Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T01:47:22.612Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Oscillations of the large-scale circulation in experimental liquid metal convection at aspect ratios 1.4–3

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 October 2022

Jonathan S. Cheng*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Rochester, Rochester, NY 14627, USASchool of Physics and Astronomy, Rochester Institute of Technology, Rochester, NY 14623, USA
Ibrahim Mohammad
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Rochester, Rochester, NY 14627, USA
Bitong Wang
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Rochester, Rochester, NY 14627, USA
Declan F. Keogh
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW 2052, Australia
Jarod M. Forer
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Rochester, Rochester, NY 14627, USA
Douglas H. Kelley
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Rochester, Rochester, NY 14627, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: j.s.cheng@rochester.edu

Abstract

We investigate the scaling properties of the primary flow modes and their sensitivity to aspect ratio in a liquid gallium (Prandtl number $Pr = 0.02$) convection system through combined laboratory experiments and numerical simulations. We survey cylindrical aspect ratios $1.4 \le \varGamma \le 3$ and Rayleigh numbers $10^{4} \lesssim Ra \lesssim 10^{6}$. In this range the flow is dominated by a large-scale circulation (LSC) subject to low-frequency oscillations. In line with previous studies, we show robust scaling of the Reynolds number $Re$ with $Ra$ and we confirm that the LSC flow is dominated by a jump-rope vortex (JRV) mode whose signature frequency is present in velocity and temperature measurements. We further show that both $Re$ and JRV frequency scaling trends are relatively insensitive to container geometry. The temperature and velocity spectra consistently show peaks at the JRV frequency, its harmonic and a secondary mode. The relative strength of these peaks changes and the presence of the secondary peak depend highly on aspect ratio, indicating that, despite having a minimal effect on typical velocities and frequencies, the aspect ratio has a significant effect on the underlying dynamics. Applying a bandpass filter at the secondary frequency to velocity measurements reveals that a clockwise twist in the upper half of the fluid layer coincides with a counterclockwise twist in the bottom half, indicating a torsional mode. For aspect ratio $\varGamma = 3$, the unified LSC structure breaks down into multiple rolls in both simulation and experiment.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Periodic motions of the LSC in convection: (a,d) the sloshing mode, (b,e) the torsional mode and (c,f) the jump-rope vortex (JRV) mode. Panels (a–c) correspond to one apex of the motion, set as the initial phase, while panels (d–f) correspond to the opposite phase. The blue region represents the plane of the LSC. Arrows represent motions of the LSC associated with each mode. Dashed lines represent a meridional slice of the vessel, which coincides with the time-averaged plane of the LSC motion in each case.

