Overview of the Project
If theatre historians had been paying attention to the proceedings at a Gilbert and Sullivan conference in Lawrence, Kansas in 1970, they would have heard a gauntlet strike the ground when Michael R. Booth delivered “Research Opportunities in Nineteenth-Century Drama and Theatre.” He called for research on audiences (“cultural levels, class origins, income, tastes, and development”), performance in the hinterlands (“we know that in 1866 60% of the theatre seats in metropolitan London were outside the West End”), economics (“theatre profits and losses, actors' wages, authors' income, management and organization, the pricing of seats”), and performance techniques (“technical developments in set construction, staging, lighting, traps, and special effects” as well as acting style).Footnote 1 This cri de coeur to break the hegemony of literary teleologies is recognizable, in 2015, as a mandate to reorient inquiry toward how repertoires were delivered rather than how authorial talent was paramount, what buttressed profitability rather than what constituted fame, and who sustained a gamut of theatres rather than what demarcated elite taste. It set the agenda for aligning theatre studies in wholly new directions, and without citing a single source or calling out any particular historian it inventoried how theatre history could come into line with social history.
Though Booth had a deep impact on his subfield of nineteenth-century theatre, the realignment of theatre studies overall happened less by direct influence than by diffusion. Arguably, it was not theatre scholars who contributed ideas with the greatest impact. In sociology, Erving Goffman was using theatre as a central metaphor to describe social relations (backstage/frontstage, persona, and frame analysis); in social history E. P. Thompson documented the emergence of a social class that consolidated its political identity within nationhood and in negotiation with a host of social and cultural institutions not initially their own (class identity neither reducible to labor nor forged exclusively through revolution); and in historically and philosophically inflected sociology Jürgen Habermas traced the post-Enlightenment emergence of a nongovernmental public sphere sustained through the medium of discourse by the bourgeoisie (Öffentlichkeit).Footnote 2 This set of ideas continues to affect profoundly how theatre historians conceive of the locus of performance across nominal boundaries of performer and spectator (enhanced, of course, by Augusto Boal's work), attention to performance by and for migrant or marginalized communities and not exclusively in lauded temples of prestige (including respect for poor theatre aesthetics, indebted to Jerzy Grotowski and Peter Brook), and cognizance of theatres among other forums for public discussion whose traces are often noticeable through dissensus politics (aesthetically indebted to Bertolt Brecht and more recently the cultural theory of Jacques Rancière).Footnote 3 Additional multidisciplinary insights during the early 1980s sparked paradigm-shifting ideas from outside the field of theatre studies. Victor Turner offered a structuralist account of community expression (social drama); Stephen Greenblatt introduced overt acts of constructing identity through performance (self-fashioning); Natalie Zemon Davis recognized ludic display as a constitutive element of coercive politics (charivari and shivaree); and E. J. Hobsbawm followed up with the concept that venerable ritual and symbolism could be bogus (invented tradition). In 1990, when we tend to think of French poststructuralism taking hold of the American academy, Judith Butler pointed out that the agential creation of subject identities has transformative potential (signification destabilized by conscious manipulation, as in parody) and in so doing added linguistically based phenomenology to the mix of psychoanalytically inflected feminist theories of identity formation that have subsequently blossomed into various gender, queer, and subaltern facets of theatre and performance studies.Footnote 4 At this juncture, the performative turn becomes legible in cultural studies, though its antecedents are legion in the previous decades.
As a result of these influences, and others allied to them, theatre history has largely reoriented toward understanding performance as a social entity: normatively constitutive of sociability, productive of the public sphere, received by socially constituted units and subunits, and reflective of wider social conditions both in its ostensible content and the reactions it engenders. Research on various forms of social cohesion and heterogeneity (not limited to class or subcultures), public formations and counterhegemonies (notably through gender, race, and ethnicity), and corporeality (human, animal, machine, and corporate) shows the strong imprint of social history and cultural history. Recently, theatre history's preoccupation with representation and symbolic power has also embraced questions about memory, cultural cohesion over time, and the consolidation, transmission, evolution, and misperformance of repertoires. Here, performance historians lead the cultural studies pack through the insights of Diana Taylor (archive and repertoire), Dwight Conquergood (speaking to and with other cultures in dialogical performance), Joseph Roach (surrogation), and Barbara Kirshenblatt-Gimblett (objects' performance of culture).Footnote 5
The time is right to examine what this means for theatre history in a temporally and geographically far-ranging perspective. Consequently, the authors of this essay agreed (with the hesitatingly enthusiastic yet fatally intrigued demeanor of the already overcommitted) to spearhead the creation of a six-volume set, A Cultural History of Theatre, commissioned by Bloomsbury Press (UK). This is scheduled to appear in 2017, with the likelihood of paperback and reconfigured print-on-demand versions thereafter. This follows antecedents in the same marketing niche of cultural histories of animals, childhood and family, the human body, sexuality, food, women, gardens, furniture, and the senses: all the classic territory of cultural history in its “history of everything” mode. Yet to think about theatre history in this company is defamiliarizing: corporeality and materiality merge significantly with the intangible and tangible aspects of performance in many cultures across time, with some relatively stable facets (bodies, sexes), mimesis and representation always in negotiation with materiality and verisimilitude (built form, sensual stimuli), and the constructed loci of theatres in tension with natural sites and instantiations (framed and curated spaces that mold experience and sensation). Our constraints include period divisions or “ages”—antiquity, medieval, early modern, enlightenment, empire, and the modern—and length (ninety-five thousand words per volume). We are fortunate to have secured a set of esteemed editors—Martin Revermann, Jody Enders, Robert Henke, Mechele Leon, Peter Marx, and Kim Solga—to take up the charge of their respective periods.
