Timothy Daniels has written a personal study of Islam and everyday life in Central Java, one in which he is very open about disclosing his presence as the “involved researcher” seeking to navigate the manifold ways that Islam is expressed by Indonesians. Yet this is also a study that seeks to engage with the work of others, questioning the numerous “euphoric couplets” (if I may borrow Robert Cribb's amusing formulation; “Circles of Esteem, Standard Works, and Euphoric Couplets: Dynamics of Academic Life in Indonesian Studies,” Critical Asian Studies 37 [2005]: 289–304) deployed by his predecessors and contemporaries. Scholars of Indonesia will naturally recognize such concepts as the “thin veneer” of Harry Benda and “Muslim puritans” of James Peacock and at times connect the author's representations of the work of American and Australian scholars (for Benda's use of the concept of the “thin veneer,” effectively derived from the earlier work of J. C. van Leur [1908–42], who declared religion to be a “flaking glaze” over Javanese social life, see the former's The Crescent and the Rising Sun: Indonesian Islam under the Japanese Occupation, 1942–1945 [The Hague and Bandung: W. van Hoeve, 1958], 17). For a Weberian analysis of Indonesian Islam in terms of a Protestant work ethic, see James L. Peacock, Muslim Puritans: Reformist Psychology in Southeast Asian Islam (Berkeley, Calif.: University of California Press, 1978). That said, Daniels seems to draw something of a long bow when he casts them as the modern incarnations of the colonial “scholar officials” who trod the same terrain in the 19th and early 20th centuries.
For readers who choose to forego the dubious pleasures of the series editors’ preface, the real meat of Daniels’ book begins with his own introduction, in which he lays out his concern to connect Islam and “democracy” (the quote marks are his) with public cultural forms. This is then followed by an exposition of the terrain of his study. Islamic Spectrum in Java is not intended to be read as the consummate work on Indonesia (or perhaps not even on Java) as a whole but rather centers on the princely territory of Yokyakarta, a city known to many for its maintenance of the traditional artistic forms of shadow puppetry (wayang) and percussion orchestras (gamelan).
With such traditions in mind, especially given their objectifications as tourist fetishes of a nationalized Indic past across the 20th century, Daniels is at pains to locate the more avowedly Islamic forms of public performance, such as the recitation of Qurʾanic verses or the odes of Jaʿfar al-Barzanji (1690–1764) while nonetheless pointing out how the participants of some of these rituals might well engage with such entertainments as hypnotic dancing to Javanese rhythms using leather props in the shape of horses. It is events like these, and the traditional offerings made at the graves of the deceased, that would doubtless infuriate some believers at the other end of a very broad global spectrum. Daniels is, moreover, quite clear that some acts interpreted by outsiders as somehow Islamic are conceptualized by their practitioners as something else altogether, falling now under the hegemonic rubric of “culture” (budaya).
In perhaps his most explicitly framed chapter, “Locating ‘Islam’ Between Thin Veneer and Normative Piety,” Daniels addresses previous framings of the spectrum, rejecting earlier assertions that real Islam was hardly to be found on Java or, by way of extreme contrast, that almost everything to be found in the regal complexes of Yogyakarta was steeped in Islamic mysticism as Mark Woodward would have us believe (Islam in Java: Normative Piety and Mysticism in the Sultanate of Yogyakarta [Tucson, Ariz.: University of Arizona Press, 1989]). At the same time, however, he does seem to accept such scholarship that contends the Islamization process on Java involved some form of rapprochement between indigenous Hindu and South Asian Sufi mysticism (pp. 42–43). Still, when it comes to the highly contested practices said to encapsulate some memories of such meetings—the visitation of tombs, entering into trance states, and partaking of ritual meals—Daniels rightly holds that even if people across local society “emphasize one or another points along this continuum [of religious manifestations], there are no clear-cut divisions between one sort of blending and another.” If anything, they constantly renegotiate their “convictions and commitments to particular beliefs and practices over time” (p. 47).
