These essays on heritage tourism in the US South underscore how powerfully the legacies of slavery, the Civil War, and segregation shape the interpretation of the region's historic monuments and sites. A few pieces also address the role of Native Americans and poor whites. Editor Karen L. Cox divides the thirteen essays into four sections, each offering a different approach; the first focusses on sites devoted to famous individuals. Chapters by Hilary Iris Lowe and Kathleen Clark on novelists Mark Twain and Margaret Mitchell, respectively, highlight the conflicts among researchers, local promoters, and tourists over the meaning of these writers' works and lives. Olympic champion Jesse Owens and rock ’n’ roll icon Elvis Presley, Barclay Key and Michael T. Bertrand show, are not heroes to everyone in their hometowns – Owens because he was black and Presley because he was poor.
In the following section on race and slavery, Alisa Y. Harrison demonstrates that the plantation house museum – a mainstay of the southern tourist landscape – celebrates a mythical antebellum era that erases the histories of slavery, emancipation, and postwar economic transformation. African Americans readily challenge such whitewashed narratives, as Ethan J. Kytle and Blain Roberts found in a study of contemporary tours of Charleston, South Carolina, but their counterhistories reach primarily black tourists, not whites. Examining the efforts of white elites in Selma, Alabama to balance competing celebrations of the Confederate past and the civil rights movement, Glenn T. Eskew describes a similarly segregated tourist experience.
Wars revolutionary and civil are the focus of the next three essays. Sarah M. Goldberger notes that Yorktown, a national park that commemorates a critical American victory over British forces in the American Revolution, neglects the role black people played in constructing the park. The decision of an Alabama county's white leaders to make a never-used Civil War-era iron furnace the center of local neo-Confederate tourism, John Walker Davis and Jennifer Lynn Gross reveal, directed attention away from the county's history of violence against African Americans, notably the 1961 firebombing of a bus carrying Freedom Riders. J. Vincent Lowery writes that the aim of Georgia's Stone Mountain is to memorialize the Confederate “Lost Cause,” yet plans to carve a massive sculpture honoring the rebel heroes here have never been fully realized, while local businesspeople have long marketed different “Souths” centered on jazz or country music or the regional cuisine.
The final essays turn to the built and natural environments. Anthony Stanonis shows that the racial and ethnic divides long typical of New Orleans shape its iconic aboveground graveyards as well. Official interpretations of the Great Smoky Mountains National Park first erased history altogether, Richard D. Starnes argues, and then cautiously in the 1970s began to acknowledge the park's agricultural and Cherokee pasts. In closing, Andrew K. Frank shows how Seminoles and Miccosukees were marketed, and increasingly marketed themselves, as the last unconquered Native peoples living in the United States' last unconquered landscape, the Everglades.
A short review cannot capture the complexity of these case studies, each of which makes a valuable contribution. However, the volume as a whole suffers from a narrow framing. Aside from the editor's brief references to some classic works in tourism and a perfunctory review of the history of US pleasure travel, neither she nor the contributors engage with the interdisciplinary scholarship in this field or with tourism outside the United States. Harrison's note on Ireland's commemoration of the Famine (130 n. 5) and Stanonis's on Afro-Brazilian funerary practices (265 n. 48) indicate how a broader context would enrich this book. Perhaps most directly relevant would be heritage tourism in other American nations, all of which have histories of indigenous dispossession, African slavery, and civil rights activism. The scholarship on public memory might have prompted the authors to ask whether the memorialization of a great wrong can ever be both accurate and inclusive, or what the relationship between popular and scholarly histories should be.
One could also wish that the volume had interrogated the idea of “the South.” Except when Lowe calls Mark Twain's home state of Missouri part of the West (21), the question of regional boundaries goes unasked. Moreover, as Lowery writes, an exclusive focus on race may obscure other key themes (223). In short, Destination Dixie deserves the attention of southern historians and students of US tourism. Its relevance to the broader history and theory of tourism remains to be explored.