A significant aspect of how, as General Editors, we shape the series is the designation of consistent chapter rubrics to be repeated in each volume. This necessitates some inferential judgment as well as hard-headed decision making. Theatre is generally acknowledged to be the most social of artistic practices, requiring collectives to both produce and consume it. However, its production and reception do vary significantly over the past two and half thousand years. Standard theatre histories tend to follow a predictable pattern combining linguistically unified terrain or national periodization with genre consolidation or stylistic movements. Instead, the chapter headings that will uniformly structure all six volumes of A Cultural History of Theatre represent significant cultural approaches as opposed to purely regional, national, aesthetic, or generic categories. The originality and applicability of the proposed rubrics lies in the emphasis on recurrent patterns of emergence and recombination that enable comparison and dynamic change across time and place.
1. Institutional frameworks: These are the institutional factors that enable theatre to take place and be sustained, such as patronage, markets, festivals, finances, entrepreneurship, and subsidy underwriting the material conditions for theatre.
2. Social functions: Theatre is an occasion involving specific public and private behaviors related to attendance, forms of concurrent consumption (food, sex, and contingent festivities), and social stratification by class, gender, race, and ethnicity.
3. Sexuality and gender: These most fundamental aspects of human relations are patterned in the content of stories, casting and employment, attendance, and the access to cultural knowledge that either reflect permissiveness or the converse, revealing cultural anxieties, permutations, norms, and limit cases.
4. Environment of theatre: Theatres' geographical distribution and place in the urban landscape—proximity to other ceremonial, governmental, mercantile, or industrial pursuits, and to thoroughfares and throughways—impact the value of theatre and the experience of theatregoing.
5. Circulation: Theatre is a medium on the move, whose vectors of circulation reflect contemporaneous trade routes, multidirectional influences, and “contact” across cultures since antiquity.
6. Interpretations: Theatre's social and collective nature often generates suspicion among political and religious partisans. Cultural history traces philosophical, theological, and artistic debates that oscillate between outright rejection and pedagogical affirmation.
7. Communities of production: Theatre is shaped by kinship and training networks involving artisanal contributors, such as actors, writers, directors, and set and costume designers, and thus is constituted through labor as a commodity.
8. Repertoire and genres: The subject matter and forms of theatre reflect social anxieties and influences (new caste stratifications, regional differences, market differentiation, language, migration, etc.) that circulate as repertoires and consolidate as genres.
9. Technologies of performance: Theatre is an early and great adapter of technology, integrating engineering, lighting, optics, materials, and so on into staging and scenography.
10. Knowledge transmission—media and memory: Theatre and print culture have a mutually imbricated history; however, theatre is also retained and transmitted through individual and cultural memories via rehearsal, collective devising, souvenirs, cross-generational lore, and gossip.
Every editor has queried whether their remit is to commission essays about a European tradition or a global phenomenon: our answer is emphatically “yes,” recognizing the impossibility of fully disambiguating Europe from North Africa in antiquity, from Byzantium in the Middle Ages, from the New World in the early modern period, from Asia in the Enlightenment, from distant archipelagos in the so-called Age of Empire, or even the loci of Europe under the globalization of the twentieth century.
The ten chapter rubrics represent a way to see a plethora of historical writing and then, in turn, to select perspectives that crucially matter in each period. In principle, everything that is cultural should belong somewhere. In practice, choices must be made, and so the result will be indicative rather than comprehensive. Not all theoretical debts will be acknowledged. Not all practical applications will be pragmatic to include. Sometimes this will reflect the editors' vision, and sometimes it will be the contributors' polemic. Throughout the process of commissioning, conceiving, drafting, and improving the constitutive essays we encourage authors to think not only about how scholarship on their chronological period is distributed across the ten rubrics but also why certain claims are important to make in particular ways. Additionally, we encourage authors working on a given rubric to think together transhistorically, necessarily with adjacent volumes but also across the entire temporal span.
Questions of Periodization
The problematic nature of theatre's periodization has long been recognized within the discipline. Because theatre studies arose relatively “late,” it turned initially to more established disciplines—mainly literature and art history—for models of structuring the past. Neither proved to be entirely suitable for theatre. In the late-1980s Thomas Postlewait analyzed a number of theatre history textbooks and identified twenty-two separate criteria by which theatre periods were determined.Footnote 6 Although most theatre histories begin with what could be termed Cultural epochs (with a capital C)—Antiquity (meaning Greek and Roman civilizations), the Middle Ages, and the Renaissance—subsequent divisions follow divergent criteria ranging from monarchical reigns (Jacobean or Georgian) to pannational attributes (Scandinavian or African) to aesthetic movements (such as modernism or the avant-garde). After the Middle Ages, periodization tends to branch off into national trajectories, which in turn follow periods of “flowering” (usually literary but sometimes derived from the fine arts): for example, the Italian Renaissance, Elizabethan England or Siglo de Oro Spain, and French Classicism. “Baroque” theatre on the other hand—an art-historical stylistic descriptor—cuts across political and linguistic divisions. Such divisions in turn reflect the “older” tradition of German Kulturgeschichte, which tried to formulate perspectives that, while not seriously questioning categories such as antiquity or the Renaissance, included an all-encompassing approach to “high” cultural production.
