Calvert's study of Sayyid Qutb offers not only the fullest biography to date of the individual considered by many to be the founding father of radical Sunni Islamism but also a compelling history of modern Egypt from the interwar years under British domination and its tutelary regime, to the 1952 revolution and the brutal dictatorship of Jamal ʿAbd al-Nasir. By placing Qutb squarely in the context of Egypt's struggle for independence, Calvert demonstrates the way in which Qutb's thought continued to develop over his entire life and in close association with the cultural, religious, political, social, and economic circumstances and debates of his time.
The widespread interest in political Islam and the enigmatic figure whom many consider the founding father of radical Islamism, as well as Calvert's extensive familiarity with modern Egypt and with a wide range of Arabic writings by and about Sayyid Qutb, ensure that this book will both find a wide audience and enhance our understanding of this complex thinker. Calvert already added much to our understanding of the early history of this figure through his fine translation, editing, and introduction (with William Shepard) of Qutb's memoir of his childhood in the village of Musha in Upper Egypt, A Child from the Village (Syracuse, N.Y.: Syracuse University Press, 2004). Here again this author's attitude of “empathy, not necessarily sympathy” (p. 10) toward his subject, his lively and accessible writing style, and his acumen with Arabic texts is further on display. Calvert not only provides for his English readers details from untranslated portions of Qutb's works but also carefully and critically wades through the many other details found in Arabic biographies of Qutb and biographies of those who interacted with Qutb during his lifetime. The author has done his readers a further service in analyzing the various commentaries on Qutb by both his sympathizers and detractors, those who seek to downplay the more militant aspects of his corpus and those who would exaggerate it.
Calvert remains keenly attuned to the wide variety of Qutb's intellectual influences, critical foils, and personal associates. He situates Qutb firmly in the cohort of nationalist intellectuals that emerged in the wake of the 1919 popular uprisings against the British occupation. Like so many others of this generation and like his mentor ʿAbbas Mahmud al-ʿAqqad, Qutb's first political association was with the nationalist Wafd party. He also shared with many Egyptian writers a growing frustration with the failure of the nationalist movement to deal with continued British domination of the country and confront the glaring gap between Egypt's rich and poor. In the rich literary period of the 1940s, Qutb interacted with and critically engaged the works of Tawfiq al-Hakim and Naguib Mahfouz. Calvert's detailed analysis of these interactions is unparalleled, as is his explanation of the intellectual process by which Qutb made his turn to Islamism. Challenging the commonly told story that Qutb was radicalized through his sojourn in the United States between 1948 and 1950, Calvert locates the origins of Qutb's turn to a reformist Islamism in his growing attention to socioeconomic issues and a heightened concern with matters of social justice that was apparent as early as 1947. Thus, Qutb experienced the United States through an Islamist lens, and his negative impressions of the country in turn reinforced rather than produced his ideological shift. Calvert's painstaking account of Qutb's interactions with the Free Officer's Movement and the repressive policies of the al-Nasir regime explains Qutb's shift toward a more militant Islamism. Here too Calvert offers a nuanced and precise analysis of Qutb's increasingly Manichean worldview as he unpacks such notions as the modern jāhiliyya (ignorance of Islam), ḥākimiyya (God's sovereignty), jihad, and martyrdom, taking great care to avoid conflating Qutb's understandings with those of contemporaries such as Mawdudi or takfīrī (excommunicating) activists who would go beyond Qutb in declaring individuals jāhilī.
Calvert's study also adds much to our understanding of the multiple roles played by a number of Islamist women associated with Qutb. Zaynab al-Ghazali, Khalida al-Hudaybi, and Qutb's sisters, Hamida Qutb and Amina Qutb, provided meeting spaces for and transmitted messages among Islamist leaders, visited imprisoned activists, and facilitated the publication and circulation of Qutb's writings. These women played more than a supporting role in Calvert's analysis. He draws attention to their facility as writers in their own right and recounts their individual sacrifices, including their own harrowing experiences in prison.
Although Calvert's primary aim seems to lie in assessing Qutb's life and thought in its own time and place, it is clear that many parts of the book are written with an eye to the present. For many readers this will add significantly to the book's relevance, as Calvert explicitly complicates the notion that responsibility for contemporary militant and violent Islamist groups can be placed firmly at Qutb's doorstep. Calvert does not deny that Qutb has been an important influence on global jihadis, but his full attention to the nuances and circumstances of Qutb's thought demonstrate clearly the ways in which this complex thinker has inspired a wide variety of Islamic thinkers and actors—from reformists to revolutionaries—who have read Qutb according to their own purposes. For example, Calvert documents numerous references that global jihadis have made to Qutb yet argues persuasively that this group is fed most directly by an Egyptian jihadist stream, which itself was influenced by (but also departed from) some aspects of Qutb's thought, as well as by elements of Saudi Wahhabism that were developed among the mujāhidīn in Afghanistan. The author also demonstrates the ways in which prominent ʿulamaʾ, such as the Azhar trained shaykh and public personality Yusuf al-Qaradawi and the former Shaykh al-Azhar Jad al-Haq ʿAli Jad al-Haq, read, criticized, and departed from Qutb.
Other nods to the present are more tangential to Calvert's analysis. Although it is interesting to hear what Qutb meant to contemporary Islamists such as Tunisia's Rashid Ghannushi and Afghanistan's Gulbuddin Hematyar, in light of both the Egypt focus of the study and the aim of demonstrating the wide range of actors who read Qutb's works in their own way, it would have been useful to analyze his influence on independent Islamists who remain highly influential in Egypt, such as Fahmi Huwaydi, Muhammad ʿImara, and Salim al-Awwa. On at least one occasion Calvert's reading from the perspective of the present contributes toward more problematic inclusions. For example, he draws a too easy line from Tariq Ramadan to Qutb via Ramadan's father and suggests an oversimplified and highly questionable conflation of these three individuals’ projects (p. 192).
Nonetheless, one hopes that Calvert's well-researched and carefully articulated study of Sayyid Qutb will be widely read and add much greater nuance to our understanding and characterizations of this child of the Egyptian countryside, civil servant, literary critic, ideologue of reformist and revolutionary Islamism, and political dissident, prisoner, and martyr.
