Middle East Historiographies is the third publication arising from a collaborative project on the subject that has already produced an earlier volume (Histories of the Middle East: New Directions, 2002) and a special issue of the Mediterranean Historical Review (19:1 [2004]) on Ottoman history and historiography. The editors of the earlier volume announce their project as “part of a general effort to re-examine our profession, as an intermediate report on the ‘state of the art”’ (p. 2). This is carried through in the first book by themed essays examining specific case studies from a variety of methodological perspectives so as to “rethink Middle East studies by ‘doing history”’ (p. 2), providing a range of examples of historians at work in broad thematic and diachronic areas of the field—modernization, globalization, colonialism, and nationalism. This follow-up volume is in general more historiographically oriented, with critical bibliographic essays discussing the history of history writing, but several contributors also offer historical, as well as historiographical, accounts of their chosen subject areas.
The earlier volume concentrates more on the 19th century, although several studies address 20th-century material, including a chapter by Joel Beinin on the impact of neoliberalism on Middle Eastern workers since the 1970s and another by Walter Armbrust on gender and cinema in Egypt focused on the 1950s; despite its subtitle, the present work also contains much of interest on the mid- to late 19th century. Given the overlaps of chronology and theme, it is perhaps more useful to think of them as companion volumes rather than distinct attempts to map current historical practice on the question of Middle Eastern modernity (the earlier volume) and narratives of the 20th century (the present volume).
The present volume begins with an introductory section (Part I: The State of the Art), with an introductory essay by Gershoni and Singer and a survey by R. Stephen Humphreys of Western historiography that takes in the classicizing field of “Islamic” history as well as, or rather more than, modern Middle Eastern history per se. Three thematic sections follow, beginning with “Colonialism and Nationalism,” which Charles D. Smith opens with a consideration of World War I and its aftermath as “the pivotal period” in the region (p. 39), viewed from the contrasting standpoints of the Ottoman and European empires, Arab nationalism(s), and Zionism. Julia Clancy-Smith follows up with a wide-ranging discussion of “women, gender and empire” that offers a broad overview of writing on imperialism and the colonial experience that notably points to both escaping from “the nationalist narrative and tunnel of time” and remedying “the Maghreb's marginalized position relative to Middle Eastern history” while also pointing out that the potential of “comparative history has yet to be exploited fully” in the field (pp. 90–91).
Fatma Müge Göçek's chapter, “Reading Genocide,” offers the only essay in the volume to engage directly with a body of Middle Eastern historiography as its principal object in an attempt at analyzing Turkish narratives of the “Armenian deportations and massacres of 1915,” a brave intervention on a crucial topic that unfortunately deals with the narratives in question in very general terms, relegating reference to actual authors and their works to the endnotes and devoting only two very brief paragraphs (pp. 121–22) to the “post-national critical narrative,” whose representatives are again hidden away in a note (pp. 126–27, n. 17).
Part III (Narratives of Crisis) contains two excellent essays, both focused on Egypt, each of which critiques the long-dominant trope of “crisis” as characteristic of the region's contemporary history. Israel Gershoni looks at intellectual history, specifically the generation of writers of the interwar “modernist school” (Husayn, Haykal, and al-ʿAqqad et al.) whose turn to Islamiyyat literature in their later careers has sometimes been construed as emblematic of a “crisis” of modernism and of modernity, a view (expounded particularly in the “Orientalist legacy” of Gibb) that Gershoni emphatically refutes. Ellis Goldberg, in a more technical intervention on Egyptian political economy, performs a similar exercise in deconstruction in a neat demonstration of the fallacy of the long-held theory of “ecological crisis” in prerevolutionary Egyptian agriculture, showing how subsequent anticolonial arguments unwittingly adopted the views of colonial apologists and how both ignored empirical information available at the time.
