No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
The study of the modern history of the Middle East has long suffered from a tendency to play catch up to new methodological and theoretical work pioneered in European historiography, seeking merely to apply such work to the Middle East. Elizabeth Thompson's excellent work is a different sort of endeavor. Her path-breaking book, recipient of the American Historical Association's Joan Kelly Memorial Book Prize and the Berkshire Conference of Women Historians First Book Prize, is an attempt to introduce a serious gendered perspective into the history of Mandatory Syria and Lebanon but to do so in a way that asks far broader questions about the nature and meaning of citizenship in the context of colonialism. Rather than limit her analysis of citizenship to the political language of liberalism and law, Thompson traces the emergence of a hierarchical colonial citizenship in Mandatory Syria and Lebanon. Using a variety of French, Syrian, and U.S. archival sources, as well as Arabic periodicals and personal interviews in Damascus, Thompson argues forcefully that this citizenship was defined largely by the social policies of the French Mandatory state mediated by male elites—religious patriarchs, urban notables, and rural landowners. These policies, however, were also contested by women's organizations, labor, and Islamic populist movements that challenged the gendered hierarchy of colonial power.
Without losing sight of the soldiers and the repressive state apparatus that undergirded the French Mandates, Thompson suggests that the French Mandatory state and its colonial citizens created a “civic order”—a broad arena in which state and citizen interacted, negotiated, dueled, collaborated, and bargained with one another. She argues that it was the dislocating context of World War I, the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, and the introduction of French Mandatory rule in the newly created states of Lebanon and Syria that engendered a “crisis of paternity,” or the destabilization of male authority as heads of households and of the larger community and concomitant transformation of women's roles. This produced a “gender anxiety” that she then traces across two decades of French Mandatory rule as a struggle between republican rights and paternal privilege. Thompson sees three conflicting models of reconstituted authority emerge at the end of the 1920s (in tension with one another): (1) paternalistic privilege; (2) republican fraternity; and (3) universal democracy, each with a different vision of proper gender relations at home and in the civic order. These developments in turn led to the evolution of a “colonial welfare state.” By detailing the health, educational, and labor policies; press; and civic organizations, Thompson elaborates on her idea of a hierarchy of citizens (which privileged men, Lebanese, and Christians because of their better integration into the French Mandatory state's mediating institutions) wherein paternalistic social aid bestowed by France through its collaborating intermediaries was gradually transformed into social rights claimed directly upon the state itself.
According to Thompson, women's citizenship became a focal point of debate around the nature and limits of the this new civic order in the 1920s. Therefore, the heart of the book (chaps. 6–9) explores with nuance the vibrant elite women's movement that emerged in Lebanon and Syria in the 1920s. Thompson then goes on to map what she refers to as the “spatial boundaries of the colonial civic order” (p. 171) in which she interprets the rise of violent gender conflict in cities across Syria and Lebanon in the 1930s as an effort by male rivals to control public space by mobilizing and holding mass demonstrations against, for example, unveiled women's street presence or against elite female movie-goers. Targeting women, these demonstrations were as much an attempt by different male groups to resist as to reshape the terms of negotiation with the Mandatory state. Gender, Thompson argues, was a crucial site of solidarity and compromise that lessened class and religious tensions between competing male elite and subaltern groups. Thompson concludes her study with a discussion of what she describes as “gender bargains” that sought to stabilize the colonial and post-colonial civic orders in Syria and Lebanon. These bargains aborted the promise of equal citizenship for men and women by depriving women of various civil and political rights, particularly suffrage and egalitarian personal-status laws. Both the Lebanese sectarian political system that cohered around the 1943 National Pact and what Thompson refers to as Syrian statist paternalism reflected these bargains.
Thompson's deft and ambitious interweaving of social, cultural, and political history inevitably generates questions. For one, the Ottoman background to this “crisis of paternity” is underplayed, in part because Thompson respects too much the historiographical break around World War I between Ottoman and Arab studies. Thompson is clearly well read in 19th-century Ottoman history, so it would have been interesting if she had elaborated on how the late Ottoman-era tension between rights and privileges (the abiding tension of the post–Tanzimat empire) defined and shaped the French Mandatory–era tension that she emphasizes. Moreover her notion of a “crisis of masculinity” is overemphasized to the point of burdening the otherwise convincing argument of the book. And perhaps most intriguing is Thompson's conclusion that the drive toward a democratic welfare state ended with the decolonization of Syria and Lebanon. Such an assertion sits uncomfortably with her own emphasis on colonialism's central role in fomenting “gender pacts” that preserved men's privilege and reinforced religious and class hierarchies. It also leaves open the question that Thompson alludes to in her final chapter—namely, how the post-colonial Lebanese and Syrian states “preserved and even extended, in variant ways, a spirit of paternalism alongside the rhetoric of rights” (p. 284).
These questions, however, only underscore the importance of Thompson's profound work. By demonstrating that inequalities of gendered citizenship are not inherent in Muslim or Arab culture but are historically produced, Thompson contributes greatly to a more critical and sophisticated historiography of the modern Middle East. Despite her modest disclaimer in the Introduction to the book, Thompson has managed to reshape the history of Syria and Lebanon by bringing in gender analysis in a serious and sustained manner; she has, in short, exposed the poverty of nationalist and Orientalist historiography of the modern Middle East. She has also moved beyond the often stifling paradigm of post-colonial history that reduces the role of non–Western actors to simple and heroic “resistance” by showing how resistance to colonialism is itself inevitably bound up in simultaneous projects of power. Equally important, she has made the vibrant history of the Mandatory period of Syria and Lebanon accessible to a wide range of readers outside Middle Eastern studies without sacrificing detail or nuance.