The past decade has been a very good one for historians of the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms (907−79), as a growing body of research, both in Chinese and in English, has emerged to expand and enrich our understanding of the often neglected period of disunion between the Tang and Song dynasties. This volume, edited by Peter Lorge, represents a collective effort of scholars at the forefront of the field to explore further this turbulent era, with the intention of “advancing the overall understanding of the period as a whole” (p. 4). Challenging the traditional view shaped by Song historians such as Ouyang Xiu (1007–72), who condemned the Five Dynasties as an interregnum characterized by cultural darkness and moral degeneration, this book proposes that the period was “fully continuous with the Tang and Song” (p. 1). Many trends in the Tang dynasty, the contributors argue, continued through the Five Dynasties and into the Song. The multipolar configuration of power deprived the era of a uniform culture under a single sovereign, but the coexistence of multiple cultural centers across China proved a catalyst for cultural, economic, and social transformations in subsequent centuries. As Lorge puts it in his introduction, “Culture flourished because it was not unified” (p. 5). Consequently, the contributors to the volume sensibly emphasize the complexities of a period characterized by heightened regional development, and document from different perspectives “a deep-rooted ideological shift away from the cultural need for a defining imperial center” (p. 5).
In addition to Lorge's introduction and his concluding chapter, the book contains essays by six other authors. Each of their essays stands on its own while simultaneously supporting the overarching theme of the volume. The essays can be divided into two groups, with four essays focusing on political issues and two on art history. Naomi Standen explores the issue of loyalty, to expand on ideas she developed in her Unbounded Loyalty: Frontier Crossings in Liao China (Honolulu: University of Hawai‘i Press, 2007). By examining the shifting roles of Zhao Dejun, a military governor active in the northern border zone during the early Five Dynasties, Standen recovers a vivid, more accurate picture of a period during which people faced a variety of alternatives and made choices in response to specific situations. The traditional view, which condemns Zhao as disloyal for his repeated change of masters, obscures the different understanding of loyalty during the Five Dynasties. In his chapter on the social origins of founders of the southern regimes, Hugh Clark demonstrates that individuals in south China faced similarly diverse choices. Clark argues that most of the southern rulers do not fit the model of banditry developed by Robert Somers in his study of the origins of military strongmen in the late Tang and early Five Dynasties, as most southern rulers did not become “outlaws” as a result of injustice, but were merely scoundrels, rogues, or refugees “driven by an interest in self-aggrandizement and survival” (p. 70).
That the chaotic tenth century also confounded literati is demonstrated by the case of Han Xizai, the subject of Johannes Kurz's paper. Han's eccentric and extravagant private life, as Kurz points out, serves as an emblem of an uncertain time when swift political changes frequently threatened status and position. Adopting a broader perspective, Ruth Mostern's essay surveys the changing geographical arrangements from the rise of regional autonomies during the late Tang, through the gradual reassertion of direct control over territory by the new courts of the Five Dynasties, to the reestablishment of a centralized geography during the early Song.
Two art historians examine the cultural continuity and diversity of the period. De-nin Lee uses the tomb murals from Baoshan, in Liao territory, to show how painting as a form of culture extended to the periphery of China proper. Tracy Miller, in a stellar essay with copious illustrations, tracks the local styles of timber-frame architecture that remained dominant throughout the middle period even after the unification of the Song.
All of the essays in this volume are first rate. They provide concise, elegant, and useful arguments, and offer nuanced portraits of tenth-century China, which is understood as a dynamic period both continuous with the Tang and the Song, and at the same time highly fluid and diverse. The collection would have been even more convincing, however, if it had included one or more essays on a broader variety of topics, such as economy, religion, or institutions. Yet there is no doubt that this collection is essential reading for scholars and students interested in this “long tenth century” (p. 118). Peter Lorge deserves credit not only for editing the volume, but also for contributing a thought-provoking concluding chapter in which he proposes the innovative argument that the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms did not really come to an end until the creation of an imperial culture during the third reign of the Song dynasty.
