In 1959, Prince Edward County, Virginia shut down its schools. Five years after Brown v. Board of Education, the federal courts were beginning to demand at least token moves toward desegregating public schools, and this was something the whites who ran this rural Virginia county were unwilling to do. The closure of public schools in Prince Edward from 1959 until 1964 offered the nation yet another tragic object lesson in the perverse commitment of southern whites to Jim Crow, even in its dying days. In his insightful and thoroughly researched book, Southern Stalemate: Five Years without Public Education in Prince Edward County, Virginia, Christopher Bonastia explores the remarkable story of this county's struggle over school desegregation.
The roots of this struggle go back at least to the late nineteenth century, when the first schools for African Americans appeared in Prince Edward, but the story picks up in earnest in 1951, when over four hundred black students walked out of their high school to protest its meager resources. The walkout gained the attention of lawyers from the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), who agreed to represent the students and their parents in a lawsuit – although only after Prince Edward blacks abandoned their calls for equalized resources and signed on to the NAACP's desegregation agenda. The Prince Edward case would ultimately be one of the five lawsuits consolidated into the Supreme Court's Brown ruling.
As was typical in most of the South, the Brown decision had little immediate impact on schooling in Prince Edward. Segregationists regularly threatened to shut down public schools if required to integrate, but rarely did they feel the need to follow through on these threats since in the most resistant communities a combination of white resistance and judicial wariness effectively delayed implementation for years. By the late 1950s, when the courts were willing to demand at least some efforts toward desegregation, Virginia's organized resistance to Brown had weakened considerably and nominal desegregation occurred in much of the state. Prince Edward's segregationists refused to go along.
The most obvious question – and one that Bonastia does an excellent job of answering – is why this particular community went to such extremes in its defiance of Brown. Various schools in the South closed temporarily rather than desegregate, but Prince Edward was the only jurisdiction willing to keep them shuttered for such an extended period. Prince Edward's exceptionalism can be traced to several factors. There was the rather thin commitment to public education among whites. Many felt that they had a right to get the kind of schools that they wanted – after all, they reasoned, whites paid the majority of tax dollars that went to public education – so it was not much of a change for them to shut down the schools, slash tax rates, open an all-white private Prince Edward Academy, create a school voucher program (after courts blocked an effort to directly fund the academy with tax dollars), and go on with their lives. Another factor was the dominance in local politics of a relatively small number of die-hard segregationists. Although the school closures likely had majority white support, the decision-making process in Prince Edward was hardly a majoritarian enterprise, even among whites. Demagoguery became policy with precious few political checks. Also contributing to white segregationist extremism was the relatively high percentage of African Americans (over 50 percent of the school-age population), coupled with the relatively low level of residential segregation. These demographics meant that even limited integration plans would result in considerable interracial schooling. Additionally, Prince Edward's rural, largely agrarian economy had relatively little need to attract outside economic investment, thus diminishing one of the most powerful potential pressures to abandon its flagrantly retrograde approach to racial affairs.
Another factor that had an effect in sending Prince Edward down its ignominious path to historical significance was the difficulty involved in mobilizing resistance to the school closures. As Bonastia makes clear, schools were particularly challenging targets for social protest – more so in many ways than other elements of Jim Crow, such as discrimination in public accommodations and voting rights. Organizing a protest movement was particularly difficult in Prince Edward, where the black population was dispersed, economically dependent on whites, and declining in numbers even before the school closures. And although the closures provided a potentially powerful platform for protest mobilization, putting on national display the irrational extremism of segregationism, they also undermined the conditions for effective local activism. When the schools closed there was an exodus of black teachers who were forced to search for work elsewhere. Combine this with the fact that the closures led some African American families to leave the district and others to send their children to live with family or friends so that they could receive an education, and one can see why there was relatively little local activism to protest the abhorrent situation in Prince Edward. It was only in 1963–64, in the last year of the school closures, with the civil rights movement in full effect and outside interest in Prince Edward County at its height, that there were significant stirrings of a local protest movement.
