In Richards v. Kiken, plaintiff Katherine Richardson Richards (“Richards”) filed a complaint with a demand for a trial by jury on all issues presented against defendant Dr. Michael S. Kiken (“Kiken”). The complaint alleges that Dr. Kiken “medically raped” Ms. Richards at least twice. Ms. Richards claims that Dr. Kiken breached his fiduciary duty to her by using his own sperm, without her knowledge or consent, to impregnate her rather than the sperm of an anonymous donor that he had promised to use, and by continuing to hide that he was the biological father of her children. The complaint includes twenty-two claims including: two battery claims, two intentional fraud claims, two breach of fiduciary duty claims, and two intentional infliction of emotional distress claims. The initial case management conference is set for Monday, December 7, 2020 at 2 p.m. before Honorable Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers of the United States District Court for the Northern District of California via Zoom.
I. THE RICHARDS’ CASE
In 1978, Ms. Richards and her husband went to Dr. Kiken for help because they could not conceive a child on their own.Footnote 1 After being physically examined and tested for infertility, the couple was told by Dr. Kiken that they were struggling to conceive because of male-factor infertility.Footnote 2 In accordance with Dr. Kiken’s advice, Ms. Richards and her husband decided that Ms. Richards would undergo an artificial inseminationFootnote 3 procedure using sperm from an anonymous donor.Footnote 4
Ms. Richards agreed to be artificially inseminated by an anonymous sperm donor so long as the following conditions were met:
(1) The sperm would come from a sperm bank; (2) the sperm would be from an anonymous donor who would never know Plaintiff’s identity; (3) the donor would be a medical student or medical intern (which they understood to mean he would be in the age range of approximately 22–28); (4) the donor would physically resemble Plaintiff’s husband; (5) the donor would share a similar ethnic background as Plaintiff’s husband; (6) the donor would be in excellent health; (7) the sperm specimen would be medically screened and cleared; (8) the donor would have above-average intelligence; (9) the donor would have musical ability as Plaintiff’s husband did; and (10) the donor would share their Christian faith.
Id. at 13. Dr. Kiken promised Ms. Richards and her husband that the conditions stated above would be met.Footnote 5
Ms. Richards’ husband had hazel eyes and a pinkish skin tone.Footnote 6 He was 5’11 and had an athletic build.Footnote 7 His family was Norwegian, Irish, and English, and they were Christians.Footnote 8 He was also musically gifted.Footnote 9 In comparison, Dr. Kiken was shorter than Ms. Richards’ husband and was slender.Footnote 10 He had brown eyes and an olive complexion.Footnote 11 He was in his late 30s, and thus did not fall into the standard 22-28 age range a standard medical student or intern would be in.Footnote 12 Dr. Kiken’s family was Jewish and he did not have a similar family background to Ms. Richards’ husband.Footnote 13
Ms. Richards became pregnant on her second round of artificial insemination and gave birth to a daughter in 1980.Footnote 14 Dr. Kiken told Ms. Richards and her husband that they could not tell anyone that they used a donor’s sperm unless there was a severe medical emergency. He also told them that if there was an emergency and their child was in danger, “the donor’s medical information would be provided by the sperm bank by referencing the donor ‘number.’”Footnote 15
Ms. Richards and her husband eventually went back to Dr. Kiken because they wanted to conceive a second child with the anonymous donor they had used before.Footnote 16 Dr. Kiken told them that he had saved the donor’s “number,” and could thus use the same donor to help them conceive their second child.Footnote 17 In 1981, Ms. Richards conceived a son, and Dr. Kiken allegedly led Ms. Richards and her husband to believe that their son was conceived from the same anonymous, healthy, young medical student or intern they had used before.Footnote 18
In 2019, Ms. Richards’ daughter received a 23andMe DNA kit as a gift.Footnote 19 The results of the test revealed that aside from her full-brother, who was Ms. Richards’ son, she also had a half-brother.Footnote 20 Furthermore, the results showed that she was 50% Irish and French and 50% Ashkenazi Jewish, and that she was a carrier for Tay Sachs, which is a rare and serious genetic condition that is often passed through people with Jewish heritage.Footnote 21
