
Kraepelin died 100 years ago but he still generates strong feelings and polarised views. He was the father of psychiatry, the first to apply rigorous scientific observations to mental disorder. Among his achievements, he laid the foundations for modern nosology, including the distinction between manic depression and dementia praecox, which could be separated by outcome. The alternative opinion is that Kraepelin has been shown to be utterly wrong in this and in almost every other respect. He was influential because he wrote a book (solely for the money) when there were few and it became the standard text. He was a therapeutic nihilist who believed in degeneration theory. His was a biological reductionist who led generations of psychiatrists into error and laid the eugenic foundation that Nazi doctors built upon, notwithstanding that he died long before their rise to power.
So Kraepelin is an ambiguous figure. It is a strength of this text that it draws out these and other ambiguities, without taking a position. Instead, it uses Kraepelin’s intellectual legacy as a motif while examining the state of modern psychiatry.
This is no hagiography. A lot of it is about epistemology. Nonetheless, there is some history here. Kraepelin emerges as less dogmatic than some of his followers, with an early interest in psychology that sounds surprisingly modern. He had a lifelong friendship with Wilhelm Wundt, who invented experimental psychology. He was supportive of the shy Alzheimer and others, and he was nominated for a Nobel Prize by Bleuler.
An overlooked skill in editing a book is balancing control and freedom for individual contributors. This is really well executed here, chapters working both as free-standing pieces and in continuity. The book is a series of excellent essays by mainly European experts, from the modern genetics of Michael Owen to the Mad Studies of Peter Beresford. It is never reluctant to embrace criticisms and complexities of modern psychiatry, and starts with a suitably ambivalent foreword by an eminent American, Allen Francis, who considers Kraepelin’s embrace of psychopathy as a mental disorder as a serious and enduring mistake. Each helpfully ends with bullet points summarising what has been said. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it, and I am confident that it will come to be seen as a classic. Most seminal texts in psychiatry have a single author, at least initially. Not this one. What is unusual about this book is its scope. It is of interest to anyone involved in mental health, including psychiatric trainees who are puzzled that ‘classic’ presentations of schizophrenia are so uncommon. It is thought provoking and rich, a really serious contribution to the intellectual underpinning of our subject. It is available Open Access. Highly recommended.

eLetters
No eLetters have been published for this article.