Every year, thousands of officials and delegates come together to negotiate on global institutions to govern climate change. But do these negotiations produce anything else than hot air? The conventional wisdom holds that they do not.
In political science, frustration with the multilateral climate negotiations has produced a body of research on alternative approaches to the governing of climate change. David Victor's Global Warming Gridlock and Matthew Hoffmann's Climate Governance at the Crossroads are examples of such alternative approaches. While both books focus on alternatives to multilateral negotiations among all countries of the world, they propose very different solutions to the problem at hand.
Victor argues that states can break the global warming gridlock by relying on a strategy based on incremental and credible promises. In Victor's view, the main problem of multilateral climate negotiations is an obsession with global targets and timetables for reducing greenhouse gases. For governments, it is impossible to commit to large emissions reductions over a time span of decades. Consequently, their promises are not credible enough to trigger concrete action. Clean technology is not deployed, developing countries are not engaged, and global emissions are not decreasing. On the basis of this diagnosis, Victor proposes that major emitters promise concrete and immediate action conditional on other major emitters' returning the favor. These promises would be tailored to each major emitter's needs so that they would be credible and politically feasible. They would also be subjected to rigorous verification.
Hoffmann's book examines a diverse set of climate governance “experiments” that have recently emerged in the shadow of the failing multilateral negotiations. Not only states but also cities, firms, religious organizations, provinces, and many other actors have begun to experiment with various approaches to reducing their carbon footprint and deploying clean technology. According to Hoffmann, these experiments help various stakeholders develop creative alternatives to multilateral diplomacy. Given the tremendous complexity of climate change, creative experimentation can help stakeholders learn about effective and ineffective strategies. While it is too early to tell whether these experiments are a game changer, Hoffmann argues that the center of gravity is already shifting from multilateral negotiations to decentralized responses.
Both books have much to commend. Global Warming Gridlock has three major virtues. First, Victor correctly emphasizes the centrality of regulatory capacity in energy policy. In climate policy debates, it is often forgotten that governments cannot directly adjust their country's emissions. A climate policy must be not only politically feasible but also robust to future attacks by its opponents. Energy systems change very slowly, and so noncredible climate policies do not provide the kind of regulatory certainty that is necessary for encouraging energy producers and consumers to invest in clean technologies.
Second, Victor recognizes the central importance of credibility in climate diplomacy. The holy grail of multilateral negotiations has been a legally binding treaty that would set ambitious emissions targets for all countries of the world. Although this goal has not been met, Victor argues that meeting the goal might not do much to mitigate climate change. If the government of a sovereign state promises to reduce emissions by 20% by 2020, why would other governments believe this promise? Enforcing multilateral agreements is notoriously difficult, and so governments should only commit to actions that are readily verifiable and politically feasible. These actions should not be vague long-term targets but specific short-term policy promises.
Finally, Victor highlights the importance of tailoring climate policy commitments to each major emitter's needs. The political and economic challenges of climate policy vary across the globe. Germany faces one set of constraints, the United States another, and China yet another. Without a clear understanding of what these constraints are, and a shared of understanding of what each government can implement, climate policy will remain at an impasse.
Climate Governance at the Crossroads also deserves praise, for at least two reasons. First, to my understanding, Hoffmann is the first to provide a comprehensive overview of climate governance initiatives. While some subsets of the universe of climate governance initiatives, such as US state policy, are well understood, his book brings together the most important types of climate governance initiatives and offers a comparative analysis of them. This comparative analysis provides a useful foundation for future scholarship.
Second, Hoffmann's discussion of the implications of his research for future research and policy is unusually useful. While much of the literature on decentralized climate governance suffers from unwarranted hype and naive optimism, Hoffmann's account is balanced. He recognizes that his analysis cannot address the complex question of effectiveness, and his concluding chapter carefully summarizes challenges for improving the quality of climate experiments. In particular, he recognizes the networked nature of the world of climate experiments and suggests that different experiments could benefit from deeper ties with one another.
Both books also suffer from notable weaknesses, however. I found two aspects of Global Warming Gridlock problematic. First, Victor's explanation for the failure of multilateral climate diplomacy is not particularly convincing. He claims that multilateral diplomacy has gone awry because diplomats “thought global warming was just another environmental problem, but the standard tools of environmental diplomacy don't work well on problems, such as global warming, that require truly independent coordination” (p. 203). In contrast to Victor's realistic analysis of the nature of the global warming problem, this explanation seems quite naive. What about the political power of interest groups that stand to lose from climate policy, such as coal producers? What about the role of the Senate filibuster in killing countless climate policies in the United States? What about the deep distributional conflict between industrialized and emerging countries? What about fundamental disagreements concerning burden sharing? To this reviewer, these factors seem much more fundamental to an understanding of the global warming gridlock than the nostalgia of environmental diplomats.
Second, given Victor's emphasis on credibility, it is ironic that his policy proposals are themselves somewhat vague. What exactly are countries such as China and the United States supposed to promise? For example, it seems difficult to believe that the domestic politics of the United States would allow a large income transfer to China in exchange for reduced use of coal. Similarly, it seems hard to believe that the European Union's promise to reduce emissions or deploy renewable energy would fundamentally change China's political-economic calculus or reduce opposition to climate policy among conservatives in the United States. I may well be wrong here, but Victor's book does little to convince me.
Climate Governance at the Crossroads also suffers from two problems worth mentioning here. First, Hoffmann does not measure the extent to which policymakers are actually learning from climate experiments. Although these climate experiments seem to produce information and the author's interviews confirm this expectation, for a social scientist this is not enough. Hoffmann's book falls short of a rigorous demonstration that climate experiments are actually causing meaningful learning.
Second, while Hoffmann's analysis is strong on the descriptive side, it does not even attempt to develop a theoretical account to explain climate experiments. He never reaches beyond the rather obvious claim that if multilateral negotiations are failing, then interested actors have incentives to act. This is unfortunate because the causes of climate experimentation are central to an evaluation of their effectiveness. If climate experiments are implemented by actors who are fundamentally different from the rest of the world, then it is not at all clear that climate experiments produce useful information for the rest of the world. No amount of experimentation among a small transnational climate elite helps solve the problem unless these experiments somehow influence the behavior of outsiders.
While both books suffer from weaknesses, this is not altogether surprising given the monstrous complexity of the climate change problem. Overall, both books are impressive and should be read by anyone interested in the future of planet Earth.