One of the great strengths of this book is Bonastia's facility in moving between the various actors and institutions involved in the desegregation struggle. Although ostensibly covering a relatively focussed topic – a case study of a single Virginia county – Southern Stalemate is an impressively ambitious and wide-ranging work of scholarship. At the heart of the book is an empathetic examination of the obvious victims: those African Americans who lost years of schooling when Prince Edward shut down its schools. But Bonastia also gives considerable attention to the world of the segregationists who masterminded the massive resistance campaign, as well as those whites who might not have been leading the charge but who willingly went along. He also explores the experience of whites, mostly from outside the South, who sympathized with black Prince Edwardians and sought to do something about their situation. Bonastia offers considerable detail on federal civil rights policy and the Supreme Court's role in ultimately breaking the closure stalemate. He tells the story of the creation of the Free School Association, an organization largely masterminded by the Kennedy administration but privately funded, which operated schools in Prince Edward during the 1963–64 school year. (Over fifteen hundred black students and a handful of whites enrolled in the Free Schools.) Bonastia's research is extensive, and he writes knowledgeably and incisively about varied levels of historical experience on all sides of the civil rights struggle.
Also impressive is Bonastia's attention to the diversity as well as the continuities of Jim Crow as practice and ideology. A powerful theme of the book is the variability of white responses to desegregation. Virginia itself was far from monolithic in its commitment to massive resistance, and there was even considerable variance in how whites within Prince Edward County responded. As Bonastia puts it, “local contexts shaped the concrete strategies that whites employed to turn back racial change” (104). Yet there were also powerful continuities to the way white resistance played out in response to the civil rights movement. Indeed, as this book demonstrates, the racial extremism evident in Prince Edward was in certain ways characteristic of segregation's defenders throughout the South. Bonastia pushes this point a step further, locating a connection between the white-supremacist tactics employed in rural Virginia and today's racial conservatives. Segregationists, he notes, defended school closures (and segregation generally) by downplaying white-supremacist rationales and drawing on race-neutral rhetoric, emphasizing the value of local control and individual choice. In this way, the language of hardcore segregationism can be seen as laying the groundwork for conservatism in the post-civil rights movement era.
Here Bonastia might claim too much, however. To label this an early articulation of “colorblind” conservatism, as Bonastia does, is misleading. To begin with, much of this rhetoric of localism and choice was simply bread-and-butter conservatism, its place in American political culture long pre-dating the segregationist stand against the civil rights movement. It would have been shocking had segregationists not embraced these readily accessible strains of localism and libertarianism. So to claim the segregationist incorporation of this rhetoric as illuminating the unsavory “roots” of modern conservatism is perhaps to confuse branch and root – conservatism's roots are far deeper. Furthermore, the entire goal of the segregationist assertion of a right to local control or individual choice was to immunize explicitly race-conscious policy from federal scrutiny. While some of their arguments clearly sought to avoid the language of white supremacy, they most assuredly were not indifferent to race as an explicit basis for policymaking; they thus rejected the central tenet of modern colorblind conservatism.
The end of the school-closure stalemate – or, more accurately, the beginning of the end – came in September 1964, when, after the Supreme Court held that the school closures placed Prince Edward in violation of Brown's desegregation requirement, the public schools finally reopened. Predictably, the school population was overwhelmingly black, as most whites remained in the segregation academy. Also predictably, the schools were shamefully underfunded and overcrowded. “Prince Edward Negroes Won Battle but Lost the War,” ran a Washington Post headline. In the following decades, the school system improved, as blacks gained political power and as whites gradually came back to the public schools. By the 1990s, test scores were on par with state averages and whites comprised over 40 percent of public-school enrollees, roughly mirroring county demographics. Bonastia concludes this excellent historical study with an appropriately measured assessment of the achievements as well as the failures in the long struggle for racial equality and educational opportunity in Prince Edward Country.
