This excellent book advances our understandings of Argentine economic and political liberalism during the turbulent years from 1930 to 1950. When read in conjunction with Sandra McGee Deutsch's work on Argentine extreme right-wing movements of the time, The Argentine Right (SR Books, 1993) and Las derechas (Stanford University Press, 1999), as well as Federico Finchelstein's study Transatlantic Fascism (Duke University Press, 2010), Nállim's work fills many, but not all, of the gaps in our understanding of the politicians who formed Argentina's first national political party, the Partido Autonomista Nacional (National Autonomist Party, PAN), and how their ideological descendants fit into conservative politics after 1930.
Liberal groups included sectors of the Socialist Party – a non-Marxist group that included many social reformers and public health physicians – and regional political parties like the Partido Progresista Demócrata (Democratic Progressive Party, PRD) that followed former PAN members, as well as the Unión Cívica Radical (Radical Civic Union, UCR), the second major political party that won presidential elections in 1916. After that date, some politicians joined political coalitions that called themselves conservative, a term that also linked them to many undemocratic groups they ultimately opposed. These parties, in turn, split into different factions based upon personalities and class-based issues. All confronted the realities of populism under the Radical Party, fascism, militarism and ultimately Peronism. They reacted in different ways, leading the author to argue that ‘liberalism did not have a single meaning common to all the different groups that defended it at different moments in the period under examination’ (p. 5). Furthermore, Nállim adds culture and politics to traditional views of liberalism as an economic doctrine so that he can examine literary production of the time and place Argentina in a larger Atlantic context to counter notions of Argentine exceptionalism. His seven chapters analyse chronologically the rise of liberal thought from the independence era to Peronism, with several chapters dedicated to economic liberalism and its variants.
While the liberal PAN ruled Argentina during a period of unprecedented European immigration and great economic expansion and development, by the turn of the nineteenth century its image had become tarnished by political corruption and the great economic crisis of 1890. Unable to share power, the PAN began to fragment and new political parties emerged. The splinter group created in 1890 by Hipólito Yrigoyen, the UCR, shattered liberal hegemony in 1916, and then splintered again into Personalist (pro-Yrigoyen) and Anti-Personalist (pro-Alvear) factions. The Socialist Party, in turn, split on the same grounds into the Socialist Party and the Independent Socialist Party (anti-Yrigoyen). These fractures facilitated the shift from liberalism into a ‘liberal conservatism’, and many political leaders floated in and out of the new parties according to economic conditions and the rise of newly energised groups such as organised labour, the military and the Catholic Church. Eventually historical revisionism, a movement that firmly linked liberalism's embrace of immigration and universal suffrage with now unpopular issues such as foreign investment and the presence of immigrant-based New Left groups including anarchists and communists, found its voice. Similar political transformations were found throughout Europe and the Americas, but Argentines tended to see their political landscape as unique. These views not only became part of the political landscape; they were also found in the works of many writers of the period, especially Ricardo Rojas, who came to admire Spanish authoritarianism.
Events in Spain during the 1920s and 1930s served as a catalyst for both conservatism and liberalism in Argentina. Both Catholic and anti-democratic political and literary groups looked to the dictatorship of Miguel Primo de Rivera in the 1920s and hailed the formation of the Spanish Falangist Party in the 1930s. Linked to authoritarianism and Catholicism, this group, under the leadership of General Francisco Franco, opposed Republicans and led Spain into a civil war in 1936 that echoed throughout Europe and the Americas. Followed by the rise of Hitler and Mussolini, democratic groups throughout the world organised to oppose fascism and totalitarianism. The civil war became a rallying cry for both the right and the left, liberal and fascist, in post-1930 Argentina.
Intellectuals in Argentina defended anti-democratic activities as well as opposing Nazism and fascism. Nállim's discussion of major Argentine literary magazines and newspapers in the 1930s and 1940s reinforces his analysis of liberalism to show the depth of commitment to unfettered suffrage, the defence of the Constitution and secularism. Ironically, these same writers came from elitist backgrounds and ultimately focused their scorn on Juan Perón and his supporters, viewing them as barbaric remnants of the Argentine past and opposing Perón's efforts to enact female suffrage and a welfare state. They dismissed the president elected in the most open election in Argentine history as a home-grown fascist.
Nállim shines in his discussion of the flow of ideas through literary currents that transmitted liberal thought, and of how economic liberalism led to the Concordancia's plans for economic reforms in the 1940s. He is less successful discussing the liberal conservatives who supported the Concordancia, however, as well as why the Socialists managed to enact so much long-delayed legislation defending mothers and the welfare state. He does not fully balance the impact of individual personalities that often led to party splits with ideological differences, and beyond discussing Federico Pinedo, he does not tell us the names or the trajectories of those people who had once been Radicals and Socialists but joined in with anti-democratic elements within the Concordancia alliance. Were they hoping to ultimately seize control of the movement, especially after the death of President Roberto Ortiz in 1942, or did they want, as Ortiz had done, to democratise the Concordancia? This question remains for future researchers.
Until now, the studies of liberalism, the Radical Party and the Socialist Party have ended at 1930, and much confusion has arisen over the difference between ‘liberal conservatives’ and ‘right-wing conservatives’. Part of the problem is due to the lack of ideological rigidity among Argentine politicians, and this has caused them to cross borders with a frequency that might dismay those who believe in rigid ideologies. Jorge Nállim, along with the other authors mentioned, has made key inroads into this labyrinth of confusion.