Ms. Richards was shocked when she learned about the results of the test because she believed Dr. Kiken representations that the sperm donor was Christian, in excellent health, and “medically cleared.”Footnote 22 At this time, she did not know nor did she suspect that Dr. Kiken used his own sperm to impregnate her.Footnote 23
Around the same time Ms. Richards’ daughter received her results from 23andMe DNA, she was having serious health issues and needed to find out information about her family medical history, including the sperm donor’s medical history, in order to explore treatment options.Footnote 24 Because Dr. Kiken had previously told Ms. Richards and her husband that they would be able to access the sperm donor’s medical information if their child was in danger, Ms. Richards contacted Dr. Kiken for help.Footnote 25 She sent him a letter and asked for help in accessing information about the sperm donor’s medical history; however, Dr. Kiken did not respond.Footnote 26 Ms. Richards contacted him again via phone and left a voicemail, but he did not call her back.Footnote 27
During this time, Ms. Richards had her son’s DNA tested.Footnote 28 The results showed that he and his sister were full siblings, and thereby confirmed that the same donor sperm was used to conceive both of them.Footnote 29 A genealogist helped Ms. Richards’ daughter as she searched for information on her genetic history in different online databases.Footnote 30 According to results from the database, Ancestry.com, Dr. Kiken was Ms. Richards’ children’s biological father and his parents were their biological grandparents.Footnote 31 Ms. Richards’ children were also found to be genetically related to Dr. Kiken’s cousins.Footnote 32 According to what genealogists believe, “the centimorgans, which are the units in which DNA is measured and passed on, that are shared by Dr. Kiken and Ms. Richard match what a child of Dr. Kiken would be expected to have.”Footnote 33 As such, there is a very small chance that the genetic similarities between Ms. Richards’ children and Dr. Kiken and his family are simply a result of intermarriage between the two families.Footnote 34
On September 16, 2020, Ms. Richards filed a complaint in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California against Dr. Kiken and demanded a jury trial for all the issues stated in the complaint.
Ms. Richards maintains that Dr. Kiken medically raped her at least twice,Footnote 35 when he intentionally used his own sperm, without her knowledge or consent, to impregnate her in 1979 and in 1981.Footnote 36 She alleges that this contact was “unlawful, harmful, and offensive,” and caused her to suffer “severe and debilitating damages as a result.”Footnote 37 Furthermore, Ms. Richards alleges that Dr. Kiken disregarded the conditions that she and her husband had set forth and broke his promise to fulfill those conditions by using his own sperm, without her knowledge or consent, to impregnate her.Footnote 38 She alleges that he violated his fiduciary duty and oath as a physician by inserting his own sperm into her,Footnote 39 and she maintains that she would not have agreed to use sperm from someone who carried the Tay Sachs gene.Footnote 40
Furthermore, Ms. Richards alleges that as a result of Dr. Kiken’s repetitive transgressions, her trust and life have been crushed and she has suffered from physical symptoms, including severe and devastating anxiety and emotional pain.Footnote 41 Ms. Richards’s maintains that at the time Dr. Kiken committed the transgressions, he was in a professional and commercial relationship with her and fraudulently and knowingly hid from her what he had done in order to avoid being held liable for his wrongdoings.Footnote 42
Ms. Richards argues that because of Dr. Kiken’s fraud, concealment, and failure to disclose the truth even though he was in a doctor-patient relationship with her and had a duty to do so, “she did not know nor could she have known in the exercise of reasonable care” that Dr. Kiken used his own sperm to impregnate her twice without her permission.Footnote 43 Therefore, Ms. Richards argues that her cause of action did not accrue until she learned what Dr. Kiken had done through her daughter’s investigation into the identity of the sperm donor.Footnote 44 She also maintains that by refusing to acknowledge that he is the father of her children now, Dr. Kiken’s actions constitute ongoing fraud.Footnote 45 She claims that Dr. Kiken’s conduct was “malicious, oppressive, despicable and/or in reckless disregard [of her] rights,” and that by “using the same sperm to inseminate women living in a small geographic area—where their children may interact without knowing their genetic relation to one another,”Footnote 46 Dr. Kiken actions show that he recklessly disregards the rights of his patients, their children, and the community generally.”Footnote 47
