Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T00:02:33.720Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Performance and governance of Swiss pension funds

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 August 2008

MANUEL AMMANN
Affiliation:
University of St. Gallen, Swiss Institute of Banking and Finance, Rosenbergstrasse 52, 9000 St. Gallen, Switzerland (e-mail: manuel.ammann@unisg.ch, andreas.zingg@unisg.ch)
ANDREAS ZINGG
Affiliation:
University of St. Gallen, Swiss Institute of Banking and Finance, Rosenbergstrasse 52, 9000 St. Gallen, Switzerland (e-mail: manuel.ammann@unisg.ch, andreas.zingg@unisg.ch)
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

We investigate the relationship between pension fund governance and investment performance. For this purpose, we develop the Swiss Pension Fund Governance Index (SPGI) which is a standard metric for the governance quality of Swiss pension funds. The empirical analysis is based on a sample of 96 pension funds with total assets of more than CHF 190 billion. We find evidence for governance issues in the area organization and target setting. Our results support the widespread hypothesis of a positive relationship between pension fund governance and investment performance.

Information

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © 2008 Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Composition of the sub-index SPGI OrganizationThe SPGI consists of six sub-indices. The sub-index SPGI Organization takes values between 0 and 10 with better-governed pension funds having higher values. The sub-index measures the governance quality with regard to organization based on ten objective and measurable criteria.

Figure 1

Table 2.Composition of the sub-index SPGI Target SettingThe SPGI consists of six sub-indices. The sub-index SPGI Target Setting takes values between 0 and 10 with better-governed pension funds having higher values. The sub-index measures the governance quality with regard to target setting and management objectives based on ten objective and measurable criteria.

Figure 2

Table 3.Composition of the sub-index SPGI Investment StrategyThe SPGI consists of six sub-indices. The sub-index SPGI Investment Strategy takes values between 0 and 9 with better-governed pension funds having higher values. The sub-index measures the governance quality with regard to investment strategy based on nine objective and measurable criteria.

Figure 3

Table 4.Composition of the sub-index SPGI Investment Rules and OrganizationThe SPGI consists of six sub-indices. The sub-index SPGI Investment Rules and Organization takes values between 0 and 7 with better-governed pension funds having higher values. The sub-index measures the governance quality with regard to investment rules and organization based on five objective and measurable criteria.

Figure 4

Table 5.Composition of the sub-index SPGI Controlling and Steering (part I)The SPGI consists of six sub-indices. The sub-index SPGI Controlling and Steering takes values between 0 and 26 with better-governed pension funds having higher values. The sub-index measures the governance quality with regard to controlling and steering based on 19 objective and measurable criteria.

Figure 5

Table 6.Composition of the sub-index SPGI Controlling and Steering (part II)The SPGI consists of six sub-indices. The sub-index SPGI Controlling and Steering takes values between 0 and 26 with better-governed pension funds having higher values. The sub-index measures the governance quality with regard to controlling and steering based on 19 objective and measurable criteria.

Figure 6

Table 7.Composition of the sub-index SPGI CommunicationThe SPGI consists of six sub-indices. The sub-index SPGI Communication takes values between 0 and 3 with better-governed pension funds having higher values. The sub-index measures the governance quality with regard to communication based on three objective and measurable criteria.

Figure 7

Table 8.Summary statistics of the pension fund data sampleNumber, assets, plan type and legal form of the 96 pension funds in our data sample in comparison with the pension fund universe in Switzerland. Summary statistics are as of the year-end 2006.

Figure 8

Table 9.SPGI index values of the survey participantsDescriptive statistics of the survey-based SPGI and its six sub-indices. The sample consists of 96 Swiss pension funds. Maximum index points of the SPGI and per sub-index are reported in parentheses. The current governance quality of Swiss pension funds is indicated by the mean value of index points as a percentage of the maximum.

Figure 9

Table 10.Correlations of regression factorsCorrelations of the factors explaining pension fund performance. SPGI is a standard metric for the governance quality of Swiss pension funds. ADCO represents the administration costs and AMCO the asset management costs. SIZE is the natural logarithm of total pension assets, CORA the coverage ratio, LEFO the legal form and PLTY the plan type. The variables are based on a sample of 96 Swiss pension funds.

Figure 10

Table 11.Results from OLS regressions of NVA on different SPGI governance indicesResults of OLS regressions of the 2005 and 2006 NVA on the SPGI and its six sub-indices as well as costs, size, coverage ratio, plan type, and legal form. The sample consists of 96 Swiss pension funds. Statistically significant coefficients are marked with asterisks.

Figure 11

Table 12.Results from OLS regressions of value creation from the choice of the strategic asset allocation on different SPGI governance indicesResults of OLS regressions of the 2005 and 2006 value creation from the choice of the strategic asset allocation on the SPGI and its six sub-indices as well as costs, size, coverage ratio, plan type and legal form. The value creation is mirrored by the difference between the gross policy return and the minimum required return. The sample consists of 96 Swiss pension funds. Statistically significant coefficients are marked with asterisks.

Figure 12

Table 13.Results from OLS regressions of value creation from active implementation on different SPGI governance indicesResults of OLS regressions of the 2005 and 2006 value creation from active implementation on the SPGI and its six sub-indices as well as costs, size, coverage ratio, plan type and legal form. The value creation is mirrored by the difference between the gross fund return and the gross policy return. The sample consists of 96 Swiss pension funds. Statistically significant coefficients are marked with asterisks.

Figure 13

Table 14.Results from OLS regressions of NVA on different governance mechanisms (part I)Results of OLS regressions of the 2005 and 2006 NVA on different governance mechanisms and six additional non-governance-related explaining variables. The sample consists of 96 Swiss pension funds. Only the significant results are reported in the table.

Figure 14

Table 15.Results from OLS regressions of NVA on different governance mechanisms (part II)Results from OLS regressions of the 2005 and 2006 NVA on different governance mechanisms and six additional non-governance-related explaining variables. The sample consists of 96 Swiss pension funds. Only the significant results are reported in the table.

Figure 15

Table 16.Results from OLS regressions of NVA on different governance mechanisms (part III)Results from OLS regressions of the 2005 and 2006 NVA on different governance mechanisms and six additional non-governance-related explaining variables. The sample consists of 96 Swiss pension funds. Only the significant results are reported in the table.

Figure 16

Table A1.Benchmark indices by asset classOverview of benchmark indices by asset class used to estimate the expected return of the 2006 investment strategy.

Figure 17

Table A2.Risk and return of benchmark indices by asset classRisk, return and reference period of the benchmark indices by asset class.