No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 September 2004
Anyone interested in early-twentieth-century labor-management relations in the United States must at some point confront Sanford Jacoby's now “classic” book, originally published in 1985. Because of its importance in the literature every research library possesses a copy, but, because the book has been out of print for a few years now, younger scholars and students who like to scribble in the margins of books that brim with new ideas and insights have had to forego this pleasure. No longer.
The revised edition contains the original manuscript, covering the years to 1945, plus a final chapter that brings the argument through to the close of the century. Jacoby's basic thesis is that an odd assortment of social reformers and former efficiency experts, under the banner of the “personnel management” movement, set the stage for many of the features we have come to associate with being a “good” employer today—decent wages, fringe benefits, and opportunities for internal advancement through promotion. Combining an exhaustive review of the literature with a mound of government survey evidence, Jacoby documents the progress of this movement in rich detail. The final chapter reflects on the movement since mid-century, and especially on whether recent developments threaten its earlier achievements. While interesting, because this chapter covers 55 years in less than twenty pages, whereas the original manuscript covered 45 years in over two hundred pages, it has a rather rushed feel to it compared to the preceding chapters.
I will not focus here on a review of the original material, but rather comment on its influence on the work of economic historians and labor economists since its initial publication. Virtually every book even tangentially related to the subject matter cites Jacoby's study. Moreover, the Social Science Citation Index reveals that the book has been cited 219 times in social science and humanities journals since its original publication. A closer look at the citations, however, reveals that less than 20 percent are from economics journals. The majority of the citations are from management science, sociology, and history journals.
The reason for this, I think, is the style of presentation; the book is really a narrative history of the movement, sprinkled with a few comments on economic theory (e.g., against the notion of inevitably efficient institutional change) and a few tables of figures documenting the results of the movement (e.g., the percentage of firms with profit-sharing plans in the 1920s). Economists, and even some economic historians, squirm in their seats while reading narrative history. After all, there are no hypotheses on which to establish a foothold, and no systematic empirical evidence is marshaled to back up claims. Furthermore, painting with broad brushstrokes is not always conducive to sorting out strict causality.
Like much narrative history, Jacoby's account is subject to these sorts of criticisms. For example, following a painstaking account of the personnel management movement's attempt to establish a system of internal promotion and group pension plans into American industry during the 1920s, we are told, near the end of the discussion, that only a handful of firms had adopted such practices. Indeed, in the end, many of the features this movement strove to establish in American industry were brought on by either government intervention during the war periods or by the threat or ultimate success of unionization.
But, if the methodological approach of economics—self-interested behavior subject to constraints—leads us to conclude that the personnel management movement has no independent historical legacy because the benevolent features it strove to establish were anathema to profit-minded businessmen, and, in the end, only adopted through the force of government and unions, it is our loss. Modern game theorists and cliometricians must at some point begin to shed light on phenomena such as the rent-sharing behavior of firms, the role of fairness in labor-management relations, and why it is that some firms choose “high road” labor practices while others in the same industry follow the “low road.” Jacoby's account offers important lessons in this regard. Indeed, this “classic” is a treasure trove of hypotheses awaiting careful theoretical formulation and empirical testing.