The “global cities” of the 19th century are increasingly coming to the attention of historians of Africa, Asia, and the Middle East. Jonathan Miran's study of Massawa on the Red Sea coast is a clear example of this orientation and a benchmark to which future studies will have to refer. The book combines the classic genre of urban history with insightful analysis of the nature and development of cosmopolitanism, the emergence and influence of hybridity in various forms, and the impact of colonial power and nation-state policies on a city. The strength of this work is that the author consistently seeks to historicize these processes as part of an attempt to answer his main question: what produces the characteristics of a city like Massawa?
The empirical basis for this book rests on an impressive array of languages: Arabic, Tigrinya, Tigra, Afar, and Saho. The result is a discussion drawing on sound archival research. One example is the author's presentation of the actual content of court cases that demonstrate the wealth of Indian merchant houses. The inclusion of a rich selection of maps and photographs makes this book especially readable and accessible to the nonspecialist.
The author makes a convincing argument for viewing the Red Sea as an area epitomizing the artificiality of traditional area-studies boundaries. Trade, familial, and religious connections across the Red Sea were persistent and regular, occurring almost daily. This historical study of the city is correspondingly multiangled, viewing developments from several vantage points: local, supralocal, regional, and cross-regional. Such a multifocal perspective demands much of an author, and it is a great strength of Miran that he directly addresses the question of how this type of study best be organized: “How does one amalgamate . . . multiple historical frames of reference into a more or less coherent narrative?” (p. 11) Overall, the author succeeds in his enterprise, challenging the center-periphery perspective, and focusing instead on connectivities.
The author approaches his fundamental question by addressing the historical functions of the city, or its potential to mediate between multiple commercial (and other) spheres. He takes as a starting point the fact that over the span of 500 years prior to Eritrea's independence in 1993, Massawa was under Ottoman Egyptian, Italian, British, and Ethiopian occupation. These successive waves of foreign rule serve as a starting point for an investigation of “technological, political, economic and migratory factors” that transformed Massawa from a sleepy port to a veritable Red Sea hub in the 19th century.
The author first deals with the gradual assertion of independent authority and the eventual fall of the Ottoman-installed nuwwāb of Massawa and then implicitly explores the regionalization of the Red Sea. He examines the social, political, and religious power base of the nuwwāb. Miran demonstrates that control over agricultural and grazing lands as well as trade routes into the interior was as important as control over transoceanic networks and taxation of overseas traders. The study also analyzes the positions of Arab and Indian traders and financiers in the face of increasing European presence. In Massawa, as elsewhere along the East African coast, the massive growth of European shipping threatened but did not entirely eliminate traditional shipping via locally crafted vessels. The effect was that Massawa became integrated into the economy of its immediate hinterland.
To this reader, the most interesting section of the book deals with “becoming local” in Massawa and the implicit rise of the “Homo mare erythraeum” (Red Sea citizens). As the Egyptians modernized the city in the 1870s, Massawa began to attract people from the hinterlands, where they became laborers, traders, or water carriers, for example. Here the author also addresses the issue of Massawans’ genealogy, or more correctly, how they narrated their origins. Again, the author emphasizes immigration from the interior as having been at least as important as immigration from Egypt, Hijaz, Yemen, and Hadramawt.
The book then returns to its central questions: What did it mean to be a Massawan in the boomtown days? How were identities negotiated, and what were the paths of integration for those coming from land and sea? In his discussion, the author analyzes both the physical layout of the city and ideas of race, class, and origins held amongst the population. He also discusses the urban notables, their power bases, and the complex relationships between groups who defined themselves as such. His detailed analysis of the Massawan urban elite, and their interconnections, properties, and matrimonial practices, is both thorough and excellent and should be read by all scholars with an interest in African Muslim urban societies.
Miran's book demonstrates how specific and carefully reconstructed interregional interactions shaped the Red Sea town of Massawa in the 19th century. Particularly revealing is the process by which overseas immigrants from India, Arabia, or Egypt moved into positions that enabled them to achieve wealth and therefore social and religious status. The city was “highjacked by migrants” (p. 271), as the author states, while preserving its links to the immediate surrounding mainland. Herein lies a question: when a city experiences this type of boom based on transregional migration, to what extent are existing local dynamics preserved or severed? Massawa is here portrayed as a two-way door, facing both land and sea, much like other trading ports. This study indicates that neither entry was completely closed at any one time.
The work should also be commended for its approach to the concepts of “region” and “regionalization.” Construing the Red Sea as a region, the author consistently places Massawa within a web of interrelated locations: the hinterland, trade routes into the interior, port cities on both the Arabian and African side of the sea. He also locates this region in the wider web of the Indian Ocean, the Middle East, and the expanding European colonial empires. In so doing, he opens the possibility of comparative studies in the Red Sea and invites further research on the region's links with wider systems of migration, trade, and cultural exchange.
The potential for comparative studies with other trading towns—whether on sea or inland—is also valuable, as the author notes on several occasions. This is especially true for the 19th-century boomtowns of the East African coast (notably, Zanzibar as well as others).
