Among the Native American civilisations noted for their roadways are the Inca (and their Nasca predecessors), the Anasazi and the Maya. What student of ancient American culture has not encountered the popular question: why did these people build roads if they did not have a wheel? Save for a special section of the journal Ancient Mesoamerica in 2001, only the Maya roadways, the so-called sacbe (literally ‘white road’ in Yucatec Maya, plural sacbeob), have lacked thorough treatment, until now.
Archaeologist Justine Shaw's White Roads of the Yucatán focuses on the Cochuah region of the east-central portion of north Yucatán, where a large number of these straight, elevated, plastered causeways dart across the landscape. They can be up to 110 kilometres in length and up to 15 metres in width, and they are elevated as much as three meters above the surrounding terrain. Bringing together archaeological data from Ichmul and Yo'okop, two regional capitals, Shaw addresses the general question of why the Maya needed to build, modify and alter such structures at different times.
Two descriptive chapters on the archaeology of the two sites follow an opening chapter that reviews previous studies. At Ichmul, two sets of roadways radiate out from the centre. These were constructed during the Terminal Classic period (850–1100 CE), when the site had reached peak population, accompanied by a consequent effort to integrate outliers that previously may not have been closely related to the regional capital. The same appears to hold true for Yo'okop, which lies on the south-eastern periphery of the Cochuah region, although the arrangement of sacbeob is somewhat different.
Three chapters deal, respectively, with sacbe construction, types and variations. There are inter-site causeways that leave one site, pass through lower-density occupation zones and arrive at another site, as well as intra-site causeways that cover a short distance within a given zone of occupation. Shaw attributes the sacbeob's dead-straightness, mirrored in many contemporary roads in north Yucatán, to pure efficiency in transporting goods. Excavating along the inter-site causeways breathes life into these overgrown lines of communication, revealing resting places, shrines, equipment storage facilities and even an ancient five-ton stone roller once used by a road repair gang of corvée labourers. Systemic variations range from linear (non-hierarchical or implying an equal relationship among loci) and cruciform (appropriating the cardinal directions) to radial and dendritic systems, the latter resembling the radial except that interconnected sides are positioned in concentric rings about the point of emanation.
The next two chapters deal with function and the issue of why some cities built sacbeob and others did not. To transport ideas, people and goods – that is, for economic reasons – would seem to be the obvious explanation, at least for the narrower, dendritic road plan. Another would be that politics are manifested and power exerted through controlling territory and setting up tribute routes. Water management also figures in the picture. Early colonial observers had alluded to ritual, especially processionals and pilgrimages, as a major function of sacbeob. Like some of the Nasca lines and certain Anasazi roads, these are often wider than they need to be for basic transport of goods. The short intra-site causeway that slices through Labna and the kilometric Uxmal–Kabah inter-site sacbe, each ending in a great arch, come to mind. Like the grand plan of Teotihuacan, Cuzco, and even Washington DC, such roadways and axes often incorporated celestially based referents, thus serving as an expression of the integration of social and cosmic order.
Shaw is modest about the capacity of her database to address the presence/absence question, which is complicated by the fact that there may be overgrown causeways that have gone undetected in many areas and consequently have not yet been surveyed. Rather, she wisely deploys her evidence to answer a more accessible question, which she deals with in the final two chapters: when a sacbe was ‘built, used and maintained, what factors may have conditioned this investment?’ (p. 134).
Taken together, the chronological, ceramic, epigraphic and climatological evidence points to the Terminal Classic as a time of rapid change. The rulers of Ichmul and Yo'okop needed to build causeways as a mechanism of social integration. In hard times, sacbeob could offer a means of transport of agricultural products. They could also assist in revivifying a political environment in which the regional capital had begun to lose its influence. Finally, a symbolic function connecting core and periphery seems evident, especially in a large burial-related complex at Ichmul; the presence of sacbeob here suggests that it likely functioned as a ritual centre dedicated to ancestor worship. In like manner, when their empire had become unwieldy, the Aztecs reached out to peripheral tributaries around the Lake Texcoco basin by permitting segments of their rituals dedicated to the months of the year to be conducted at these outliers. For this they needed no roadways, as water transport across the lakes served their purpose. Ichmul's capacity for innovation likely elevated that site to greater importance than Yo'okop, which maintained a more ‘international’ outlook (p. 165), importing more ceramics and elements of architectural style, Shaw concludes.
In both cases the regional centres of Cochuah depended on sacbeob to successfully navigate their rather depressed populace through different kinds of troubled waters. White Roads of the Yucatán thus exhibits considerable appeal to those interested in the study of road systems of other civilisations and in core and periphery relations as a vehicle for social integration in general.
