With eighty-five essays, The Routledge Companion to Dramaturgy offers comprehensive coverage of dramaturgical theory and practice. “[I]ntended to serve as a primary sourcebook for dramaturgy students, practitioners, and academics” (5), the collection also seeks to “frame dramaturgy in the contemporary context, taking into consideration the new-media revolution and the increasingly interdisciplinary and intermedial nature of performance-based artworks” (5).
The wide range of essays emphasizes versatility and adaptability and the continuing relevance of analytical research processes in professional theatre and education. Contributors address practice from new play development to video game storyboarding, from composition in the university classroom to immersive theatrical experiences in prison barracks, and for performances with dance or puppetry. Reprints of classic essays include “EF's Visit to a Small Planet: Some Questions to Ask a Play” by Elinor Fuchs; “Dramaturging Non-Realism: Creating a New Vocabulary” by Tori Harding-Smith; and “Leadership Advice to a Dramaturgy Student,” by Ann Cattaneo. Other essays touch on the historical genealogy of dramaturgy from Germany to Great Britain to the United States, where “dramaturgy means a comprehensive theory of ‘play making’” (1). The editors include contributors with diverse backgrounds, nationalities, and analytic foundations, from early career scholars and dramaturgs to seasoned professionals. Scholars in Europe, such as András Visky and Marianne Van Kerkhoven, take up dramaturgical analysis from within the particular politics of European communism and neoliberal economics. Several highly respected dramaturgs and scholars in the United States contribute, including Faedra Chatard Carpenter, Adam Versényi, Gwydion Suilebhan, Gitta Honegger, Dassia N. Posner, and many others.
The collection endeavors to clarify the scope of what it means to be a dramaturg or to do dramaturgy. Lawrence Switzky opens his essay, “Dramaturgy as Skill, Function, and Verb,” by claiming “Dramaturgy is a job perennially in search of a description” (173). Switzky insists, “the dramaturg's resistance to specialization is a part of the job: a symbolic reminder of the theatre's enduring refusal to honor rigid distinctions between work and play, and knowing and doing” (174). Even with this somewhat utopian qualification of dramaturgical value, dramaturgs themselves inhabit one of the few roles in professional theatre without collective bargaining power through a labor union. The adaptability of dramaturgy, which Switzky emphasizes as critical to theatre making, may lead to the undervaluing of dramaturgs as artistic professionals.
Vicki Stroich's essay “On Dramaturgy and Leadership” advances that conversation considerably. She provides a matrix of skill sets for dramaturgs, rather than discrete tasks or role-based labor, in categories such as listening and research; interpretation, synthesis, and articulation; and constructive critique. Amy Kenny's essay, “Dramaturgy as Training: A Collaborative Model at Shakespeare's Globe,” provides an additional route toward illuminating roles and values in dramaturgy. Kenny argues that the dramaturgical process participates within the liberal arts tradition of critical thinking, fosters skills necessary to that tradition, and is applicable to many events or contexts.
Internationally focused Parts I and II, “World Dramaturgy in the Twenty-First Century” and “Dramaturgy in the Age of Globalization,” comprise nearly one-third of the volume. Noteworthy essays here include “Dramaturgy in Post-Revolution Iran: Problems and Prospects,” by Marjan Moosavi, and “From Alienation to Identity: Transnational Communication of Russian-Israeli Theatre,” by Miriam Yahil-Wax. The strength of both essays lies in the authors’ close attention to local dramaturgical practices and sociopolitics in globalized networks. The collection includes a wide range of practices and theories from locations in Asia, Europe, and the Middle East. Beyond that, however, only South African and Brazilian dramaturgies appear for continental Africa and the hemispheric Americas. For example, only one essay addresses an indigenous dramaturgical practice: “Collaborative Dramaturgy in Latin American Theatre,” by Margarita Espada. In the future, more practice and scholarship from these areas of the world will broaden historical understandings of narrative and conflict in performance.
Essays on new media dramaturgy, from digital media to intermedial performance, appear throughout, emphasizing the collection's desire to address the contemporary “new-media revolution” (4). Many contributors argue for expanding analysis and conceptualization of narrative. In “Phronesis for Robots: (Re)Covering Dramaturgy as an Interdiscipline,” Michael Chemers applies Aristotle to systemic dramaturgy. He proposes digital “management of narrative systems rather than the plotting of single narrative arcs” (366). Similarly, Klaus P. Jantke's essay, “Dramaturgical Design of the Narrative in Digital Games,” studies the importance of inductive logic and manipulation of time within the structure of a game. Meanwhile, Jodie McNeilly offers a “Method for a New Dramaturgy of Digital Performance,” by proposing a “movement away from prioritizing the play text towards the democratic inclusion of the visual, physical, spatial, sonic, and virtual” (431). Still more essays, such as those by Tanya Dean and LaRonika Thomas, explore the importance of digital media for production research and audience outreach. Overall, the collection makes substantial strides toward including new media analysis and theory under the consideration of dramaturgy.
Many essays model dramaturgical process with in-depth case studies. Highlights here include Jules Odendahl-James's essay “The Science of Dramaturgy and the Dramaturgy of Science,” which explores the experimental process of cocreating knowledge. Another highlight is Kristin Leahey's “The Youth Respondent Method: New Work Development of Theatre for Young Audiences,” which outlines an interactive development process, soliciting and using feedback from prospective audience members to shape the work. Leahey's methods may be useful to theatres wanting to revitalize connections with audiences, or to educators searching for a student-centered and responsive curriculum.
The Routledge Companion to Dramaturgy will prove highly useful in theatre and performance practice, education, and scholarship. Artistic directors, directors of individual productions, and early career and long-time dramaturgs will find support for their artistic missions and new ideas for audience development and outreach. At the college level, undergraduate students will benefit from the insights into text analysis and applications of performance history, while educators will find pedagogical encouragement and inspiration. Finally, scholars of performance and theatre will appreciate the wide-ranging coverage of dramaturgical theory in the rehearsal room and literary classroom.
