Mark LeVine is a “musician–activist–academic” troubadour, and his book reflects a genre of work that combines solid analysis with advocacy. He is a scholar but by no means detached. He speaks Arabic, Hebrew, Turkish, Persian, French, Italian, and German and has traveled extensively in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA). He is also a conceptual thinker who seems quite at ease with empirical and statistical materials. Moreover, he has met, conversed, and played with a significant number of cultural, political, and intellectual figures in the MENA region. Above all, he is both a promoter and critic of what he refers to as “the global peace and justice movement.” He is currently a professor of history at the University of California, Irvine. Thus, the book is a composite of LeVine's analytic perspective, personal experiences, and normative preferences; it is a panoramic exposition of culture, politics, and economics in the contemporary MENA. The stated purpose of the book is to show how neoliberal globalization contributes to the perpetuation of tyranny, violence, and corruption in the MENA, and he examines a cluster of tangible and intangible variables to make his case. He takes us so deep into the labyrinthine of globalization that the reader might have to struggle to remain focused on the message. He never fails, however, to show the relevance of his excursion trips in the journey and their connection to his main themes.
LeVine argues that “the peoples of the region have to fight two battles simultaneously: against their own despotic and corrupt governments, and against the larger ‘world’ financial system” (p. 157). As an example of this double challenge, he provides empirical evidence to show the connection between the rise of oil prices and the increase in weapons exports to the region. He makes a credible case to demonstrate that “the political and economic systems of the region are determined in crucial ways by an arms–petrodollar cycle that can only function in an environment devoid of peace, justice, democracy, and autonomous development” (p. 156). His analysis of the war in Iraq is a must read. It is vastly different from the official story and the mainstream media coverage of the conflict, for he places the war in the context of the Bush administration's decision to use Iraq as a laboratory for its neoliberal design to remake the political economy of the Middle East region
LeVine maintains that young Muslims are best positioned to join the global struggle for peace and justice, but the cultural imperialism of the economically progressive Western activists makes it difficult for them to identify with the movement. “What makes this situation worse,” he writes, “is that while the peace movement finds it difficult to bring Muslim youth more actively into its activities, it leaves the door open to extremists Muslim religious movements which are doing increasingly well at recruiting young Muslims in the absence of a positive alternatives” (p. 267). He is critical of the European and North American supporters of the “global peace and justice movement” for wanting Muslims to be more like us… discard their veils and “assimilate to the dominant Western culture of the protest movement” (p. 271). As important, he writes, “while ‘we’ make demands (however subconsciously) on our Middle Eastern comrades to be more like us, many more of us would do well to learn Arabic, Persian, Turkish or Hebrew and go live in the Middle East, learn the cultures and bring back that knowledge to use for the larger movement” (p. 272).
It is indeed the case that, after the collapse of Eastern socialism and secular nationalism in the Islamic world, extremist Islam has become an appealing alternative for Muslim youth. The discussion of culture in the book is the key to its overall analysis. The socialist and nationalist ideologies of the post World War II period focused on national self-determination and economic justice without disturbing the native culture. Today, challenge to cultural norms and taboos is central to politics and social change in the MENA countries. From a secular or human-rights perspective, one can view this challenge as a positive development in the long run; but for the time being, it is a major impediment to the advancement of peace and democracy in the region. LeVine's analysis of culture change, in relation to both globalization and native traditional sensibilities, is the most important contribution of his book to our understanding of contemporary upheavals in the Middle East and North Africa.
LeVine regards the U.S. media coverage of Islam to be often superficial or distorted and provides a historically informed portrayal of Islam as a religion or cultural system that, like other major religions, lends itself to diverse and evolving interpretations. He does this both conceptually and empirically. What makes his observations unique and instructive is his ability to combine his personal experiences as a traveler in the Arab/Islamic world with an impressive knowledge of the history and cultures of the region's peoples and states. His style of writing ranges from providing statistical evidence to show how the policies of the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund, and the World Trade Organization impact the lives of ordinary people to creative storytelling about musicians, preachers, and gay and lesbian dancers in a Beirut nightclub. This variation in LeVine's narrative shows that his iconoclastic book is a product of scholarly research as well as journalistic dispatches from Iraq, Israel, Palestinian territories, Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, Turkey, and Morocco. He has interviewed senior international political figures, discussed the Qurءan with Muslim Brothers, lived next door to Hamas mosques, dodged terrorist bombs, and performed from Woodstock to Damascus Gate. He is the kind of hybrid analyst who can blend scholarship, journalism, and art with an impressive command over his subjects. Few readers would agree with all of his views, but even fewer could fail to appreciate his edifying and revealing insights.
