No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 June 2004
The rise of online information services deserves attention not merely as a chapter in the history of computer technology, but as a noteworthy field in and of itself. Charles P. Bourne and Trudi Bellardo Hahn make clear that the topic is ripe for exploration by historians of various kinds.
The co-authors are both scholars and leaders in the field of online services. Their book offers a lavishly detailed examination of the early—although not earliest—years of the development of online services. Bourne and Hahn intend to “… capture all the relevant facts, interpret and synthesize them, and mold them into a coherent story” (p. 7). Indeed, the authors provide a thorough chronology of the development of online systems and information retrieval services.
The first four chapters explore the early research in online and other information systems that culminated in a multitude of university and nonacademic efforts to develop prototype or experimental systems. Subsequent chapters exhaustively trace the emergence and use of some particularly prominent systems. Before concluding, the authors devote two chapters to a meticulous examination of the rapid rise of operational online industry in the 1970s. These chapters are the book's most useful and may be the best currently available treatment of the industry.
The series of questions that guide the authors' research are reflective of those that economic historians might ask and merit repeating. “What role did hardware, software, telecommunications and database developments play in driving the progress of online systems telecommunications and online systems?” “What were the characteristics of the early online services? What were their purposes and functions, and how well did they accomplish them? What roles did formal evaluation play in the progress of online systems and services?” “What was the role of government and private funding?” “What were the characteristics, behavior, and attitudes of the online pioneers?” (pp. 8–9)
Bourne and Hahn demonstrate that information retrieval systems were constrained by existing computer technology, and show how adroitly the developers of online systems adapted to the speed and memory limits of the hardware. In fact, the features of some of these information services exceeded the aptitudes and needs of even the intended users. It is in describing the interplay between end-users and online systems and the cross-fertilization of ideas and systems features between researchers and prototype models that the book is at its best. Many early online systems were intended for use by discrete groups of end-users. More often, however, intermediaries—particularly librarians—proved to be the conduit connecting the ultimate user of information retrieval services with the results of an inquiry. Users contended with various shortcomings of the early systems and hardware and ultimately provided feedback that aided in making system improvements.
More broadly, the authors illuminate many instances of interaction and collaboration among the various online pioneers. Computer scientists, librarians, engineers, psychologists, and others used the lessons learned from the early, prototypical models to enhance the level of performance and range of functions available in subsequent online systems. Indeed, the period examined by the authors seems to have been one in which online information services advanced from the status of imperfect, experimental tools that were often used by searchers in specific disciplines or industries to become part of a robust online industry serving a much broader audience. The histories of emerging industries are often interesting, and the authors' treatment of the creation of a viable online industry gives us a view of the challenges faced in establishing pricing strategies and creating a virtuous circle of systems, users, and databases.
Bourne and Hahn make clear that “the rapid developments of the 1960s were a direct result of the plenitude of government support for information storage and retrieval research, experimentation and development”(p. 408). They rigorously detail the extent to which numerous public and private funding sources supported research efforts that yielded a rapid advance in online systems. Hence, the remarkable degree of university, defense-related, and private efforts to create workable online systems becomes clear.
This book may well serve as a definitive reference on a decisive period in the development of online information retrieval. It is not, however, a history that will provide a useable introduction to the field. Bourne and Hahn assume of their readers a degree of knowledge that seems unrealistic. The level of detail often overwhelms a narrative that is laden with acronyms and abbreviations. Although meticulously researched, the authors' insights are not always easily discerned. There is, for example, no sufficient analysis of the conditions that proved most conducive to establishing commercially viable online systems or firms; neither is there a clear examination of how efficiently the large sums of public money were spent.
Perhaps this is too much to ask. The authors broadly achieve their goal of providing a thorough record of the rise of online information systems, but they have circumscribed their audience in doing so.