Periods contrast as well as cohere in succession. A nineteenth-century historian sees stylistic differences between 1830 and 1890, marking the zeitgeist that produced and embraced Giselle utterly incommensurate with the zeitgeist that produced and received Hedda Gabler, though evolved through a succession of traceable stylistic innovations. An English early modernist marks an epochal divide between 1642 and 1643, and a breach of another kind at the retirement of Shakespeare in 1613. Temporal structures are based on events, nonevents, shifts, fissures, and locations of many kinds, according to different logics. Our six volume editors note, within the restriction of six periods, that there are some minor blessings: antiquity is a broader brief than “classical,” and medieval has porous boundaries from the fifth to sixteenth centuries. The series is forged within constraints of notional time: six “ages” that have been common currency for Eurocentric theatre history yet with which we could mount multiple persuasive critiques. We concluded early on that this was not worth contesting, for the designations that are sometimes calendrical and sometimes epochal are a little better than some alternatives. The designations are marketing devices that can, nevertheless and soon enough, be overridden by editors' and readers' choices. In addition, the themes invite diachronic reading across a single rubric, for example, as a cultural history of sexuality and gender in theatre, circulation of theatre, or theatre technology. Given that every major religion and cultural tradition has its own calendar—some solar, others lunar, and still others dynastic—linear time is about as arbitrary as any cultural marker can be. Any choice has meaning, to be sure, but the press's constraint is not the battle we deemed worth fighting.
There are more interesting questions to ask about cultural history and temporality. Should epochal delimiters—even if they could be agreed upon—mark the opening and closing of cultural historical periods or their fulcrum points? Is 1789 and its cultural implications a great revolutionary moment, never seen before, often seen since, in the midst of massive realignment of the estates, the end of ecclesiastical feudalism, the birth of liberty, the precursor to tyranny, the model for constitutional reform, or a brief flicker of ideological idealism extinguished by overweening forces from center and periphery? And culturally, is it the precursor to new genres, a shift in censorship regimes, an impetus to reorganize patronage, leverage for democratizing spectacle, or a way to think about social practices in a spectrum from executions to festivals to marionettes? Synchronization is useful to measure similarity or contrast, but it cannot be other than that. Should we focus on the incremental change (analogous to tectonic, climate, or agrarian shifts) or l'histoire événementielle (quotidian organization such as a moment-by-moment narrative of battle)? The answer will always be hedged. In our charge to editors we built in flexibility to approach issues as they think warranted, with different solutions to both the pace and scale of change and stability as well as social, economic, ethnic, religious, administrative, migratory, and other relevant complications that bear upon the cultural field but have their own historical chronologies and variants. Indeed, we hope to see approaches that recognize historical modes in many terms, not just developmental, or epochal, or intercultural.
A cultural historical approach to theatre-historiographical periodization must therefore take cognizance of the postpositivist critique formulated by Postlewait and others and at the same time harness the work and approaches of cultural historians. The conventional epochal division of A Cultural History of Theatre is not specific to theatre because it applies to all books in Bloomsbury's series, whether about emotions, death, home, alcohol, money, work, peace, medicine, hair, Western empires, or crime and punishment (topics to be published after theatre). They assume that within such large temporal swaths human creations, activity, preoccupations, or experiences labeled as “cultural” followed trajectories and patterns both homogeneous within the epoch and heterogeneous to those before and after. While it is a truism that epochal borders are usually “blurred,” this does not mean that within the demarcated boundaries common patterns of activity cannot be identified and studied. The periodization question is further complicated by the ten rubrics outlined above that remain constant across volumes and provide a diachronic perspective on a cultural history of theatre. The rubric “institutional frameworks,” for example, presupposes that theatre or theatrical activity evinces characteristics that display the durational consistency (although not necessarily immutability) that one associates with the term. By reading all six contributions to a rubric back to back, an alternative history of one aspect of the complex cultural activity we call theatre should emerge. By reading all ten, then multiple cultural histories might result.
From Kulturgeschichte to New Cultural History
How can a cultural history of the theatre be positioned within the wider field of cultural history itself? In a recent survey, the doyen of English-speaking cultural history, Peter Burke, compares the marginalization of the field in his own country to its embrace in the United States, arguing that the US tradition of immigration has created a greater sensitivity to cultural issues and differences, whereas the UK obsession with class would explain the importance of social history there.Footnote 7 He draws a comparison to a similar disparagement of cultural anthropology, a term prevalent in the United States, whereas in the United Kingdom social anthropology is the established field, though in practice there is little difference. The confusion is due in part to the evolution of the term itself, which has undergone significant changes in the countries where it had or has currency.Footnote 8
Historians today distinguish between “old” and “new” cultural history. The older variety is largely a nineteenth-century Germanic invention known as Kulturgeschichte and primarily associated with the Swiss historian Carl Jacob Burckhardt, though the term goes back to the eighteenth century. Burckhardt's foundational book, Kultur der Renaissance in Italien (1860) was translated into English as Civilization of the Renaissance in Italy (1878). The translation of Kultur as civilization renders fairly closely Burckhardt's own scholarly program which, as he states, was to study “a civilization which is the mother of our own, and whose influence is still at work among us.”Footnote 9 In its execution the “essay,” as he terms his massive book, attempts a more broadly based cultural approach than the term “civilization” evokes. Dedicated on the one hand to great (art) works and achievements, scientific breakthroughs, and elite social behavior, it seeks at the same time to find underlying currents and categories that form the framework of his book. The categories themselves—the state as a work of art; the development of the individual; the revival of antiquity; the discovery of the world and of man; society and festivals; morality and religion—reveal a scope that is closer to an understanding of cultural history in our time than in his. It is noteworthy that the English translator resorts to the word “civilization” to render the author's Kulturepoche, Zivilisation, and Kulturgeschichte. Despite the breadth and depth of Burckhardt's approach, epochal “greatness” still forms the underlying rationale for the book. The fact that it is still in print in many translations testifies to Burckhardt's ability to speak to a contemporary understanding of cultural history, even if he seldom provides a view from “below” that we find in the historical anthropology of Carlo Ginzburg or Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie.