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a) Design drawing of the experimental set-up. The cylindrical vessel is composed of copper top and bottom plates and a Delrin acetyl polymer sidewall. (b,c) Velocity and temperature measurement probe placements around the set-up. There are nine ultrasound transducers (numbered 1–9 and colour coded) and two sets of four thermocouple probes embedded on both the top and bottom plates (numbered T0–T3 with positions marked by red circles). Horizontal ultrasound probes are placed at heights $z = H/4$, $H/2$ and $3H/4$ for $\varGamma = 1.4$, 1.7 and 2, and $z=H/3$, $H/2$ and $2H/3$ for $\varGamma = 3$. Chord probes 5, 6 and 7 have beams parallel to probe 1 but offset horizontally by $D/4$ (the probes are placed at a small angle in order to account for refraction of the beam at the Delrin–gallium interface). Some probes in the $\varGamma =3$ vessel are rotated to different locations to conserve space, but they retain radial/chord orientations. Vertical ultrasound probe 9 is located at the radial centre while probe 8 is 4 mm from the sidewall. The radial distances of the thermocouple probes from the central axis are 1.15 cm, 2.30 cm, 3.80 cm and 4.45 cm.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Dopplergrams showing velocity as a function of distance from probe and time, from a convection case at $Ra = 6.5 \times 10^5$ ($\Delta T=8.8\,^\circ$C, $\varGamma = 1.7$). All of the probes used for a typical case are included here, with numbers and positions given in figure 2. Features with slopes matching the solid or dotted lines move away from or toward the probe, respectively, with speed equal to the free-fall speed $U_{ff}$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Variation of the Reynolds number $Re$ with the Rayleigh number $Ra$ for all convection cases. Simulation cases are plotted as yellow hexagrams. Best-fit scaling trends over all aspect ratios are plotted as black lines. Also plotted for comparison are the best-fit scaling slopes from previous low-$Pr$ convection studies: $Re = 12 Ra^{0.424}$ (Cioni et al.1997), $Re = 6.5 Ra^{0.45}$ (Scheel & Schumacher 2017) and $Re = 8.0 Ra^{0.42}$ (Zürner et al.2019). Panels (a–c) show $Re$ vs $Ra$ using estimates of $Re$ based on $U_r$, $U_{3D}$ and $U_{LSC}$, respectively. Panels (d–f) show $Re$ compensated by the overall best-fit scaling trends vs $Ra$, with coloured lines representing the best-fit trends for individual aspect ratios. Yellow hexagrams represent velocity measurements from the simulation case.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Visualisations of the flow in simulations (a–d) compared with velocity measurements in experiments (e–h). Panels (a,b,e,f) show $\varGamma = 1.4$ data at $Ra=1.2\times 10^6$ while panels (c,d,g,h) show $\varGamma = 3$ data at $Ra= 1.4\times 10^5$. Panels (a,c,e,g) show vertical slices of the flow. Panels (b,f) show horizontal slices at height $3H/4$. Panels (d,h) show horizontal slices at height $2H/3$. The overall flow morphology visible in simulations is also captured by experimental UDV measurements.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Conditionally averaged snapshots of the flow field at different points in the JRV cycle at $Ra = 1.2 \times 10^{6}$, $\varGamma = 1.4$. (a–d) Vertical slices of the simulated velocity field (arrows) and temperature field (background colour). (e–h) Velocity components measured in experiments. From left to right, the panels correspond to phases 0$^\circ$, 90$^\circ$, 180$^\circ$ and 270$^\circ$ of the JRV cycle. At phase 0$^\circ$, the vortex core is near mid-height on the right-hand side. Over the cycle, it orbits along a circular path in the clockwise sense, opposite the counterclockwise circulation of the LSC.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Power spectral density of (a–c) temperature measurements from thermocouple TC2$_{bot}$ and (d–f) spatially averaged velocity measurements from velocity probe 6, with aspect ratio and Rayleigh number varying as shown. Solid black lines mark the lowest clear frequency and dashed black lines appear where a harmonic peak was identified. Green lines mark another spectral peak that is most prominent at lower $\varGamma$. (g) Frequencies of spectral peaks measured in all temperature and velocity probes from the $\varGamma = 1.4$ case shown in (a,d).

Figure 7

Figure 8.Peak frequencies varying with $Ra$ for each probe in each case. Red stars represent peaks in the temperature spectra while blue circles represent peaks in the velocity spectra. Simulation data are plotted as yellow hexagrams. Panels (a–c), (d–f), (g–i) and (j–l) show data from $\varGamma = 1.4$, 1.7, 2 and 3, respectively. Panels (a,d,g,j) contain raw frequencies, and the dashed lines in each panel represent $f \sim Ra^{0.4}$. Panels (b,e,h,k) show peak frequencies normalised by the free-fall frequency, $f_{ff}$. Panels (c,f,i,l) show peak frequencies normalised by the turnover frequency derived from velocity measurements, $f_{3D}$. A dashed black line is plotted at $f/f_{3D}=1$. We associate the lowest-frequency peaks at each $Ra$ with the JRV, except for $\varGamma =3$, where the flow morphology is less clear. For $\varGamma =1.7$ and 2, higher-frequency peaks are harmonics of the main peak. At $\varGamma = 1.4$, an additional set of peaks occurs at slightly lower frequency than this harmonic. At $\varGamma = 3$, the secondary set of peaks does not appear to be a harmonic of the lowest-frequency signal.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Orientation of the LSC estimated from velocity measurements. (a) Schematic showing our methods for estimating orientation. Other panels show distributions of the orientation $\theta$ over one hour each at (b) $\varGamma = 1.4$ and $Ra = 1.2 \times 10^6$, (d) $\varGamma = 2$ and $Ra = 4.7 \times 10^5$ and (e) $\varGamma = 3$ and $Ra = 1.4 \times 10^5$. Panel (c) shows the same analysis applied to the DNS case (same parameters as panel b). Curves in panels (b–d) indicate normal distribution fits omitting the noisy regions where $\|\theta - \mu \| > 70^\circ$ ($100^\circ$ for the simulation in panel c). Here, $\mu _{LSC}$ and $\sigma _{LSC}$ are the average and standard deviation of the LSC orientation, respectively. The insets show polar histograms, with the radial extent representing the number of counts in each bin.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Variation of sidewall temperature with angular position $\theta$ and time $t$ (Hovmöller diagrams) in simulations of the $\varGamma = 1.4$ case at $Ra = 1.18 \times 10^{6}$. (a) Height $z = H/4$; (b) $z = H/2$; (c) $z = 3H/4$. The characteristic ‘accordion’ shape of the warm and cold regions as they evolve in time demonstrates prominence of the JRV mode (Horn et al.2021). Black curves indicate the orientation of the LSC.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Frequency $f_0$ of the strongest spectral peak in each convection case, as measured (a), normalised by the thermal diffusion time $\tau _\kappa$ (b), normalised by a diameter-based diffusion time $\tau ^D_{\kappa } = D^2/\kappa$ (c) and normalised by a path length-based diffusion time $\tau ^L_{\kappa } = L^2/\kappa$, all varying with $Ra$ (d). Each frequency is an average from all velocity probes $f_0^U$ (circles) or all temperature probes $f_0^T$ (stars). Secondary peaks $f_1$, appearing at $\varGamma = 1.4$ and 3, are drawn in lighter colours in (a). Colours represent aspect ratio following figure 4. Experimental frequency peaks from Vogt et al. (2018) are included as grey circles. The dimensions of their set up are $D_{RoMag} = 20$ cm and $H_{RoMag} = 10$ cm. Best-fit trends over both temperature and velocity data are plotted as coloured lines with fits given in table 1. Best-fit trends between $f_0$ and $Ra$ become nearly identical when compensated by $\tau ^L_{\kappa }$, but are also effectively collapsed by $\tau ^D_{\kappa }$.