Ms. Richards requests a declaration that Dr. Kiken’s acts and conduct violate California law, a judgment entered in her favor on all claims for relief, full compensatory damages, economic and non-economic damages for pain, suffering, mental anguish, emotional distress, humiliation, and inconvenience that she has suffered and will reasonably suffer in the future, punitive damages, forfeiture and disgorgement of the professional fees she paid to Dr. Kiken, restitution, a copy of Dr. Kiken’s personal health history, pre-and post-judgment interest awarded at the highest lawful rate, and all other relief in law or equity that she is entitled to and that the court finds to be equitable, just, or proper.Footnote 48
II. LEGAL IMPLICATIONS
The increase use of at-home DNA kits from companies such as Ancestry.com and 23andMe have led people who were conceived through artificial insemination to uncover that their mothers had been artificially inseminated, without their knowledge or consent, by their fertility doctors.Footnote 49 Fertility doctors who inseminate their patients with their own sperm without the patients’ consent or knowledge commit “fertility fraud.”Footnote 50 This practice is morally and ethically wrong because of a doctor’s engagement in an act that “exploits his patients’ ignorance, trust, intense desire to conceive, and vulnerability.”Footnote 51
With the increase use of mail-in DNA kits, it is likely that more fertility fraud cases will be exposed.Footnote 52 As such, there needs to be laws that award damages to victims of this crime and enforce severe punishments to deter this kind of wrongdoing. In the past, states have failed to protect its citizens from fertility fraud because of the lack of legislation criminalizing the act.Footnote 53
Currently, California, Indiana and Texas are among the few states that have laws that criminalize fertility fraud.Footnote 54 Indiana was forced to create a law that makes it a felony to use sperm to inseminate patients without the donor and recipients’ knowledge after several 23andMe at-home ancestry tests taken in 2014 revealed that Dr. Donald Cline, a fertility doctor in Indianapolis, had used his own sperm to impregnate his patients during the 1970s and 1980s without their knowledge or consent.Footnote 55 DNA tests have linked Dr. Cline to fifty-seven children of his former patients.Footnote 56 At the time prosecutors examined Dr. Cline’s case, there was no federal or state law that prohibited Dr. Cline’s act, thus, he was only charged with two counts of felony obstruction of justice. In the end, he was only fined $500 and lost his medical license even though he had already retired.Footnote 57
Currently, Indiana’s Senate Bill 174 allows patients, their spouse, their surviving spouse and their children to file a civil cause of action for fertility fraud against health care providers who treated the patient for infertility and used their own sperm to inseminate the patient without their patient’s informed consent.Footnote 58 This bill provides everyone who was affected by a physician’s wrongful and dishonest action the opportunity to seek damages that include: reasonable attorney’s fees, the cost of the fertility treatment, and compensatory or punitive damages.Footnote 59 While the bill states that a civil cause action for fertility fraud has to be brought no later than ten years after the child turns eighteen, or twenty years after the procedure was performed, it also allows the cause action for fertility fraud to be brought within five years of any of the following events: the victim finds sufficient evidence to bring an action against the doctor through DNA, the victim becomes aware of a recording that provides evidence sufficient to bring an action against the doctor, or the physician confesses to the offense.”Footnote 60 The enactment of this bill represents a major development in state legislation that criminalizes fertility fraud.