The attempt to grasp an epoch in all its interrelatedness also marks Dutch historian Johan Huizinga's work and in particular his influential Herfsttij der Middeleeuwen (1919; English, The Waning of the Middle Ages), which in the spirit of Burckhardt examines late medieval culture as “a study of the forms of life, thought and art in France and the Netherlands in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries.”Footnote 10 His point of departure was the desire to understand better the art of Van Eyck and his followers in the context of the “the entire life of their times.”Footnote 11 Great art rather than popular culture places Huizinga in a genealogy following Burckhardt's study of Renaissance Italy, which (as Burckhardt alludes) was really an extended detour on the way to writing a history of Italian art.
Though the status and literary quality of both books is undeniable, they remained outside mainstream political historiography and played a marginal role, at least in recent theatre history, even though Burckhardt deals with theatrical material in several different chapters. His importance for cultural theatre history needs to be seen in terms of the contexts in which he deals with theatrical genres, rather than what he actually says about them. His willingness to discuss moresca dances alongside Plautine comedy stands in contrast (for today's readers) to a predilection for Hegelian metaphors of flowering and decline. By the same token, Huizinga deals only marginally with established forms of drama, yet his insights into the performative, sportive, and erotic aspects of the late medieval tournament and an interest in clothing and emblems can easily be integrated into a contemporary perspective on medieval theatricality.Footnote 12
Modern cultural history can be referenced to two main scholarly traditions: historical anthropology and New Cultural History.Footnote 13 The former precedes the latter, and though the latter draws on the former it is by no means coterminous with it. Historical anthropology refers to a movement that led historians to draw on the huge body of social/cultural anthropological data and theory to illuminate historical practices and a number of ethnologists to investigate the past. The new alliance between the disciplines of history and anthropology became focused in the late 1960s around two central questions, one methodological and theoretical, the other disciplinary. The former addressed the problem of how the structural-synchronic perspective of anthropologists could be reconciled with the chronological-diachronic methods and narratives of historians. The American anthropologist Marshall Sahlins focused the debate around the key terms “event” and “structure.”Footnote 14 How do events (the domain of historians) influence “structure” (the domain of social scientists) and vice versa? It was this extremely complex problem that led to the second question, which was that of territorial divisions. The anthropologist Clifford Geertz had early problematized the ahistoricity of his own discipline and its “emphasis on systems in balance, on social homeostasis, and on timeless structural pictures.”Footnote 15 He later described the territorial realignments brought about by the cross-fertilization between the two disciplines as “a change in the ecology of learning that has driven historians and anthropologists, like so many migrant geese, into one another's territories: a collapse of the natural dispersion of feeding grounds that left France to the one and Samoa to the other.”Footnote 16 What Geertz implies here is that before this ecological shift, France had a history and Samoa did not (or at least only a very recent one), and that Samoan culture is characterized by “timeless structural pictures” whereas French history is only of interest in so far as it is manifested in significant, that is, political, “events.” It became evident to perceptive observers on both sides of the feeding grounds that such a dichotomous view was untenable. In practice, the territorial disputes were less problematic as scholars stuck to their respective patches: anthropologically inclined historians remained in France or Italy, whereas a new generation of anthropologists began to concern themselves with the historical past and began to sift through colonial archives relating to the cultures they had hitherto studied in situ.Footnote 17
In theatre history the event–structure dichotomy took on a different emphasis because an event-centered historiography appeared congruent with performance incidence and analysis. Interest became focused on questions of circulation, contact, and exchange. Here the concept of performative encounters, especially putative “first encounters,” appeared enormously attractive, providing as it did both scope for historical ethnographic inquiry and the “close reading” techniques of performance analysis. It is especially notable that formative literary scholars (Stephen Greenblatt and Saidiya Hartman), anthropologists (Marshall Sahlins and Michael Taussig), historians-cum-anthropologists (Greg Dening), and theatre and performance scholars (Richard Schechner and Joseph Roach) all explored performative encounters in their respective studies.Footnote 18 Such so-called encounters served to problematize the event–structure dichotomy, inasmuch as precontact cultures would appear to epitomize structure in the “timeless structural pictures” mode (Geertz) whereas “their contingent or evenemential character” required recourse to a theory of the performative.Footnote 19
