Though part of Cambridge's extensive “Introductions to Literature” series, Jennifer Wallace's The Cambridge Introduction to Tragedy concerns more than how a dramatic text is built. In fact, Cambridge's whole series is perhaps misnamed. Labeled as “introductions” and vigorously releasing titles since 2002, the series in fact introduces a range of more specialized topics, including genres, methods of scholarship, and modes of artistic creation. The volumes are all positioned as textbooks, so Wallace writes with a purposefully accessible tone and includes deliberately reflective passages on the project of writing a textbook.
Because Wallace conceives of tragedy in cultural terms as much as generic terms, many pathways open through theatrical manifestations labeled as “tragedy.” Wallace titles her first chapter “Approaching the Subject” and begins by laying out the tensions between aesthetic and experiential definitions of tragedy, firmly indicating the ethical consequences inherent if tragedy is “a matter of response, rather than purely aesthetic structure” (5). This raises useful questions about how and when the label “tragedy” conveys information about form, content, or the reactions of spectators, individually or in groups.
Wallace proposes that tragedy is “the art form created to confront the most difficult experiences we face: death, loss, injustice, thwarted passion, despair” and argues that the “staging of tragic drama should be essential to thinking about the metaphysics of tragedy” (1, 9). To this end, she highlights the way that tragedies often attempt to stage the un-stageable. Contemplating theatre as “‘the place for watching things,’” she therefore positions tragedy as a form that allows audiences to “bear witness” to sorrow, suffering, and desperation, framed within an economy of cultural consumption and political events, noting not only that “this activity is something we are prepared to pay money for, something that we traditionally admire,” but also that tragic drama seems to be produced most plentifully in periods “when beliefs are changing, when there is a shift in values, when politics seem unstable” (1, 8). Wallace's opening chapter proved so decisive in setting the agenda of a class on contemporary tragedy when I assigned it, that up until the day of the final exam, we consistently returned to her definitions and questions, especially the byplay of aesthetic and social definitions, the ethics of shock, the ambiguity of tragic effects, and the dynamics of bearing witness (or staging something for others to bear witness to) as a vindication of why theatre matters.
After the first chapter, the textbook template becomes more apparent. Wallace provides a condensed but still rigorous reading of major periods and authors of tragic drama in Chapter 2, focusing partly on authors and partly on period or geographical groupings. She includes a section on “the Greeks” and one that pairs Seneca and Racine for an exploration of reason and passion from two different directions. Shakespeare stands in his own section, whereas Wallace groups Ibsen, Strindberg, and Chekhov under the rubric of “Romantic Tragedy.” She likewise combines O'Neill, Albee, Miller, Williams, August Wilson, and Tony Kushner in the section on “American Tragedy.” Her section on “Postcolonial Tragedy” takes a different tactic, discussing Wole Soyinka and Athol Fugard as representative of the designation and considering the “alternative tradition” of Japanese nōh theatre and its influence on Western modernists as part of a global conversation about tragedy. Her last section on tragic drama returns to a single-author focus, essentially using Samuel Beckett as a proxy for discussing valences of modernism and postmodernism by arguing that comic absurdism carries a tragic vision.
The comparative level of compression from Chapter 2 on drama to Chapter 3 on tragic theory is striking. The former, at almost double the length of the latter, has space to expand readings of specific plays while setting periods or groups of authors in well-defined contexts. The theory overview in the third chapter, however, works entirely in the mode of précis, succinctly distilling key points and elements of vocabulary from Aristotle, Hegel, Nietzsche, Kierkegaard, Camus, and Girard. Here her effort to address an undergraduate audience shows; nonetheless, the summary still exceeded the ability of many of my undergraduates, who synthesized these readings primarily as sources for epigraphs to their papers. My graduate students, meanwhile, noted that three philosopher-critics who undergird Wallace's masterful introduction—Terry Eagleton, Peter Szondi, and Miguel de Unamuno—are omitted.
Both the drama and theory sections end with a set of case studies, which, along with the introduction, are the most successful syntheses of the book. Case studies on physical violence and language end Chapter 2, while case studies on fate, politics, and gender close Chapter 3. These sections feature sophisticated examples, such as a discussion of dismemberment that seamlessly links aspects of Artaud, King Lear, The Duchess of Malfi, The Bacchae, and Sarah Kane's Blasted, and allow Wallace to work through the heritage of Darwin, Brecht, and Freud in relation to tragedy.
Wallace's fourth chapter stakes the book's claim that tragedy is not simply a formal or textual issue. Wallace considers tragic themes and modes found in visual culture, novels, films, psychoanalysis, and theology. This chapter suggests a wide range of cognates to the concerns of tragic theatre, but these are not well integrated into the rest of the work. Some discussion about dramatic tragedy and nondramatic tragedy might have provided a compelling subject for one of Wallace's reflexive passages about the work of writing about tragedy.
Chapter 5, “Coda: Tragic Sites,” gestures toward this reflexivity, proposing that particular places take on tragic resonances—battlefields, concentration camps, memorials, and human bodies themselves—and that these sites are part of what theatre represents when it stages tragedy. In this final chapter, Wallace hits a grace note about the intertwined issues of “event and representation” and about the dynamics of the “act of participation or the act of witnessing” (192), so that when my class finished reading the text, they felt they had gotten somewhere: perhaps right back to where they had begun, but with more insight. We were more than thoroughly introduced to tragedy, and my students were convinced that tragedy matters.
