Credited as one of the main architects of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Ayatullah Murtaza Mutahhari (1920–79) is the focus of his devout student Mahmood Taqizadeh Davari's new monograph. In this rather short but abundantly documented book, the sociology lecturer from the University of Qum introduces this prominent Shiʿi scholar–theoretician of the last third of the 20th century to the West. The book explores the major aspects of Mutahhari's political activities and the philosophy that guided them, which, according to the author, was based on “Islamic universalism” (p. 165). The nonspecialist may appreciate this work less, for it is written with the assumption that the reader already appreciates the intricate world of Shiʿi ideology that shapes the society's economics, women's rights, politics, and religion. Davari believes that Mutahhari's theorization, critical to the foundation of the Islamic republic, is important to understand because, first, it is all encompassing, hence affecting every aspect of human life, and, second, because it is not solely based on ʿaql (reason) or on strict interpretations of Islamic texts but derives from a combination of the two.
Several works about Mutahhari were published in Persian and English after his assassination, but what makes Davari's book unique is the combination of his academic background in the West and at the Hauzih-yi ʿIlmiyih-yi Qum, which enables his apt use of almost all of Mutahhari's writings. The author claims that Mutahhari's theory of an ideal Islamic state provides its own specific economic system, social values, political paradigms, and women's rights. Its economic system is presented as a mixture of socialism and capitalism that rejects usury. In addition, Mutahhari's interpretations of vilāyat-i faqīh and his adamant call for safeguarding the Islamic republic from the vice of secularists are argued to stand at the core of his political and philosophical ideas.
Another positive aspect of the book is the author's historical narration of important events, such as the oil nationalization, the birth of key groups such as the Fadaiyin-i Islam and the Marxist Tudeh party, and the struggle among different Islamist groups. Along with analyzing Mutahhari's books, articles, interviews, and lectures, Davari uses memorial speeches, interviews, obituaries, private and published memoirs, and biographies delivered and written by different prominent figures, including Ayatullah Ruhullah Khomeini.
Davari states that Mutahhari considered the mujtahedīn to be “religious champions” whose knowledge should guide the society in ethical, political, economic, and social affairs (p. 15). Accordingly, no figures influenced Mutahhari more than Ayatullah Mirza Ali Aqa Shirazi, Hussain Ali Montazeri, and Ruhullah Khomeini. However, this devotion did not mean blind obligation to implement every aspect of their political agenda. For example, Mutahhari, as the author argues, did not support or believe in Montazeri's militancy in establishing an Islamic state. Mutahhari was a theoretician who strongly believed in progress and modernization but who maintained an Islamic paradigm that relied on public education in place of violence. This is why, it seems, although he was a friend of the militant group Fadaiyin-i Islam, he never supported its violent actions. Khomeini and his vilāyat-i faqīh influenced Mutahhari in the formation of his core theory. Davari believes that this connection later helped him become Khomeini's most trusted consultant before and after the 1979 revolution.
The author places Mutahhari, and a small number of other clerical figures, squarely in the middle of the struggle against Muhammad Reza Pahlavi's tyrannical regime and directly at odds with Dr. Ali Shariati, whom some in the West consider the ideological father of the Islamic Revolution. Davari effectively demonstrates how the fundamental difference between the clerical establishment that Mutahhari represented and the Islamic intellectual circle that Shariati represented led to their opposition and separation while they both lectured at Hussainiyih-i Irshad. Mutahhari rejected Shariati's idea of a utopian society that mixed socialist and Marxist theories into a Shiʿi model that gave no political role to clerics. According to Davari, in a letter to Khomeini, Mutahhari complained that because Shariati remained ignorant of the “indisputable facts of the Quran, sunnat, maʿārif and fiqh” he should not use them in the formation of his ideas and should rather stick to the theories he learned in the West (p. 46).
This book is definitely an important addition to the list of works about Mutahhari and Shiʿi political thought, including Michael Fischer and Mehdi Abedi's Debating Muslims (1990), Farhad Nomani and Ali Rahnema's Islamic Economic Systems (1994), and Hamid Dabashi's Theology of Discontent (1993). It is certainly a strong contribution to the field, and any library specializing in Iran, the Islamic Revolution, Islamic thought, or politics in Shiʿi Islam should obtain a copy of it.
There is room for improvement, however. Important claims come without proper references. Davari's suggestion that Westernized women before the 1979 revolution liked and adopted Mutahhari's preference of an up-to-date Islamic covering of scarf and manteau is not sufficiently supported, and neither is his claim regarding the people's “increased propensity. . .towards a religiously based lifestyle” in the early 1970s (p. 54). In addition, smoother transitions between historical narrative and analysis would have made the book much more engaging. Despite these issues, Davari has surely contributed significantly to the study of Islam, Shiʿi Islam, and Iran.
