For the past three decades, critics of the diffusionist model of science in popular culture have consistently argued that the production of knowledge does not end at the lab's doorstep, but continues well beyond, in public forums. Reflecting on these travels of knowledge, Jim Secord came to define science as a form of communication. In his address to the Three Societies' meeting at Halifax in 2004, Secord invited historians of science to provide accounts of those practices that move the outcome of specialist technical work to a wider sociopolitical setting. It is to such a study of expertise that David Kirby invites readers. Along the way he allows for a broadening of our understanding of the notion, by focusing on a public arena, Hollywood studios, different from those (legal courts and political institutions) where expertise has so far been scrutinized.
Lab Coats in Hollywood is an investigation of the communication process between science consultants and filmmakers engaged in the production of such so-called blockbusters as Jurassic Park, Deep Impact or Hulk, popular-entertainment films that make an intensive use of scientific knowledge in their storyline. Here, films are seen as outcomes of this relationship, in which negotiations are conducted over what should or should not appear on screen. Instead of texts to be decoded for their meaning, the films are discussed here as tools with a mediating role in the social process that consists, for scientists, in shaping the public perceptions of science. Throughout the volume, filmmakers are shown enrolling consultant scientists in order to enhance their films' appeal for viewers, whilst retaining authority and control, so that the films remain first and foremost pieces of entertainment capable of achieving box-office success. Conversely, science consultants are shown as happy participants in the endeavour, taking advantage of it to forward their views on science.
Far from being a lamentation over the liberty filmmakers, primarily concerned with preserving the films' entertainment value, sometimes take with scientific accuracy and scientific advice, Kirby's book highlights the positive consequences such multidirectional relationships yield for both filmmaking and the scientific enterprise. It also illustrates the fruitfulness for science students of paying impartial and symmetrical attention to these instances of science in popular culture, if one is to understand how scientific knowledge is deployed in society. The book is thus an important contribution to the literature on science in entertainment media, further asserting the fertility of thinking of science as a set of embodied practices rather than as a body of knowledge.
From science consultants' identities and the practicalities of their participation in the film-making process (Chapter 3), to the impact of films in which they intervene on the development of scientific controversies (Chapter 6), through to the relationship and power differential between filmmakers and consultants on the set, Kirby explores many facets of his topic. And along the way he dispels some preconceived ideas. For instance, Lab Coats in Hollywood suggests that it is no longer damaging for scientists' careers to engage in such instances of popularization. And, significantly, it shows that science consultants are less concerned with ensuring that films contribute to raising scientific literacy than with taking care that films convey what they believe are the appropriate ‘cultural meanings’ of science (Chapter 5). This is illustrated by the discussion (Chapter 4) of how science consultants advise on the performance of science. Highlighting the emphasis consultants place on gestures and bodily behaviour within the working space, this chapter suggests that scientific practitioners perceive science as primarily an embodied activity. And the films appear as means, for science consultants, of articulating their bodies, gestures and identities qua scientific practitioners, in front of the public.
But scientific advisers can also use films to make planetary-scale hypothetical disasters that could be averted by science look plausible (Chapter 8). Or they can take advantage of a film to promote and test in a fictional social world not-yet-existing technologies, the ‘diegetic prototypes’ discussed in Chapter 9. In both cases consultants are enabled to promote, on the silver screen, the equation of technoscience with innovation, creativity and public interest, and to assert the notion that, if appropriately funded and supported, science and technology can be instrumental in overcoming crucial developmental obstacles or even making the world safer.
For a good part based on extensive interviews with consultants, Lab Coats in Hollywood provides many insights into scientific practitioners' perception of entertainment films as media of science communication. It demonstrates the heuristic value of abandoning the diffusionist model of the popularization of science when engaging with such instances of science in popular culture as blockbusters (and entertainment media generally). For, mostly concerned with scientific content and scientific literacy, this model would not permit access to the richness of what is happening during the production process, which is when, beyond scientific facts, beliefs and values about the work and actions of scientific practitioners are attached to the films. As a study of expertise, the book also significantly adds to the definition of the term. For it shows advisers not merely intervening as specialists in their academic field of enquiry, but rather holding authority about science as a way of thinking, which Kirby names the ‘expertise of logic’ (p. 146).
But most of all, what the book underscores is that science consulting in Hollywood is entirely premised on the dominant model of popularization, and that the blockbusters whose production is examined here are perhaps the most efficient vehicles of this model. On the one hand, filmmakers displaying science consultants as publicity material contribute to naturalizing the belief that the physical world is what scientists say it is, and implicitly endow them with authority over what is or is not an appropriate simplification of this knowledge. On the other hand, to consultants, ‘Paris is well worth a Mass’. They would willingly surrender on a scientific fact as long as what they take to be the proper ‘cultural meanings’ of the scientific enterprise are conveyed. Lab Coats in Hollywood thus nicely shows that blockbusters, generally disregarded as inappropriate vehicles for scientific knowledge, are in fact a brilliant promotional tool for the scientific enterprise.