The intersection of history, anthropology, and performance studies coincides with a reevaluation of the term “cultural history.” The seminal and eponymous volume edited by Lynn Hunt, The New Cultural History (1989), outlined both the theoretical genealogy of the new version and some of its possible applications.Footnote 20 The theoretical framework derived from social history (E. P. Thompson), historical anthropology (Natalie Zemon Davis), ethnology (Clifford Geertz), epistemic forms of power (Michel Foucault), and the metahistory of Hayden White. Its self-declared “new approaches” conducive to performative analysis included the emergence of audience attention as a social norm (James Johnson, Listening in Paris), performance's relationship to the history of print culture (Julie Stone Peters, Theatre of the Book 1480–1880), the body and Enlightenment science (Joseph Roach, The Player's Passion), and the spatial semantics and proxemics at work in specific civic spaces (Marvin Carlson, Places of Performance). As New Cultural History has progressed with and without its epithet, a number of themes and fields have emerged. Its exponents harnessed theorists who are equated with the theory revolution throughout the humanities. Apart from those already mentioned, these also include Mikhail Bakhtin, especially his writings on carnival; Norbert Elias on processes of civilization; and Pierre Bourdieu's writings on social and cultural capital and habitus.Footnote 21 More importantly, a number of concerns emerged that both drew from and energized adjacent disciples: interest in cultural practices rather than ideas; focus on representations as the means by which cultures manifest their inchoate forms; expanded concern with “material culture” (borrowed from social anthropology); and, drawing on all three above-mentioned theorists, rediscovery of the body in the context of feminism, gender theory, and queer politics. More recent concerns include memory and memorialization, performance, and histories of knowledge and knowledge practices.Footnote 22
Theatre appears to have had little explicit importance in the wider New Cultural History project. This is no doubt because, like classical music, it is or was considered to be a cultural epiphenomenon, a manifestation of the cultural superstructure that the new historians were trying to get under. Theatrical cultural history was nevertheless being written, if only because some theatre historians were drawing on the same theoretical paradigms as their new cultural colleagues. This cultural turn is already evident in important collections such as in the volume edited by Tom Postlewait and Bruce McConachie, Interpreting the Theatrical Past (1989) and the historical essays in Critical Theory and Performance (1992), edited by Janelle Reinelt and Joseph Roach, but it is not formulated explicitly as such. “Performance” takes precedence over “culture” in the theoretical and methodological realignment of theatre history in the 1990s. Although performance studies initially had a strong focus on contemporary phenomena, a minority of scholars utilized such approaches to study the past. Joseph Roach's study Cities of the Dead (1996) can be regarded as an example of a cultural history of performance, indeed as the book that bridged the previous divide between theatre history and performance studies. It traverses or circumnavigates the Atlantic between London and New Orleans, between the early-eighteenth and the late twentieth century, via links forged during the slave trade and the sixty million Africans who perished or were displaced across the Middle Passage. Roach is concerned with performance in the widest sense of the word, encompassing dramatic plays, English funerary rites, slave auctions, sexual exhibition, and Mardi Gras processions. Linking these disparate phenomena is the concept of surrogation, “the three-sided relationship of memory, performance, and substitution.”Footnote 23 The key question is “how culture reproduces and re-creates itself,”Footnote 24 a central concern of anthropology of course, for which it has coined the term enculturation. The movement of both Europeans and Africans across the Atlantic, however, entailed more enculturative breakdown than continuity, so that Roach's study focuses on the process by which cultures create substitutes for lost, forgotten, or destroyed forms. A central function in these surrogation processes is occupied by corporeal memory, which offers more than superficial affinities with performance. Both are forms of standing in, each offering “a substitute for something else that preexists it.”Footnote 25 By foregrounding performance as a bodily memory process, Roach created a specifically theatrical contribution to the wider cultural history project.
The performative turn is one of the many research paradigms that characterize both historical anthropology and New Cultural History. The rise of performance studies in the 1990s provided the bridge for the growing two-way traffic between anthropology and theatre studies both in terms of subject matter and theory. Additionally, performance ethnographers such as Dwight Conquergood, Della Pollock, Norman Denzin, and D. Soyini Madison challenged theatre scholars to regard performance operating simultaneously as the theory, means, and product of inquiry. Certain performative phenomena such as festivals, rituals, and political ceremonies had already been studied by historical anthropologists and read “thickly” in the Geertzian manner. European festival cultures almost always included genuine theatrical performances, so that a link or at least common ground was already established. To effect productive interdisciplinary exchange, however, it was necessary to bridge some gaps. These bridges came from a variety of sources. One was Victor Turner's theory of social drama with its model of breach, crisis, redress, and reintegration or schism.Footnote 26 Although developed on the basis of fieldwork among a Central African tribe, it was eagerly adopted by historians and projected back onto Europe's “tribal past”: ancient Greece, for instance, where historians had been gradually realizing that the structures and cultural patterns obtaining there had probably more in common with Central Africa and precontact Samoa than with the neoclassicism of J. W. von Goethe or J. J. Winckelmann.Footnote 27
From Social History to Cultural History
Social and cultural history are characterized by several traditions in twentieth-century thought. Since the 1920s the Annales School's focus on observation of long periods of economic, social, and cultural evolution, “neglecting surface disturbances” (”négligeant les trépidations de surface”),Footnote 28 made it unsuited to theatre studies insofar as theatre is perpetrated in institutions that tend to perish with their founders—there are exceptions, of course, and thus there are institutional, civic, and regional histories of theatres—and in events of a few hours' duration that repeat, albeit with difference. Studies of genre and dramatic theory are better suited to the timeline of the Annales, yet these are not historical phenomena except when instantiated through specific performances or when flashing to incandescence through transient (usually scandalous) events.
