Shifting Frontiers of Citizenship is a remarkable collective effort to analyse the current characteristics of citizenship in Latin America. By analysing the ‘evolving practices and redefinitions of citizenships’ (p. 2), this book examines the challenges of liberal citizenship, new alternative models of citizenship that have emerged in Latin America, and global trends in reaction to these new models. Through the eyes of 20 experienced authors, the reader experiences a wide variety of approaches to studying citizenship in Latin America, which range from case-study analysis of the political identity reconstruction of workers in Argentina to the analysis of citizenship within the context of illicit trade and gang activity in Central America. Organised in five sections, this book is a great effort towards understanding both the fluidity of citizenship and the variety of trends shaping citizenship in the region.
The four articles that constitute Section One, ‘Shifting Citizenship in Latin America-Comparative Perspectives’, explain the evolution of multiple, and some time opposing, forces that create multifaceted citizenships: liberal-republican, global-local, individualistic-communitarian, bounded and unbounded. Laurence Whitehead's article argues that as opposed to ‘democratic liberalisms’, which focuses on individual citizen preferences, Bolivia and Ecuador represent a model of ‘democratic republicanisms’ (the author emphasises the plural). In the latter model, governments are held accountable to the ‘mobilised masses’. Although they present many transgressions to democratic liberal principles, it proves difficult to deny their democratising force (p. 35). Whitehead adds that various professional communities play a crucial role promoting these ‘liberal’ and ‘republican’ agendas, however in fragmented, opposing, and self-interested ways. Shmuel Eisenstaedt's chapter portrays the coexistence of converging institutions of modernity and its many interpretations from various topics including rights, authority and territory, which do not correspond uniquely to the nation-states, but also to local and transnational units. Later, Bryan Turner's chapter introduces us to the concept ‘consumer citizenship’ and examines its partial application to the region. On one hand, emerging middle classes in Latin America are increasingly adopting this type of passive consumer citizenship by expressing political preferences through media consumption and limited electoral participation. On the other hand, additional actors such as indigenous groups are still engaging in open and collective forms of deliberation. Finally, Dominguez argues that social movement engagement with ‘political society’ and public policy (such as the conditional cash transfer programmes in Brazil) has contributed towards growing citizenship participation. Yet, these policies have produced passive and ‘bounded’ forms of citizenship that do not enjoy deliberation space and pertain to the ‘very poor’ (p. 91).
In the second part of this book, authors inquire whether the politicisation of identity (primarily ethnic, class and gender) is able to spark more inclusive forms of citizenships in Latin America. Drawing upon Brazil and Mexico as case studies, David Lehmann disputes the potential of cultural recognition (or misrecognition) for social justice. Affirmative action programmes, ‘reputed and cheap’, pay more attention to limited inclusion than to equality (p. 130). In the next article, Robert Albro brings to the fore a recent state experiment in Bolivia, with the objective of discussing the complexities of identity formation. As in the past, mapping and tagging through state instruments (such as the political constitutions) implies selecting from a variety of local and collective political experiences. Thus, new formal structures are placed on top of old ones, that is, old citizenship structures do not disappear but rather coexist with new ones. Gisella Zaremberg's top-down and bottom-up systematic examination of women's political participation in Latin America shows both converging and diverging outcomes across the region. The author convincingly shows that although women in Latin America have won the right to vote, they are still not elected. In the last article of this section, Carlos Forment explains the re-appropriation of citizenship in the wake of neoliberalism. Forment details the ways in which Argentine workers of recuperated factories reconstituted themselves from being portrayed as ‘pariahs’ into ‘rights-bearing citizens’ (p. 214).
