From the presumptuously titled Oxford University Press series What Everyone Needs to Know, this book promises to enlighten readers about important facts concerning Cuba. If its goal was to provide an objective overview of the island's exceptional history and place in the world, as well as its troubled relationship with the United States, the book is successful on all levels. Firstly, it asks pertinent questions; and secondly, it provides comprehensive yet succinct answers.
The book is organised chronologically, commencing with a fairly brief section on Cuba before the 1959 revolution. The remaining main sections then analyse Cuba during the Cold War (1959–91) and following it (1991–2006), with a concluding section covering the period from Fidel Castro's enforced handover to his younger brother Raúl. Subsections within these three main sections divide neatly into analysis of domestic issues, the US–Cuba relationship and the island's relations with the wider world. Questions are brief, with most questions receiving one- to two-page answers.
Author Julia E. Sweig is the Nelson and David Rockefeller Senior Fellow for Latin American Studies and Director for Latin American Studies at the Council on Foreign Relations. In the introduction she details her direct experiences on the island, as an undergraduate and graduate student, working with an NGO, and in a professional foreign policy capacity. She sets her stall out early by offering the opinion that the US approach to Cuba ‘is misguided and must change’ (p. xvii). In her introduction, Sweig is also critical of Washington's ongoing and overarching belief that it must manage political transition in Cuba.
Following these critical statements, there are early signs that this work might repeat the myths and inaccuracies of previous books. While Sweig explains the misnomer of the 1898 Spanish–American War in Cuba, she also quotes the newspaper magnate William Randolph Hearst: ‘You furnish the pictures, and I'll furnish the war’ (p. 10). Nobody has ever provided concrete evidence that this quote was anything more than apocryphal – it is apposite and suits the purposes of academic encapsulation, but it is not authentic. Another myth is repeated by Sweig in explaining the origins of the Cuban Revolution, when she refers to the ‘biblically resonant 12 survivors’ of the Granma landing, erroneously dated as November (p. 22) rather than December 1956. While the number was ‘resonant’, it was not accurate. Fortunately such examples are very much exceptions, and Sweig demonstrates a thorough understanding of the topic at hand, with apt examples and objective analysis of a thorny subject – Cuba's history, politics and international relations (with occasional forays into culture).
The most frequently asked questions receive convincing answers, such as the perennial ‘Was Castro really a Communist?’; non-Cuba specialists will be enlightened by the question and accompanying answer to ‘Who was General Arnaldo Ochoa and why was he executed?’. It is difficult to find any fault or omission in the three-page response to ‘Why did the Bay of Pigs invasion fail?' – this includes an overview of the debacle's blueprint, the CIA-backed 1954 overthrow of the Arbenz government in Guatemala. A question on the Cuban Missile Crisis receives the same broad but concise treatment, outlining the snub to Fidel Castro and comparing it to Cuban sentiment following the island's political cleavage in 1898.
The most authoritative and original sections are the last two on post-Cold War Cuba and ‘After Fidel, Under Raul’. This is where Sweig's direct experience of the US–Cuban tug-of-war and the Cuban leadership's domestic and foreign policy approach comes to the fore. For example, she gives a succinct and convincing answer to ‘Why didn't the regime collapse?’ following the withdrawal of Soviet subsidies in 1991. Her answer points to the ‘homegrown’ nature of the revolution and its fundamentally nationalist roots (p. 130). The Elián González episode merits two questions; over four pages Sweig provides readers with an excellent overview of its background and the machinations within the Cuban exile community, as well as the value of the affair's denouement to the island's political leadership and the launch of the ‘Battle of Ideas’ initiative.
On the large topic of Havana–Washington relations, Sweig lifts the lid on the ‘Brothers to the Rescue’ controversy and explains the domestic reasons for Clinton's reaction to the shooting down of the organisation's planes by Cuban MiG fighters in 1996. Regarding Fidel's sudden illness and Raul Castro's assumption of power, she points to Washington's Fidel-centric obsession for its failure to react effectively to new circumstances. It would seem that US policy-makers had for too long worked on the assumption that the edifice of control would collapse without the bearded revolutionary leader. The legacy of 50 years’ ‘cloudy political judgment and visceral anti-communism’ in Washington left the George W. Bush administration ‘utterly flat-footed’ (p. 228) and without the necessary tools or information to react in an effective or convincing way. Again, Sweig explains that domestic US politics, particularly in Florida, dictated the government's approach to this ongoing and unresolved foreign policy question.
With such a title, it might have been expected that the book would end by asking the question to which everyone wants the answer: what will happen when the Castro brothers die? The book's structure, however, dictates that Sweig finishes on a topic related to Cuba and the world. Therefore, instead of providing a tentative conclusion about what will happen next – always a perilous enterprise for Cuba-watchers – Sweig touches on the topic of culture. This is one of many fields in which the Caribbean island punches well above its weight, much like this informative publication.
