This, the forty-third volume in Routledge's ambitious Contemporary South Asia series, needs to be read alongside Volume 16, Dispossession and Resistance in India (2010), for both concern the struggles of the Adivasi communities. But this one hardly engages with the current civil war raging in eastern and central India, its epicentre Chhattisgarh, and has in consequence a curiously disembodied feel to it. There is little on the invasion of global and Indian capital into the forest areas. No doubt the editors are right to disengage this Indian story from that of a worldwide indigenous people's movement. But this collection of essays also indicates just how difficult it is to generalise about the stories of indigenous tribal communities in India, so different are their circumstances. This is made all the more apparent by the way some interpretations in this volume flatly contradict one another. It does not help that exploitative groups have misappropriated the Adivasi cause. Understanding the issues is also ill served by the conceptual fog, at times dense, of some contributors. The editors ask, what is Adivasi subjectivity? The word translates as original (adi) inhabitants (vasi). Can we actually hear the voice of the Adivasis themselves in this series of linked micro-studies?
The essays owe a great deal to subalternist historians. There is reference to a number of resistance movements to colonial rule. Earliest is to the Chuar bidroha (rebellion) of 1776, a peasant revolt in West Bengal and the jungle mahals of Jharkhand against the higher taxes of the East India Company, though here the concern is to describe how various interest groups exploited its commemoration in 1998–9. Another essay is a revisionist attempt to characterise the Santal revolt of 1857–8 more as a tribal revolt than as part of a nationalist uprising. There is a fascinating essay by Tanika Sarkar on a Santal revolt in Malda, West Bengal, but one led by a convert to Hinduism, Jitu Santal, who insisted that his followers gave up pigs and fowls, central to Santal life, worshipped Kali, fell under the cultural spell of the very landlords they were attacking, led his followers in a campaign which rejected Muslims, lower castes and untouchables alike, and ended up on 3 December 1932 by trying to ignite a pro-Gandhian rebellion through occupying a mosque.
But just how oppressive was the colonial regime? Here two essayists, and they are contributing to a new school of Indian environmental history, drastically differ. Darley Kjosavik dates mass deforestation in Kerala through coffee and tea plantations from the 1840’s. In this account, the Indian Forest Act of 1878 gave new cultivators and timber merchants a free hand to exploit the forest: “the outcome was a total alienation of adivasis from their forest based means of production”. After 1947, “the frontier went wilder than ever with the land rush, it teemed with speculators, the timber mafia, middlemen of all shades, traders, moneylenders and entrepreneurs”. (p. 127) It is not clear how much of this was set to rights by the state taking over private forests in 1971. The author grew up in a midland Kerala village yet we do not really hear the voice of the Adivasi dispossessed in these pages, maybe just because the forest frontier was seen as an empty space. Vinita Damodorum markedly differs in her essay on the forests of Singhbhum in Chotanagpur. She finds evidence that the colonial officials of the Forestry Department, went to great trouble in the 1870s and 80s (she picks out J. S. Macpherson and J. H. Taylor) to respect the interests of the forest dwellers, protecting customary rights such as “the free collection of small produce fuel, grass, bamboo grazing and shifting cultivation in the wastelands”. (p. 106) Admittedly, she draws a distinction between reserved forests, where landlords were given a free hand, and protected forests; and Adivasis in the protected forests were themselves subject to constraints, with no rights of selling timber or forest produce, having to protect trees and sacred groves.
Independence merely exacerbated the plight of the Adivasis. In his Panchsheel approach Nehru sought by affirmative action to protect minority interests and, now classified as Scheduled Tribes, the forest peoples found themselves drawn into a Nehruvian development programme. Its failure to address their needs drove forward demands for greater political autonomy. Amit Prakash has shown how the eighteen districts of Bihar, which became in 2000 the state of Jharkhand, were always contributing more to the Indian capitalist economy — at various points in time locals blockaded the export of its mineral wealth — than it was receiving in development aid. At best they were passive beneficiaries, and experienced no actual feeling of betterment. But there was a greatly improved rate of literacy. Maybe more in the text could have been given over to describing the peculiar economy of the forest peoples, a sustainable economy which provides one with a role model in a time of climate change. David Mosse has an interesting chapter exploring how the Bhils in western India reacted to being caught between an ODA project which did seemingly seek to protect their way of life and central government agency which sought to advance commercial agriculture and agro-based industries. Admittedly, local self-help groups did provide easier forms of credit for local needs and, intriguingly, these are by way of contrast to traditional forms of collective action, expensive festivals, animal sacrifices and constitute “a prime marker in the Adivasi story of modernisation”. But, overall, there was “a carefully considered contingent capitulation to dominant ideology”, “an invisible disjunction between village realities and project systems concealed in the rhetoric of participation”. (pp. 162–163) If the needs of Adivasis were betrayed by development economics, might they be better served by forms of political autonomy?
Here again, no clear picture emerges. Very oddly the driving force behind the setting up of the state of Jharkhand was the BJP, a Hindu nationalist party, rather than the regional Jharkhand party (JHP), though the divided nature of the Jharkhand movement explains its electoral weakness. Bengt Karlsson looks at the tribal areas of the North East. Here are some sixty insurgency movements out of two hundred ethnic groups: “autonomy or self-determination, in one form or another, is indeed on the agenda of more or less all mobilised communities”. (p. 141) His micro-study is of Meghalaya which broke from Assam in 1972. He explores how the Khasi people have turned to traditional institutions (TIs), Durbars, seen as free of party politics, as an alternative means of representation to the state's Autonomous District Councils (ADCs), though they lack administrative skills, have no female representatives, and the Chiefs are actually appointed by the ADCs. Are TIs, indeed, he asks, the means to meet the needs of self-determination and avoid militant separatism? And Willem van Schendel draws attention to certain fundamental weaknesses in these autonomous movements. Theirs is often an exclusivism by way of a reaction to globalisation, to “the threatening invading of Others,” and they give way to “xenophobic ideologies of belonging” and to ethnic cleansing. (p. 29) He appeals for “a geographical imagination that is less destructive in its consequences”, for new political formations “re-imagined as more open and hybrid”.(p. 37) Just how do you fashion new political entities with such mixed populations? In Meghalaya 85% of the population is tribal. In Jharkhand, however, in 1999 but 27.66% were so. Schendel believes that merely ethnic states actually disempower. But anyway what do these political changes mean to the Adivasis?
Alpa Shah in her field work amongst the Mundas, some 50 kilometres distant from Jharkhand's capital of Ranchi, in talking to one Mangra Munda in the market of Bero, discovered that he was unaware that the new state had come into being: “in any case does it matter? What development will it bring? As far as I am concerned, it is probably only going to bring our soshan (exploitation) closer” (quoted p. 218). This is a rare moment in the book when we hear the authentic voice of the Adivasis themselves. Her research also reveals how divided this tribal society has become, with the village elites, the yadavs, siphoning off development funds, and middle class Jharkhand ethno-regional activists isolating the poor even more from the village elites. To have a greater sense of the all too human in the lives of Adivasis one has to turn to the writings of Arundhati Roy, for example, Broken Republic (London, 2011).
And now the Adivasis are caught in the cross fire of a civil war between the Indian Army and the Maoists.