The History Workshop—closely associated with Raphael Samuel, who founded it at Oxford in 1976, but branching across Europe, America, and South Africa—is reductively credited with “history from below,” though it has much broader implications for the participatory facets of who is a historian as well as what is written as history. Resisting the conservatism of political, diplomatic, and intellectual history, the “workshop” aspect of participatory history recognized that “the volunteer guides at the open-air museums; or the thousands of railway fanatics who spend their summer holidays acting as guards or station staff on the narrow gauge lines of the Pennines and North Wales” also serve as historians who promulgate interest in the past.Footnote 29 Thus, the humbler forms of entertainment—village wakes and fairs, amateur theatricals, mummings and disguisings—were the ambit of this kind of social history as well as its modern-day forms of historical reenactment and site-specific or environmental engagements. Studies of leisure, “rational recreation,” popular performance, and audience attendance are often indebted to the impetus of the History Workshop. Works by Mona Ozouf, Marc Baer, Jane Moody, and Helen M. Burke, for instance, recognize theatre as the site where class and national interests combust into riots or the formation of illegitimate institutions with impetus from the working classes.Footnote 30 In keeping with the Annales, which can emphasize great depth of detail on a locality, the History Workshop tradition connects theatres in specific localities to facets of governmentality, shows how beliefs manifest as overt behaviors, emphasizes the relevance of labor, and traces the vocal and spectacular forms of performative mentalités.
New Historicism's tendency to complicate the locus of base and superstructure, as well as its disdain for periodization, has had a significant effect on conceptions of theatre as cultural history, especially in alliance with literary studies. The technique of thick description can be well adapted to performance reconstruction; however, the reliance on “context” to matrix a compelling anecdote into social complexity negates the historical commitment to gradualist or motivated change. Even so, the influence of Raymond Williams and Walter Benjamin (rather than Michel Foucault) on theatre studies precedes the eruption of New Historicism in the 1980s and continues to shape ideas about popular culture, the durability and transience of art in modernity, sites' power to shape concepts, and ethnic and racial permutations of cultural legibility. The erstwhile “marginal” or “trivial” brings ephemeral performance events into focus along with their societies' progenitors. Time and again, theatre histories focus on how the mise-en-scène is brought to bear on the horizon of expectation about what constitutes “events” and “politics,” but they also broaden the recognition of the mise-en-scène beyond playhouse stages to their auditoria and thence to any place in the public sphere where theatrical conventions—scenery, behavioral pretense, prop manipulation, costume, and so on—heighten the stakes of oratorical or visual rhetoric.
Theatre history that adopts these modes positions theatre as a cultural institution yet also as a recognizable set of techniques recombinable into endless permutations deployed through other cultural institutions: state pomp, military protocol, bourgeois sensibility, and street life, to name a few. Thus, theatre literally constitutes and pervades culture. To limit A Cultural History of Theatre to what is more conventionally known as theatre, as we do, is to provide a key to the greater whole. The contributions that theatre historians make to cultural history are tactical—recognizing how the extra complicated dimensions of pretense and dissembling are celebrated or vilified by vested interests—and the methods that they bring to the elucidation of the mise-en-scène as a discursive, narrative, generic, visual, spatial, sonic, temporal, and affective interpretive framework constitute a particular skill set par excellence.
Temporality and Spatiality
Surrogation radically challenges what is understood as a performative practice located in a culture, at a moment of time, and either enacted or accessed for enactment by communities. It allows for highly diffused causal attributions across time and place; indeed, cause is less important than sublimation, the return of the repressed, or displacement made evident as recurrence. In contrast, Diana Taylor's construct of archive and repertoire emphasizes the craft aspect of performance: knowledge passed from master to protégé, generation after generation, as a lived practice.Footnote 31 Whereas surrogation is compatible with New Historicism's Foucauldian approach to webbed forces of power and consequentiality that become evident through phenomena, Taylor's construct resolutely recognizes the artist's mastery and agency, on the one hand, and repositories' imperfect caching of their legacy when the chain of human custody become unviable.
Distinct as they are with respect to agency, these approaches to cultural history of performance overcome several of the abiding challenges of theatre research. First, the ephemerality of the performed moment: noting repeated observations of similarity allows for inductive reasoning about transmission at the same time that syllogistic deduction (if A resembles B and B resembles C, then C is a performative trace of A) links performance to secondary (or epiphenomenal) vortices, whether on racial, ethnic, or other grounds, across vast distances and temporalities. Second, the pace of transmission and change drop out of importance when there is allowance for “culture” as the transmitter of performance rather than specific individuals. Surrogation tends to remove the human factor of labor as sustaining repertoires in favor of another human factor, memory (or misremembering), as a nonagential conveyor. The translocal, transnational, and transcontinental appeal of surrogation in historicizing modern subjects as transcultural and multicultural within global history subverts ideas about national performance history and the timelines this imposes. For Taylor, however, memory is agential and acts through the bodily practices. Transmission is changed in kind when the repertoire is archived. And third, the surprise of a first encounter (imprévu) necessarily becomes imbued with the experience of uncanny recognition (déjà vu). Additionally, it accounts for indigeneity, diversity, and hybridity as traces without the kinds of direct evidence required by philological or materialist history.
