Histories of modern Mexico generally fit within a widely accepted periodization: the Porfiriato, the Revolution and Reconstruction, and the years of PNR/PRM/PRI hegemony. Now that the PRI is down (but not out), a new genre is emerging, of what might be called post-PRI Mexico. Turbulent post-PRI Mexico has been characterized by hyperinflation, economic and financial collapse, the electoral defeat of the once-ruling party, the installation of PAN governments and neoliberal policies, the dismantling of the PRI political economy, and the rise of narco-violence and the drug wars. The four distinguished Mexicanists who wrote Mexico since 1980 provide an intelligent and coherent explanation of why modernization under the PRI led to the collapse of the 1980s and to the consequences mentioned above. They also explain why the recovery since then has been incomplete. Though not without controversy, the volume employs a consistent theoretical approach and in-depth research to make clear why neoliberal reforms have failed to spark an economic rebirth. Stephen Haber et al. organize their analysis around two questions: (1) Why did the opening up of the economy to foreign trade and investment not result in sustained economic growth? and (2) Why has electoral democracy not produced rule of law?
The introductory chapter affirms that modern Mexico has experienced a revolution, defined as a “dramatic change in the institutions that organize economic, political, and social life …” (p. 1). The authors point out that successive governments have instituted extensive reforms with marked consequences over the last quarter century. The book presents a clear description of these institutional and legal shifts. For the most part, the authors believe that liberalization and democratization could have served Mexico well had the reforms gone far enough. Instead, they point out that current reform efforts have been limited by “property-rights institutions that developed under authoritarianism” (p. 18). Unless property rights are strengthened and political institutions made more accountable, further stagnation is likely. To make this argument, the book utilizes precise definitions, in-depth qualitative and quantitative research, and clear argument.
Chapter 2, “Mexico Before 1982,” describes the evolution of property-rights institutions since independence. Particularly relevant is the contradictory inheritance from the Porfiriato, where “special privileges granted to a coalition of large landowners, powerful politicians, bankers, and industrialists” (p. 21) made possible genuine economic growth. This sets the stage for later chapters, where the authors argue that special privileges continue to undermine the enforcement of property rights and full democratization. The revolution, 1910–1920, was a reaction to an economic model that favored special privileges and well-connected, powerful families while increasing the ranks of the poor and the landless. It eventually gave rise to the PRI, which had to regenerate economic growth while placating the masses. The chapter has a sophisticated analysis of the mechanisms through which the party kept power and ruled Mexico, including their contradictions. For example, the ejido was “an amazingly inefficient way to grow food” (p. 32) but “a very efficient way to mobilize votes” (p. 33). The data supporting both is quite convincing. Equally important, the contradictions of PRI politics led to tax rates insufficient to carry out PRI social policies, while the politics of financial and economic policy slowly strangled the economy, setting the stage for crisis.
Chapter 3, the “Causes and Consequences of Free Trade,” argues that the opening of the economy in response to the economic crises of the 1980s failed because of incomplete liberalization, insufficient reforms to fiscal policy, and a continuing weakness in the banking system. The analysis of the North American Free Trade Agreement explains why it did not reignite economic growth. The authors compare Mexico with other countries and use some counterfactual analysis to demonstrate that liberalization could have worked had Mexico gone far enough in its systemic reforms.
This leads to chapter 4, “The Mexican Banking System.” Since two of the book's authors, Haber and Noel Maurer, are leading experts on Mexico's banks, it is not surprising that this chapter contains a wealth of detailed and sophisticated data that explain the problems of Mexico's financial system, which are rooted in “the weakness of contract rights” (p. 119). It is hard for a modern economy to grow without a solid banking system.
Chapter 5, “The Transformation of Mexican politics,” argues that a central part of Mexico's revolution is the transition from the “façade of democracy” under the PRI, to its current democracy. The chapter contains a succinct analysis of the legal changes that allowed the opposition to eventually come to power. Despite these changes, a lack of accountability and excessive control of party leaders has made Mexico's democracy structurally weak and perhaps unable to carry out the economic reforms necessary to move the economy forward. Like the chapter on banking, this chapter has the clearest presentation I have seen on the legal reforms that allowed opposition parties to essentially topple the PRI.
Chapter 6, “Health, Education, and Welfare,” looks at the impact of changing government policies on health, education, housing, and retirements. The authors correlate decreased mortality rates with the privatization of health care. The government also privatized pensions, but without much help to the working population. Nor did educational reform function as planned, in part for lack of resources. Whatever the reforms, the book argues that failure to strengthen property rights has undermined economic growth, which in turn increased poverty, a fact noted in this chapter.
The last chapter, “Democracy and Development in Mexico,” argues that Mexico has made substantial free-market and democratic reforms. Nonetheless, the reforms have failed to adequately strengthen the rule of law and the enforcement of property rights. Absent such changes, the country's democracy and economy are weak. The concluding chapter is a call for deeper change.
This is a volume that is as brilliant as it is controversial. Its brilliance lies in the depth and quality of research, the clearness of argument, and a focused theoretical underpinning. It is an impressive example of the ability of the new institutional economics to explain recent history. The descriptions of the institutional changes in politics and banking are so clear as to belie the complex research behind them. It is the best analysis of modern Mexican political economy that I have seen.
At the same time, the book will not be without controversy. To put it succinctly, it argues that the problem with neoliberal reforms in Mexico is that they haven't gone far enough, nor have the democratic reforms been as effective as they need to be. The book makes a strong argument that the solution to Mexico's ills is better enforcement of private property rights. This contrasts sharply with such books as the equally brilliant and controversial Shock Doctrine by Naomi Klein, which of course argues that neoliberal reforms paved the road to disaster in Latin America and elsewhere. The advantage of the Haber, Herbert S. Klein, Maurer, and Kevin J. Middlebrook approach is that the argument is so clearly stated, and the supporting data so strong, that it is impossible to dismiss. Whatever one's viewpoint, this is indispensable reading for those interested in modern Mexico.