Unlike Indiana, Texas law classifies fertility fraud as a type of sexual assault.Footnote 61 Notably, last year Governor Abbott signed into law Senate Bill 1259, which states that a doctor who performs procedures using reproductive material from a donor that the patient did not consent to can be charged with sexual assault.Footnote 62 It imposes a two-year statute of limitations that allows people to bring a lawsuit for this type of sexual assault two years from the date the offense was discovered.Footnote 63 The law only applies to offenses that were committed on or after September 1, 2019, which is the effective date of the Act. Footnote 64
Similar to Indiana and Texas’s fertility fraud laws, under California Penal Code 367g, individuals are not allowed to knowingly implant sperm during an artificial insemination procedure “into a recipient who is not the sperm, ova, or embryo provider, without the signed written consent of the sperm, ova, or embryo provider and recipient.”Footnote 65 Originally, the statute of limitations in fertility fraud crimes required that a lawsuit be brought three years from the time the crime occurred; however, Assembly member Maienschedin passed act AB 2014 in 2020 to allow victims to file a medical misconduct lawsuit for the misuse of sperm one year after the victim discovered the crime occurred or within one after the offense could have reasonably been discovered.Footnote 66 AB 2014 unfortunately will only apply to crimes that are committed on or after January 1, 2021, and to crimes “for which the statute of limitations that was in effect before January 1, 2021, has not run as of January 1, 2021.”Footnote 67
Because of the nature of this crime and the clear violation of a woman’s trust in her doctor, there needs to be laws in every state that criminalize fertility fraud and categorize it as a type of sexual assault. States should make sure that their laws will hold doctors who committed fertility fraud decades ago accountable for their actions. Indiana and Texas currently have laws that allow victims of fertility fraud to file a lawsuit against a fertility doctor a certain number of years after they discovered the harm occurred. States should use these laws as a model when trying to develop their own laws that will hold physicians accountable for the transgressions they committed decades ago. Ideally, the law should allow all the victims of the fertility fraud, including the patient who was inseminated, her spouse, and her children who were the product of the fertility procedure, to bring a cause action for fertility fraud within five years of any of them discovering sufficient DNA evidence to bring the action against the doctor and becoming aware of a recording that provides evidence sufficient to bring an action against the doctor.Footnote 68
In addition, states developing fertility fraud laws should follow Texas’s example and classify fertility fraud under sexual assault. Women who are inseminated with their doctor’s sperm without their knowledge or consent are victims of sexual assault because they did not consent to being inseminated with that sperm.Footnote 69 Here, Ms. Richards alleges that she was medically raped at least twice on two separate occasions by Dr. Kiken. Ms. Richards maintains that she wanted to be artificially inseminated by sperm from an anonymous donor that had certain characteristics and similarities to her husband. By injecting his own sperm into her, without her consent or knowledge, Dr. Kiken took away Ms. Richards’ option to be inseminated with the anonymous sperm donor she wanted to use.
Although people argue that fertility fraud does not constitute sexual assault, other experts, like Dr. Jody Maderia assert that “when a physician masturbates to produce a sample in one examination room, and then immediately uses that sample to inseminate a patient in another room, the boundaries are blurred between the clinical procurement of a biological sample and the sexual touching associated with masturbation, orgasm, and ejaculation.”Footnote 70 Therefore, because sexual stimulation is needed in order to produce the bodily fluids that are inserted into a patient without her knowledge or consent, California and other states need to expand their definition of sexual assault to include fertility fraud so that doctors who used their power to take advantage of their patients’ trust during “a procedure that is very intimate both physically and emotionally” can be held accountable for their intentional and reckless conduct.Footnote 71
Women who go to fertility doctors for help with conceiving a child place their trust and confidence in their doctors. States should have an interest in protecting its citizens from doctors who prey on a woman’s desperation to become a mother because doctors who take advantage of their patients’ helplessness by secretly inserting their sperm into them without their consent commit an act that is both morally and ethically wrong.Footnote 72
