article on how civil officials reacted to the “legitimacy deficits” vis-à-vis the financial, administrative, and legal problems during the reign of Abdülhamit II (1876–1909) and his successors.
All in all, the book fills a lacuna in Ottoman historiography by its attempt to understand the complexities and evolving nature of legitimacy throughout the entire life span of Ottoman dynastic and imperial establishment. The authors are to be credited for their contributions, all of which will surely pave the way for future studies and discussions.
