The historiography of Islam and Muslim communities in West Africa has revolved around a number of specific themes that have been debated, refined, and revised by historians. For a solid introduction to those historiographical debates and new insights into the multiple meanings of Sufi thought and practices in 20th-century West Africa, Sean Hanretta's book, Islam and Social Change in French West Africa, is a valued contribution and a must read.
Islam and Social Change is written in an engaging manner and displays exceptional analytical skill. The author uses the history of the Yacoubist Sufi community in West Africa as a framework to discuss the relationship between Sufism and socioeconomic change in West Africa. Hanretta's book serves as a window into the complexities of Muslim–colonial encounters and, more significantly, as a critique of both colonial archives and local oral traditions, which can simplify or distort—if taken at face value and not read against or in light of each other—the intricate stories they are supposed to tell.
Also embedded in this book is a historical narrative that eschews a narrow focus on Sufi leaders and instead brings to the forefront the role women and slaves played in shaping and giving meaning to religious practices in the community and to broader social and economic developments. Both groups are attributed an essential role in the history of the order and in the links Hanretta establishes between the Yacoubists’ religious idioms and practices and their pragmatic approaches to economic, social, and political change in West Africa. Hanretta skilfully illuminates how slaves and women are empowered through their own interpretations, acts, and contributions, which he integrates, with variable success, into the history of the Yacoubist community.
Hanretta reveals this complex story in three stages. The first stage includes a narrative of the history of the Yacoubist Sufi community, which was founded in 1929 by Shaykh Yacouba Sylla in Kaédi, Mauritania. Yacouba Sylla considered himself a follower of the Malian Shaykh Ahmad Hamallah, and members of his community viewed themselves as spiritual followers of the Hamaliyya tradition. The Yacoubists’ calls for religious and social reform led to their persecution by both colonial authorities and rival local Muslim elites. As a result, many members, including the leader, moved to Côte d'Ivoire, where they contributed to the local economy and engaged in local politics. Hanretta follows developments within the Yacoubist community up to the present. The latter years of its history, however, are discussed minimally. This impediment is due to a lack of available sources, an issue that is the focus of the next part of Hanretta's book.
In the second stage, Hanretta offers a thorough and engaging analysis of his source material, including documents from the colonial archive and oral histories from Yacoubists. Critical of both, Hanretta first provides an overview of colonial perceptions and policies in French West Africa that, in turn, left their marks on the content and organization of the colonial archive. Although there is little new in this overview, the explanation of how French policies and perceptions concerning the Yacoubists conveyed broader patterns in the French relationship to Islam and Muslims in West Africa constitutes an original contribution. More significant is Hanretta's discussion of the role of the “ghostwriters,” the Yacoubists’ rivals, in shaping French perceptions of and policies toward the Yacoubists. The second chapter in this part of the book deals with the oral traditions of the Yacoubists and how this Sufi community shaped its legacy and interpreted its history through a process of negotiation between religious idioms and hermeneutics, individual experiences, and a certain collective identity the Yacoubists strove to create and maintain.
The third part of the book is devoted to the “subalterns,” including slaves, ex-slaves, women, and laborers, and their roles in shaping the history of their Sufi community. The shortcomings of this section parallel those of the book as a whole. To begin, the organization detracts from the text's accessibility and overall potential. Although one is able to follow Hanretta's line of thought through each chapter, this is not the case with the larger section or the book as a whole. Overall, the main arguments are lost in unnecessary details and elaborations that demonstrate the author's deep knowledge of the history of Islam in West Africa but nevertheless obstruct the reader from following his line of thought. Better organization could have made the work more coherent and accessible and less fragmented.
The organizational problems are partially the result of the overly ambitious task the author set out to achieve. Hanretta overburdened the Yacoubist community by making its history answer a variety of, if not all, historiographical issues in the field of Islam in West Africa regardless of their significance or relevance to the topic. For instance, no one has ever claimed that Islam in West Africa can be understood only through the lens of international networks. Yet Hanretta refers to this as a key issue in the historiography, which he felt compelled to refute. It is also not clear which “anti-modern” reactions of Islamic reform he is contrasting with the Yacoubist community's history. The fact that there is no bibliography makes it difficult for the reader to assess the literature Hanretta is engaging when he makes such claims.
In short, this is a clever work that reflects the author's exceptional analytical skills and highly critical mind. It offers new and fresh insights into the relationship between Islamic thought and sociopolitical changes in 20th-century West Africa. However, it provides new frameworks of inquiry more than it answers a particular question or set of questions and could have benefited from better organization, a more focused historiographic discussion, and simpler language.