The final section, Part IV (Emerging Voices), is in some respects the most rewarding: Marilyn Booth's chapter on gender studies, social history, and Arabic fiction, Eve Troutt Powell's on the historiography of Middle Eastern race and slavery, Juan R. I. Cole's on social scientific (mis)understandings of Egyptian Islamist extremism, and Walter Armbrust's on the history of audiovisual media in the region are all engaged and engaging analyses of major themes. Three of these themes—women's fiction, slavery, and audiovisual media—have also been relatively marginal areas in the field. Although a superabundance of literature on Islamism proliferates in several disciplines, Cole's demand (made in the course of an extended, and excoriating, critique, particularly of Gilles Kepel's work) for a view of Islamist movements as “cult-like” organizations within a comparative sociology of religions offers an unusual approach to the subject.
Some aspects of the state of the field, as made visible in these studies, remain disappointing. The persistence of a still unresolved nondebate is clear in the juxtaposition of Humphreys' plea that “it is time to stop beating” the “very dead horse” of orientalism (p. 31) and his desire to rehabilitate some of its practitioners (“gifted individuals” able to bend the constraints of their times, compared to Foucault and Said, who are presented as little more than synthesizers of a Zeitgeist [pp. 31, 26]), with the concern of several other essays with the dismantling of persistent “orientalist” narratives. On the whole, the book, like the field as a whole, skirmishes around the issue of orientalism—and its extraordinary resilience as authorized knowledge, all too visible in U.S. media and policy as well as in classrooms—rather than really addressing it.
It is perhaps disappointing (no less so because it is clearly necessary) that so much attention is devoted in Smith's chapter to competing readings of the Husayn–McMahon correspondence. Cole's multiple attempts to name his object (“Islamicist,” “fundamentalist,” “extremist,” “Islamist”) suggest a terminological quandary that also ought to have been resolved long ago. Some discomfort with more recent approaches in the wider disciplines is evident (Clancy-Smith, p. 84, and Humphreys, p. 31, both evoke a certain “poststructuralism fatigue”—although the former approvingly cites both Mitchell's Colonising Egypt and Gayatri Spivak), although it is far from clear that the possibilities opened up by critical theory have even begun to be seriously explored in the field. A misplaced distinction between “the discursive” and “the real” (or “material” or “concrete”) continues to plague some perceptions of what poststructuralist approaches imply (as in the conclusion to the 2002 volume), whereas more imaginative scholarship (represented here, e.g., in Marilyn Booth's discussion of history and fiction on pp. 224–25) successfully escapes this false dichotomy.
Overall, the editors have assembled a valuable range of insightful and well-informed views of crucial themes in the contemporary historiography of the Middle East and North Africa. Taken along with the earlier volume, these studies are, as the editors intend, both illuminating as to the state of the field and suggestive of further directions that work in it might take. As they make clear, the book ought not to be understood as a comprehensive survey of how the region's 20th-century experiences have been narrated. Instead, the editors have selected contributions that “problematize and reconceptualize” a sample of “themes . . . of central importance in our field” (p. 17).
To a certain degree, the book's usefulness, in particular for teaching, might be somewhat limited by a certain (perhaps inescapable) eclecticism in the subjects covered and the absences necessarily incurred. There is nothing, for example, on the “new” Israeli historiography, on postnationalist narratives of Arab nationalism(s), on oral history, or on the relationship of history to anthropology. The geographical focus is decidedly on Egypt, with bit parts for most of the rest of the region and nothing on Iran or the Gulf. Despite the attention accorded in several of the chapters (notably, those of Smith, Göçek, Booth, and Troutt-Powell) to “Middle Easterners' self-views of their own histories” (p. 6), the focus throughout this collection is primarily on the narration of Middle Eastern history in European and North American scholarship. The writing of history within the region, and the significance of historical narrative as “public history,” in schooling, mass culture, and politics, all areas of obvious importance, are (with the exception of Göçek's somewhat tentative chapter) not the primary focus here, although they have generated considerable recent scholarship. The areas this collection leaves out, then, point clearly to the desiderata for other studies that might help fill the gaps. In this respect, as well as in the range of important topics that it does cover, this book is a very useful and extremely stimulating summary of the state of the field.
