Fintan Walsh's timely and valuable new book opens with a foreword by performance artist Bobby Baker, whose autobiographical work on mental health care issues questions normative classifications of physical and emotional well-being. Baker recounts the “stunned silence” she received at a performance talk in which she asked, “Well all art is therapy, isn't it?” (ix–x). It is this tension between the observing participant and the feeling participant that Theatre & Therapy addresses. If all art is therapy, who, or what, is in control? Walsh contends that “a critical sense of ‘the therapeutic’ allows us to better understand what certain theatre and performance practices attempt to do” (3). That is, when conceived culturally as “the therapeutic,” therapy might be more than a clinical practice; it may be a mode through which agency and well-being are shared in critical and theatrical ways. This book highlights that the intersections between theatre and therapy are more ambiguous than they first appear.
Grounded in a Freudian definition of therapy as a “psychotherapeutic tradition invested in promoting mental and emotional well-being” (2), Theatre & Therapy is divided into four parts. Over the course of these parts, Walsh tracks four critical snapshots of theatre and therapy as they developed together between the late nineteenth century and the present day in Europe and North America: the historical relationship between theatre and early pioneers of therapeutic theory and practice; actor training and audience engagement; the deployment of theatre strategies in clinical settings; and emerging “neo-Aristotelian notions of catharsis” in contemporary participatory performance (6).
In the book's first part, “Theatre and the Therapeutic Tradition,” Walsh suggests that “therapy culture” continues to emerge as a “profiteering industry . . . committed to producing a vast spectrum of neoliberal subjects who believe that there is always something wrong with their emotional lives” (4–5). He unpicks some of the historical ties between theatre and therapy as disciplines for eliciting emotional well-being over roughly the last hundred years, locating the primary nexus of theatre and therapy in the work of psychoanalyst Sigmund Freud, to whom “[m]ost branches of therapy are indebted” (6). In particular, Walsh tracks the complex amalgamation of Greek and Shakespearean tragedy, dreams and fantasy, evolutionary theory, surrealism and naturalism that converge in Freud's work on “psychological” and “psychopathological” suffering, pointing to their contingent, yet no less causal, relations. Walsh then shifts his focus to theatrical events about therapy, which primarily emerged in the latter half of the twentieth century. Here, Walsh suggests, the philosophical tropes of psychoanalytic thought are critiqued explicitly through analysis of the therapist “as character” or, as in the case of Sarah Kane's 4.48 Psychosis (premiered posthumously at the Royal Court in 2000), through their fragmented and “exquisitely wrought language” (28). Walsh's analysis suggests that attention to the historical, material conditions in which therapy developed reveals that making and feeling theatre reconfigures the “therapeutic” as an inherently political maneuver. Deploying the “therapeutic” theatrically provides a space for critical reflection on the human condition and the structures through which we relate to, and come to know, others.
The book's following parts respond to a particular meeting of theatre and psychoanalytic therapy understood as significant to the development of contemporary theatre and performance. In “Actor training and audience engagement,” Walsh pays particular attention to the “haunting” work of the theatre. He uses Daniel Day-Lewis's experience of encountering the ghost of his father whilst playing Hamlet in 1989 at the National Theatre, London, as an example of the effects and affects of psychological engagement with character preparation and development—what Erin Hurley refers to as the “feeling-labour” of theatre (Theatre & Feeling, 9). Focusing on the influence of actor-training systems developed by Konstantin Stanislavsky, Lee Strasberg, and Michael Chekhov within the European and American context, Walsh points to a dualism between physicality and emotional impulse, the paradoxical crux of much actor training and theory: If actors are to produce an authentic representation of a character's state of mind, must they feel those emotions? How do these emotions translate to an audience and beyond the theatrical setting? It is this dualism, he suggests, that “is routinely tested in the use of drama and theatre strategies within therapeutic contexts” (37). In “Drama and Theatre in Therapy,” Walsh negotiates the complex historical development of the application of drama in applied therapy settings with a focus on three key terms: “psychodrama,” “dramatherapy,” and “theatric therapies,” which emerged, predominantly, in Russia, the United Kingdom, and the USA, and in the work of Brazilian theatre maker, politician, and activist Augusto Boal. Though each term is distinct, Walsh understands them (and their emergence) as evidence of the international and transnational reach of theatre in both clinical and community settings, in which spontaneity and playfulness are key components.
The final part of the book, “Therapeutic Dramaturgies and Relations in Contemporary Theatre,” offers, in my opinion, the work's strongest and most compelling argument. Here, Walsh returns more explicitly to the therapeutic qualities of contemporary performance in which physical and emotional intimacy provide a mode through which to critique the potentialities and limitations of theatre's deployment of emotional labor to do social work. Walsh pays close critical (often semiotic) attention to the monologues of Irish playwrights such as Conor McPherson; the autobiographical solo work of Bobby Baker and Ruby Wax; and the intimate participatory work of Adrian Howells and David Hoyle, weaving personal experiences of intimacy, confession, and humiliation in performance settings to suggest that theatre's therapeutic potentials might lie in its ability to “act as powerful physical and emotional ‘holding’ spaces” (64). Such holding spaces are “not mired in the subjective” (71); rather, they are spaces of negotiation between participants, and do important cultural and social work.
Despite the book's brevity, the breadth of research demonstrated by Walsh renders Theatre & Therapy a tremendously useful baseline for further inquiry into an emerging and important area of theatre and performance scholarship. The two middle parts of the book are, however, substantially shorter than its first and last, and Walsh's grounding focus in Freud's scholarship and works produced in Europe and North America inevitably narrows the scope of his inquiry: he does not address, for example, the potentially problematic implications of Western therapeutic praxis in postcolonial contexts. Nevertheless, readers familiar with the Theatre& series, as well as with the burgeoning research in affect theory, copresence, and cognition and health in current theatre and performance scholarship, will be aware of the importance of an introductory text that distinguishes therapy from both cognition and feeling and yet intersects productively and critically with these key concerns. Theatre & Therapy is a valuable and nuanced foundational text for the future study of theatre, therapy, and well-being.