Figure 11

Table 1.Table containing the prefactor and exponent of the power-law fits for $Re_{LSC}$ vs $Ra$ and frequency peaks $f_0$ and $f_1$ vs $Ra$, at each aspect ratio $\varGamma$. We chose $Re_{LSC}$ since it collapses the data best for $1.4 \le \varGamma \le 2$ where the JRV is dominant, and also produces a power-law trend when $\varGamma = 3$.

Figure 12

Figure 12.(a) Schematic of probes 6 and 7 detecting the torsional mode. (b) Power spectral density of the velocities in the $\varGamma = 1.4$, $Ra = 9.77 \times 10^{5}$ case as measured by probes 6 and 7 (grey) and after bandpass filtering around the secondary peak ($\approx 0.055$ Hz) (blue). (c) Variation of velocity with position and time, as detected by probes 6 (i) and 7 (ii), after filtering. (d) Phase difference between the measurements on probes 6 and 7 at the secondary frequency peak, varying with distance from the probe. The phase difference is almost constant at $180^\circ$ (dashed line) throughout space.

Figure 13

Table 2.Table containing experimental convection cases. Here, $\varGamma$ refers to aspect ratio, $\Delta T$ is the vertical temperature difference, $T_{mean}$ is the mean temperature, $Pr$ is the Prandtl number, $Ra$ is the Rayleigh number, $t_{ff}$ is the free-fall time scale, $U_r$ is the typical velocity estimate from UDV probe 1, $U_{3D}$ is the typical velocity estimate given by (3.1), $U_{LSC}$ is the typical velocity estimate given by (3.2) and $Re$ is the Reynolds number. Also, $f_0^T$ is the mean peak frequency averaged over temperature probes for the main frequency peak as shown in figure 11. Similarly, $f_0^U$ is the same quantity from the UDV probes; $f_1^T$ and $f_1^U$ correspond to the mean frequency of the secondary peak averaged over temperature and velocity probes, respectively. Finally, $\sigma _{LSC}$ is the standard deviation of the LSC orientation $\theta$ and $\mu _{LSC}$ is the mean value of $\theta$ as defined in § 3.4.

Cheng et al. Supplementary Movie 1

See "Cheng et al. Supplementary Captions"

Download Cheng et al. Supplementary Movie 1(Video)
Video 2.7 MB

Cheng et al. Supplementary Movie 2

See "Cheng et al. Supplementary Captions"

Download Cheng et al. Supplementary Movie 2(Video)
Video 768.4 KB

Cheng et al. Supplementary Movie 3

See "Cheng et al. Supplementary Captions"

Download Cheng et al. Supplementary Movie 3(Video)
Video 1.8 MB

Cheng et al. Supplementary Movie 4

See "Cheng et al. Supplementary Captions"

Download Cheng et al. Supplementary Movie 4(Video)
Video 3 MB

Cheng et al. Supplementary Movie 5

See "Cheng et al. Supplementary Captions"

Download Cheng et al. Supplementary Movie 5(Video)
Video 6.8 MB
Supplementary material: PDF

Cheng et al. Supplementary Captions

Cheng et al. Supplementary Captions

Download Cheng et al. Supplementary Captions(PDF)
PDF 57.2 KB