In the following chapters Daniels engages more with his ethnographic fieldwork and explores competing practices of faith healing, the debate about the gyrating dance of a particular celebrity dancer (Inul Darutista), cultural propaganda launched by the city's “Muslim Puritans,” and the theater. The study concludes with a chapter on Emha Ainun Najib's Maiyah project, which seeks to channel various apparently contending forms of Islamic and non-Islamic performance into a form palatable to Muslim and national sensibilities.
Throughout the work it is evident that Daniels seeks to locate Islam not so much by narrowing his lens on questions of doctrine but rather by increasingly widening it to take in the interface between the public and the performative. This approach has its merits—the chapter on healing is particularly rewarding—and its pitfalls. One is sometimes unsure when the boundary between actions conceptualized as specifically Islamic and those simply carried out by Muslims is crossed. This is most evident in the chapter on student theatrical performances, which took the form more of political protest in a period of stalling political reformation. Certainly one must ask how some Javanese Muslims would react to the student actor whose photograph appears on page 122, draped as he is with numerous phalluses. One can nonetheless follow the train of Daniels’ argument as he seeks to show that Indonesian Muslims can come together across the spectrum to debate the future of their nation in the face of external plans for the incorporation of their country into the hegemonic global order. He furthermore restores the scholarly harmony of the work with his ensuing discussion of the Maiyah movement. Indeed, the restoration of harmony would appear to be a theme as he moves from disputes in his own neighborhood to discussions of Inul Darutista's “drilling” moves that so excited the Indonesian public in 2003.
Fieldwork for Daniels was hardly staid, it must be said. Although he lived among family and friends, his account is laced with occasional bitterness. As he admits, his manner could alienate perhaps opportunistic neighbors, and he had to deal with a certain amount of racism in his dealings with Indonesians who had trouble placing him as an African American. We even read that Daniels was poisoned on at least one occasion by potential informants in quest of money. While this is negative enough, he seems to want to point the finger of blame back at supervisors in the United States who had failed to warn him of the likelihood of such scams (p. 62).
Indeed a finger of blame is often pointed in the direction of the West in general. Like many Indonesians, Daniels is concerned by the ways in which foreign capital has been deployed to exploit Indonesians, among others, and he is cynical of the rhetoric about the process of democratization deployed by modern writers seemingly in quest of providing a foil against militant Islam, even remarking that some American and Australian scholars march in step to an “imperial drum” (pp. 7, 159). Here, though, Daniels does not quite deliver. Although I am sympathetic to critiques of any scholarship that seeks to engage with and export policy objectives of another state, whether in the guise of (liberal) democratization, or through the inculcation of a “civil” form that might be said to echo older Dutch efforts toward the privatization of religion, Daniels does not, to my mind, provide sufficient evidence to lend power to his claims, which are usually made in passing while documenting, and in some instances celebrating, the actions and performances of Indonesians. Still, I think this might well be a topic worthy of greater interrogation. How do Indonesians think about the scholarship that is explicitly or implicitly geared to changing them as subjects, or at least encouraging them to do so? Any number of surveys might well tell researchers what Indonesians think about Islam and democracy, but outside scholars are foolish to imagine that the subjects of such inquests are indifferent to their desires and hopes for an Indonesian future.
This is not to say that scholars should not engage with Indonesia and Islam. Quite the opposite. Still, and as Daniels might argue, we should agree that Indonesian inflections of Islam have to be accepted on their own multivalent terms and across a spectrum refracted at home and abroad. Even if some nervous observers may pour a measure of scorn on the Salafis, for example, who were little represented in this book, they have arguably played a major role in shaping Indonesian public discourse. Hence we have to accept that they are now firmly embedded in the spectrum of Islam in Java just as all manner of practices conventionally associated with Indonesia might yet be discerned in everyday Muslim life in so many other global contexts.
