By its editor's own admission, this book, a collection of eleven chapters by scholars from a variety of disciplines, is “eclectic” (p. xviii). However, it is also accessible in style and sufficiently comprehensive in scope to be of interest to and use in advanced undergraduate and graduate studies of Islamic political thought. The greatest contribution of the book lies in its demonstration of how far many contemporary Muslim intellectuals and scholars of Islam have moved beyond questions regarding the compatibility of Islam and democracy toward a fuller development of and more critical engagement with democratic theory from an Islamic perspective and in light of current political exigencies. The value of the book is, unfortunately, diminished somewhat by its lack of copyediting. In addition to numerous typos, several of the chapters are referred to as “papers,” perhaps reflecting their starting point as conference contributions. There is also lack of consistency in transliterating Arabic terms, not only across chapters but also within individual chapters.
The book's chapters are divided in three sections that move from “classical perspectives” to “regional debates” to “global discourses.” Some of the most interesting contributions are found in the first section. Tariq Ramadan and Tamara Sonn each broach the question of how Islam can provide the basis of unity in light of the diversity of opinions and interpretations about what constitutes an acceptable form of government in Islam. Both affirm that divergent views are not only inevitable but must be recognized and respected and, further, are indicative of Islam's strength and dynamism. Ramadan argues that the principles embedded in the shariʿa, “as a global path, methodology and philosophy of life,” unite Muslims and should not be confused with fiqh, “the state of juridical reflection reached by Muslim scholars at a certain time and in [a] certain context” (p. 3). The task, he argues, is for the ʿulamaʾ to struggle to arrive at “the truth” of Islam's global path while remaining humble and calm in the face of competing opinions; it is also for individual Muslims to struggle to follow the opinion that his or her own consideration finds most compelling. Sonn similarly argues that law, not a governmental form, is the basis of Islamic identity and unity. Although chiefly concerned with underscoring the importance of legal training being open and widespread among Muslims to ensure that the state preserves its Islamic identity and establishes justice, Sonn also analyzes the limits of what can and cannot be discerned from classical Islamic sources regarding acceptable forms and processes of governance. She concludes that members of the Islamic community ultimately must exercise their own judgment in deciding among the multiple and competing views on the topic.
In her contribution, Asma Afsaruddin offers compelling refutation of claims shared by modern Islamist ideologues and contemporary Orientalist scholars that the concept of a divinely mandated government led by God's representatives, which must be obeyed without question, has any basis in the Qurʾan—a fact that she persuasively establishes was acknowledged by earlier Muslim modernists. A powerful chapter by Abdulaziz Sachedina—which appears in the book's final section but would seem to be better placed with the contributions of Ramadan, Sonn, and Afsaruddin—locates a “functional secularity” (p. 174) in classical Islamic sources that provides for an ethical-religious voice of guidance rather than governance that recognizes principles of pluralism, toleration, and inclusion as the basis for a civil society.
Four chapters look at Islam and democracy in the context of national debates. Osman Bakar argues that Malaysia offers a lesson in how Islam can contribute to interethnic and interreligious harmony in the context of democratic pluralism—as well as the ways that Islamic thought can progress in such a context. Ozlem Denli outlines Ali Bulac's advocacy of a political model that accommodates a plurality of legal systems and requires a state largely limited to executive and administrative functions. It is this view, he argues, that provides present-day Muslim groups a way of correlating Islamic principles with the larger Islamic framework of the Turkish state. Mahgoub El-Tigani Mahmoud and Carolyn Fluehr-Lobban provide an overview of the classical Muslim jurist al-Mawardi, Sufi sects, and three more recent Islamists (Hassan al-Turabi, Sadiq al-Mahdi, and Mahmoud Mohamed Taha), all of whom they suggest have had a significant impact on contemporary Sudanese politics. Ali Paya analyzes the writings of three Iranian scholars (Abdulkarim Soroush, Mohammad Mojtahid Shabestari, and Saʿid Hajjarian), drawing attention to similarities among them and their distinctiveness from previous generations of Shiʿi intellectuals. He argues that a “paradigm shift” has occurred that offers new possibilities for mutual understanding between Sunnis and Shiʿa. Although each of these chapters usefully locates the book's theme in the context of national politics and provides good overviews of some of the region's most prominent Islamic intellectuals, they do not break any new ground.
The book's final section opens with M. A. Muqtedar Khan's attempt to critically examine both Islamic and American discourses on the issue of the compatibility of Islam and democracy, as well as constituent debates over such things as “the Islamic threat” and “Western imperialism.” Mark Lynch's contribution shifts the analysis away from the question of Islam and democracy toward a related question: is dialogue between Islam and the West possible after September 11? After critical analysis of some of the most prominent Islamic intellectuals and a number of their American counterparts, Lynch affirms the possibility and urgency of such a dialogue. Abdelwahab El-Affendi launches a powerful refutation of Islamic critics of democracy and the various alternatives to democracy that they offer. Taken together, these final chapters lay out in systematic fashion the politics that both animate and obscure discussion of Islam and democracy, and they make considerable progress toward clearing a path for further development of Islamic democratic theorizing.