Thus, cultural history has profoundly shifted concepts of theatrical performance. As Eli Rozik argues, “Ritual is a mode of action and theatre a cultural medium. Whereas as a mode of action ritual reflects intentions and purposes, as a medium theatre is neutral with regard to intentions and purposes and can be employed for any kind of action, including ritual.”Footnote 32 No longer merely a pastime linked to superstructure or a folk art linked to indigeneity or locality, theatre takes on powerful explanatory power of the forces exerted by intersecting economic, ethnographic, and institutional factors.
In Jürgen Osterhammel's magisterial global history of the nineteenth century, the first instance of an approach to memory and self-observation he offers is opera. Why, in a 1,167-page book that runs the gamut from colonialism to social space, urbanization to energy, and living standards to religion, does opera take this place of honor? It is because opera encapsulates a product circulated worldwide, not only appreciated in its time but still widely staged and consumed.Footnote 33 For centuries it was thought of as an Italian form, but after 1830 Paris was the nexus of the system for production and distribution, out of which stars were created who toured with successful repertoire in a network that reached to Lisbon, London, Moscow, the Ottoman Empire, the Australian coasts, and the Brazilian rain forest. By the 1860s it was produced in magnificent surroundings also at the estuary of the Mississippi, San Francisco's Golden Gate, and Santiago de Chile. The subjects of the repertoire spanned myth, legend, and modern history: Teutonic Valhalla, druidical Britain, Renaissance Italy, and contemporary Bohemia, like a performative encyclopedia of Eurocentric storytelling, with further classical variants showing up in Latin and South America beginning in 1701. The example of opera encapsulates the importance of institutional frameworks (the financiers who built and sustained opera houses), social functions (the allure of a high-status form, especially with international singing stars), the theatres' environment (the significance of the architectural envelope linking widely distributed metropoles), circulation (of repertoire but also fandom), and knowledge guilds that constitute communities of production and utilize common technologies (multiple kinds of labor, artistry, and technical expertise homogenized across locations). As culture, opera epitomizes elite taste consolidated around genres. As cultural history, it maps onto changing demography and shows the trace of print culture's ability to disseminate demand in starkly disparate circumstances. The aesthetic value of the form, or its perpetrators, is not lost in the cultural history, but it is located in frameworks that decenter the event of performance or the allure of superstars into infinitely more complex contingent practices.
The Osterhammel example makes clear that in a cultural history of theatre the event of performance may be radically decentered. Theatre historians are no longer confined to what happens onstage from the first notes of the overture any more than they are devoted to chronicles' listing of events. Vast networks of knowledge, production, and circulation frame opera's very presence in a culture, but just as important are the quotidian facet of the social mise-en-scène can unlock the meaning of a moment on stage.
Spectatorship
If aesthetic form or virtuosic vocal display are not of central interest for a cultural history of theatre—they represent only a segment of theatre's appeal—then what is a specifically cultural approach to the reason why people have attended the medium of theatre across the ages? The question of spectatorship is clearly central for a cultural history of theatre and performance, yet it is not one that features explicitly under its own rubric in A Cultural History of Theatre. This may seem somewhat amiss in a series written primarily by theatre scholars who have themselves been enculturated to affirm that, citing Brecht, “the audience regulates the performance.”Footnote 34 Samuel Johnson had somewhat a narrower concept—”The stage but echoes back the public voice”Footnote 35—yet despite the mostly unquestioned acceptance of such ubiquitous claims regarding the spectator's centrality, spectator- or audience-focused research of a historical inflection has never dominated. It could be claimed that there is therefore no case for investigating a discrete category “spectator” or “audience” independent of the performance as a whole. If the audience does regulate the performance, then it is neither useful nor heuristically possible to separate it out. Indeed, as General Editors we believe the question of spectatorship is so central to the whole concept of a cultural history of theatre that it will feature in several rubrics, not one, but not always the same ones in each volume.
There are rich theoretical constructs for approaching this challenge. A cultural approach to theatre history can draw on a number of concepts that have already been productively harnessed within theatre research. The notion of “horizon of expectation” developed within reception studies and reader-response theory can be employed to discuss spectatorship not just from an aesthetic but also from a decidedly social or ideological standpoint.Footnote 36 Patrice Pavis's highly elaborated application of the concept to theatrical performance, though not historical in method, does differentiate a number of different spectatorial codes at work.Footnote 37 The “horizon of expectation” is determined by previous experiences and background knowledge that the spectator brings to the performance and in that sense is a product of enculturation. It acts not only on an aesthetic level—recognition of stage conventions, style of acting, narrative patterns and so on—but also within an ideological frame. Spectators bring with them ideological conditioning via familial, ethnic, and class ties; education; and religious affiliations. These determine in turn the “social function” of theatregoing, the spectator's expectations of theatre, the aspects of social reality for which audiences may look in the play and preferences for certain genres in certain periods. Spectatorial habits and expectation infuse the rubric “repertoire and genres” because genres in particular need to be seen as processes of negotiation and calibration between production and reception, which in turn influence institutional frameworks as well as social functions. Social expectations may include negotiations of social and cultural capital via dress codes and the sheer fact of being in a certain type of theatre. Thorstein Veblen's concept of “conspicuous consumption” still holds for attendance at certain kinds of theatre such as opera, which are often frequented to demonstrate cultural and economic capital and as a place requiring a special kind of habitus (Bourdieu).Footnote 38
On the level of “environment” we can ask what spatial contiguity creates in terms of a horizon of expectations: the proverbial propinquity of bear-baiting arenas and public theatres in Elizabethan London, the tendency to create theatrical clusters that characterized nineteenth-century metropolitan centers, or the idea of a “fringe” or secondary set of sites where theatre is emergent (literally edgy) and antiestablishment. Sometimes these “pleasure districts” offered entertainments of a decidedly more carnal nature so that theatre in sensu stricto belonged to a complex urban milieu of performative pleasures that colored, in turn, theatre's social function for those who sought it out.
