What is naturopathy and what has it meant historically? These are the questions guiding Susan Cayleff's intricate exploration of a system of healthcare that has proven to be malleable in meaning. Focusing on America, Cayleff journeys from the emergence of naturopathy in the late nineteenth century to its present incarnation, dissecting the shifts and slips in identity which have seen it veer between a single doctrine and a bundle of ideas and practices unified only through their divergence from ‘orthodox’ biomedicine. Incorporating hydropathy, dietary principles and at various times homeopathy, osteopathy, massage and myriad other practices, the assorted forms of therapy on offer have long made naturopathy vulnerable to accusations of quackery. But underlying it is, Cayleff argues, a core doctrine of ‘vitality, constructive principles, personal responsibility, toxicity, environment, and diet’ that has bound the different therapies together (p. 72). The term ‘naturopathy’ was coined in the 1890s by Benedict Lust, who along with his wife Louisa Stroebele Lust act as Cayleff's chief protagonists. German immigrants who early in their lives had become converts to hydropathy, the Lusts would become architects-in-chief of the naturopathic movement in turn-of-the-century America, establishing a lucrative empire of health food shops, publications (Cayleff is to be commended for the attention she pays to the print culture of naturopathy) and two sanatoriums, primarily financed by the affluent Louisa. Benedict Lust had purposely sought a hybrid word that conveyed the extensive system of well-being he proposed, encompassing not just a method of healthcare – which eschewed the use of drugs or any invasive procedure – but a way of life.
Naturopathy with its emphasis on self-care without the need for expensive therapeutics had clear designs on popular appeal and naturopaths emphasized the power that laypeople wielded within the movement, in direct contrast to the exclusionary and hierarchical universe of mainstream medicine. But it also emerged at a time when cultural changes were exerting pressure upon medical practices that did not conform to convention; the increasingly visible success of the procedures that naturopaths criticized, especially vaccination and surgery, saw the medical profession confirm its authoritative status within society, which was further consolidated through their derogation of alternative forms of healthcare. While most naturopaths generally avoided the use of drugs at all, the American Medical Association's crackdown in the early twentieth century on the selling of patent medicines and nostrums was symbolic of its derision of all forms of ‘quackery’, and the organization pursued with vigour the prosecution of naturopaths, even employing private detectives to help entrap unlicensed practitioners. Increasingly the naturopathic community faced a dilemma: did the key to their success lie in resisting the regulatory attempts of the American Medical Association (AMA)? Or in attempting to mirror them by upping regulation within the movement? Tellingly in 1919 the Naturopathic Society of America changed its name to the American Naturopathic Association, a clear emulation of the AMA. But professionalizing naturopathy also meant trying to merge disparate practitioners of a multitude of therapies. Factionalism continued to underlie the movement and following Benedict Lust's death in 1945 factions turned into veritable fault lines as naturopaths in the western states, led by the Washington-based Robert Carroll, began to vocally endorse the incorporation of orthodox medical science into naturopathy. Subtle linguistic shifts were employed by Carroll and his followers to signpost their position. ‘Drugless’ was phased out and liberal use of the word ‘medicine’ introduced. Conversely the incorporation of medical rhetoric into naturopathy, Cayleff argues, became increasingly matched in the twentieth century by the inclusion of naturopathic ideas within orthodox medicine, where concepts of patient-centredness and humanistic medicine now have increased traction. This apparent professionalization of naturopathy leads Cayleff to conclude that there are parallel histories to be told, narratives of both ‘clarity and acceptance’ and ‘capitulation and cooptation’ (pp. 301–302).
The author was originally invited to write on the history of naturopathic healing by the head of the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians, and she readily admits the shift in her own thinking, initially assuming naturopathy to be ‘an eclectic blend of holistic therapeutics’, before attendance at a naturopathic conference led her to realize it was ‘a philosophy for a way of life’ (p. 1) – the Lusts surely would have approved of such an opinion. To an extent Cayleff's interpretation of naturopathy confirms already widely understood characterizations of medicine in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries: the intersections between different aspects of alternative medicine with other radical causes that she describes, such as anti-vaccination campaigns and the movement for women's rights, are well known, as are the tensions between alternative and mainstream medicines. Nonetheless the book does subject some of the critical points of the binary orthodox/non-orthodox narrative to scrutiny. Cayleff dispels the common notion, for example, that alternative medicine was inherently radical in its treatment of women; naturopaths’ glorification of the maternal role of cook, carer and nurturer – and thus the ideal conduit for the transmission of their ideas – placed the movement on similar gendered ground to that which the medical profession of the late nineteenth century was built upon. Moreover, despite protestations of accessibility and equality from naturopathic healers, Cayleff shows the movement to have been an overwhelmingly white and middle-class one, all but the wealthy priced out of the health resorts which were the centrepiece of the movement. It is here that the ‘everyday’ experience of the consumer of naturopathic goods and services is particularly conspicuous in its absence from the narrative, focused as it is on the Lust's building of the profession and the organizational ruptures that followed. I wanted to know more about the ways in which members of the populace became entwined in the movement. Instead the narrow focus of Cayleff's work means that at times the material feels stretched a little thin.
Regardless, Nature's Path is an informative read germane to our times. Cayleff notes the ever-increasing number of states in the USA now issuing statutes allowing for the licensing of naturopaths. This suggests that the movement is far from moribund and the book provides an important genealogy of the superfoods and toxins that hold sway in contemporary health culture and of the many forms of healthcare outside Western biomedicine that continue to thrive.
