In this far-reaching work, Brenda Elsey and Joshua H. Nadel give a whistle-stop tour through the history of women's sports across parts of Latin America and Central America as well as more detailed accounts of women's football in Brazil and Mexico. Although the scope of the book precludes detailed analysis and, at times, leads to some countries being glossed over very quickly (Ecuador and Costa Rica in particular), the work is successful in allowing for a broad understanding of shifting social conditions across the region and how these change and are changed by women's engagement in sport. The title Futbolera: A History of Women and Sports in Latin America signposts the tensions in the book concerning whether this is a work on football or on sports more generally and to what extent this volume can claim to cover the entire region of Latin America and all of its sporting prowess. Yet what this work lacks in academic precision it more than makes up for with regards to giving a broad understanding of public and politically-motivated conceptions that continue to restrict funding and support for women's sports, in spite of the rich histories and hard-won success stories that have occurred previously.
One clear conclusion to emerge from the myriad experiences of women's sports across Latin America is that misogyny and homophobia have consistently suppressed women's sport in the region. It is depressing to read about how Brazilian athletes have continually been forced to confront or work around antiquated claims of biology and sexuality, and even more depressing to hear that two former national players, Sissi (Sisleide do Amor Lima) and Márcia Taffarel, ‘expressed astonishment that the situation in Brazil had not improved significantly since the 1980s’ (p. 145). However, in the context of the extensive archival work conducted by Elsey and Nadel this is unsurprising. Indeed, the authors conclude that ‘this has been the case throughout the history of women's sports in Latin America: brief periods of effervescence followed by long periods of apparent inactivity’ (p. 245).
In spite of the significant obstacles placed in front of sports participants, nevertheless players and teams continue to train and organise. This book is strongest when giving insights into pioneers of sports participation across the region, which demonstrate the historical importance of women in shaping sports and challenging the narrative that women's participation is a recent phenomenon. Examples such as Anna Amélia de Queiróz, who was ‘one of the earliest celebrity female football fans’ and an ‘important feminist, scholar, and football player’ (p. 76) in Brazil in the 1910s, contribute details and inspiration. The section concentrating on the Mexican football squad's build-up to the World Championship in Italy in 1971 is particularly interesting and gives one example of consistent effort leading to significant (albeit seemingly temporary) social change. Indeed, the sections dealing with Mexico and Brazil are the longest and offer the most in terms of insight and analysis. At times, it felt as though the book might better be framed as a comparison between these two women's sports powerhouses.
However, to concentrate on the occasional lack of detail in Futbolera is to miss the power of the work in serving to draw together general conclusions that can be gleaned when looking at the region as a whole. One aspect that this approach enables is in generating suggestions for the future with the benefit of understanding what has and has not worked in different countries at different times. Elsey and Nadel argue that ‘The history of the sport and its underdevelopment by FIFA [football's international governing body], CONMEBOL [the South American football federation], and national associations suggests that the Chilean ANJUFF [association of women footballers] may be on to something – a separate federation or a player's union and support from FIFPro [the world player's union]’ (p. 263). Other suggestions concern the importance of collective action and grassroots mobilisation for delivering change. Put most plainly, efforts at recognition for women's sports ‘are not fighting for equal treatment – or even equitable treatment’ but simply ‘the basics: travel money, decent facilities, and better support’ (ibid.). While it would be easy to question how political and social contexts – created in large part by political and international sports bodies - have still not delivered a level playing field for women's sports participants, women's sports participation in Latin America – as this book makes plain – might be generally characterised as peaks of interest and support followed by reduced funding and attention.