In more general terms, the audience's horizon of expectations is also decisively shaped by what Ric Knowles has called “public discourse,” a broad term encompassing the wealth of information a theatre generates about itself and its productions. The public discourse surrounding a theatre can often be stage-managed by marketing and advertising campaigns and therefore usually transcends a particular production. It works through “cumulative impact” over time, sometimes years, occasionally even decades in the case of famous theatres such as the Abbey Theatre in Dublin with its link to Irish nationalism, or the Berliner Ensemble's association with Brecht and political theatre.Footnote 39
Questions of spectatorship also inhere in the categories “sexuality and gender,” which not only refer to categories of representation on the stage but also pervade the sociology of theatregoing. From the probable exclusion of women from Greek theatre festivals to segregated and curtained-off zenana (women-only) sections of Western-style theatres in Muslim and Hindu communities, gender divisions have almost always impacted theatre attendance. This might include a commercially motivated sensitivity in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries to the gender-specific spectatorship of performance genres aimed very much at the new audience of shopgirls and salaried workers, who featured in turn as a new category of dramatis personae.Footnote 40
Spectatorship can also be integrated into considerations of “institutional frameworks” inasmuch as these determine who attends theatre and for what reasons. Indoor theatrical performances within an Italian court festival of the early modern period, which were enabled through princely patronage, regulated audiences in a completely different way than the coeval performances at public theatres in London. As the commedia dell'arte scholar Ferdinando Taviani has argued, the sixteenth century sees a significant transformation in theatrical organization from an economia di festa to an economia di mercato, where, instead of providing theatre in the form of prefinanced, no-risk courtly festivals, itinerant troupes needed to sell their product on a fickle and open market of supply and demand.Footnote 41 Although Taviani has his sights on forms of production, the implications are just as significant for reception, that is, for audiences who were now asked to pay for professional entertainment and where purchase of a ticket activated the theatrical contract. In the fictional contract enacted between audience and playwright in the induction to Ben Jonson's Bartholomew Fair (1614), the playwright agrees to provide a play on condition that the audience pay their money and be quiet—but the latter are also entitled to “have his or their free-will of censure, to like or dislike at their own charge.”Footnote 42 Jonson's satirical intervention adumbrates a fundamental cultural and institutional agreement, a contrat théâtral, that continues to regulate most forms of theatrical performance up until the present.
“Free-will of censure” refers to the audience's function as both arbiter and transmitter of the messages emitted from the stage. The freedom to censure applies not only to the feedback loop between spectators and performers but also to the wider public that may not even be present at a performance but attends nevertheless to the existence and circulation of theatre. This wider entity can be more precisely termed the “public sphere,” that arena of debate and public opinion formation defined by Jürgen Habermas as being constitutive of Enlightenment literary, theatrical, and political culture.Footnote 43 The public sphere belongs in the rubric “interpretations,” where theatre's place, even occasionally its very existence, is debated and contested. The “antitheatrical prejudice” (Barish) that has accompanied theatre's institutional existence since antiquity draws on a long lineage of philosophical, theological, and occasionally aesthetic arguments that are articulated not in the theatre itself but in the public sphere of philosophical dialogues, learned theological treatises, performed and published sermons, and even parliamentary debate.Footnote 44 The recurring rhetorical topos, however, is invariably the theatrical spectator, a subject continually exposed to depravity and thereby requiring protection and supervision.
In sum, we can speculate that a cultural-historical examination of spectatorship will tend to emphasize continuity rather than epistemic breach, though theatre history has focused disproportionately on the latter. This is not to say that the latter does not matter, but its particularity and innovative potential is only legible against the background of patterned behaviors and conventions that may be transmitted over generations. These in turn infuse so many aspects of the theatrical medium that a discrete category “spectatorship” proves ultimately to be as reductive as it is constitutive.
This account of key ideas framing the historiography of A Cultural History of Theatre does not detail all the intellectual debts that matter; indeed, these would be far too many to mention. Our focus has been on insights that have stimulated multiple strains of theatre inquiry within broader traditions of cultural history, especially when these insights impinge on several rubrics. This maps a set of vital coordinates of what has stimulated a great swathe of theatre historiography since the 1970s; from these coordinates we undertook the task of categorizing the vast intellectual labor that constitutes theatre as cultural history and the cultural history of theatre up to 2015, ranging across scholarship that addresses millennia and embraces the global and “glocal,” so that we could stipulate just ten rubrics for all the editors to commission. Perhaps it is remarkable that there was no resistance to our choices, and that clarifying conversations have been minimal. They are, indeed, forgivingly encompassing categories. The truly difficult work is now upon the editors and authors to make choices that narrow down to what is vital for a given period.