The third section, ‘Popular Participation and Citizenship’, aims to show emerging forms of political participation in a region suffering a clear crisis of representation. Yet, they agree that these new forms of participation have not always improved accountability and social inclusion. Leonardo Avritzer utilises the case of Brazil to discuss citizen participation through participatory budgeting, a ‘bottom-up’ logic of participation that with state and society synergies has effectively channelled local demands through state policy. Leon Zamosc offers an optimistic account of popular impeachments in Latin America. Focusing on the case of Ecuador, he argues that impeachments are new forms of vertical accountability (p. 263), citizens’ direct and societal sanctions to politicians, rather than means to create instability. The following articles strike a less optimistic tone. De la Torre leaves the reader with the persuasive conclusion that in absence of strong liberal institutions, experiments aiming to deepen democracy for the ‘masses’ can result in authoritarian populist tendencies. Raanan Rein discusses the reinvention of populist movements to challenge liberal and neoliberal conceptions of citizenship. The third section concludes with the assessment that populism in Latin America is an underlying force that has never left the region and is repeatedly nourished by the promise of social justice in a highly and persistently unequal region.
The chapters in the fourth section contribute to the growing scholarship on transnational politics in Latin America. Luis Roniger's article examines the interconnected history of various countries in Central America well before the emergence of contemporary globalisation. Throughout a detailed historical journey, the author explains how both the state and civil society have been embedded in evolving transnational networks, which in turn moulded the region's institutional setting for citizenship. The following three articles examine how diasporas in Latin America have redefined citizenship through transnational relations. First, Judit Bokser examines the revival of primordial identities among the Jewish diaspora in Mexico. The Mexican discourse of mestizaje and its direct opposition to Zionism (equated to racism) nourished a ‘transnational conscience’ of Mexico's Jewish population, a conscience connected to the state of Israel. This in turn increased already established boundaries around and isolation of the Jewish community in Mexican society. Second, Maria Rosaria Stabili examines the evolving learning of civil rights and demands, both among Chilean migrants and their host leftist parties in Italy. In the final article of this section, Leonardo Senkam analyses how Jewish, Italian and Islamic ethnic and religious identities in Argentina and Brazil are reconstructed and redefined through transnational dialogue with their peers from other diasporas, and with the Israeli, Italian and Islamic political bodies.
Finally, in ‘Market Societies and Institutional Failures’, citizenship is examined with respect to the failure of the markets and the state. Mario Sznajder's article discusses citizenship and market failure for the case of Chile. Market reforms have achieved macroeconomic stability and reduced poverty, but increasing inequality has created barriers to effective citizenship across different groups. The segregation of migrants in Chile, for instance, generates segmented and incomplete forms of citizenship (p. 419). In her article, Deborah Yashar examines citizenship in the context of illicit markets. Drug markets have developed transnationally, associating trade routes with gang violence, which has in turn aggravated citizenship insecurity. The reader concludes that illicit enclaves are rapidly reshaping the relationship between the state and its citizens. Next, Alison Brysk addresses state criminal activities that violate human rights. In an era of liberalism and electoral democracy, national insecurity is still present in weaker democracies in the form of paramilitarism, torture, illegal detention, and criminalisation of protest. Finally, Philip Oxhorn tackles the complicated issue of globalisation and the local nature of citizen's rights, which unlike human rights are not characterised as universal. Today, borders are more permeable and political communities more heterogeneous, however the idea of citizenship in a globalised world can be ambiguous and challenging. In his article, Oxhorn foresees that this apparent contradiction can in fact instigate opportunities for the construction of more inclusive forms of citizenship.
Throughout the book, multiple tensions are revealed to be key in the configuration of citizenship in Latin America. Democracy has never been more present in the region, yet as contributing authors and editors acknowledge within this book, citizenship in these democracies tends to be ‘fluid, contested and unstable’ (p. 6). This book leaves the reader with an invitation to consider three main questions. First, how can the region reconcile demands for deepening democracy beyond formal and liberal procedures with the rapid re-organisation of populism and authoritarianism in the region? Second, how can inclusive efforts of citizenship combine the recognition of collective cultural rights of peoples (and not only the individual recognition to members of ‘disadvantaged’ groups through affirmative action policies) with the search for equality and meaningful deliberation in a global context of increasing segregation, environmental affliction, and violence? Finally, if transnational imaginaries of citizenship have contributed to the construction of global structures of governance, how can national and local imaginaries of citizenship shape the different translations of these structures across the region?
