The Glass House Boys of Pittsburgh makes a fine contribution to the history of child labor by detailing progressives' attempts to protect the boys in the bottle-making industry in western Pennsylvania at the turn of the century. James L. Flannery approaches his subject from multiple perspectives: those of the progressive reformers lobbying for effective legal prohibitions, powerful union leaders, state legislators, the working boys themselves, and the glass manufacturers squeezed by new technologies. Flannery finds that the process of technological change constricted the choices and possibilities of all these interests. He documents how repeated attempts by reformers to remove young boys from the glass factories, especially boys on the night shift, by tightening child labor or compulsory school attendance laws, were thwarted longer in western Pennsylvania than in other industrial states by a coalition of business and labor. However, he does not have a clear explanation of why reformers finally succeeded in overturning the famous “glass house exception” in 1915.
Flannery does a credible job of teasing out of the progressive reformers' rhetoric the animating beliefs they held about the uniqueness, plasticity, and purity of childhood and the consequent need for sheltering children. Flannery is also sensitive to the hard realities of the lives of working-class families who did not have the luxury of sharing these ideals and did not support the legislative agenda of progressives intended to better the lives of workers.
With the advent of Owen's automatic bottle machine, the crucial issue of the impact of automation is heavily fogged by the boosterism of its promoters, the fears of its critics, and the self-interest of its patent holders. Flannery makes a concerted attempt to cut through this haze but has difficulty separating legend from fact. He tends to believe the overwrought claims of the invention's labor critics that it was a technology that could at a stroke “replace virtually all adult and child labor associated with glass-bottle manufacturing.” (91) He notes that the Owens Bottle Machine company, owner of the patent, pursued a cautious licensing strategy to ensure its machine did not flood the glass market. Flannery also accepts that Pittsburgh manufacturers voluntarily chose to adopt the technology belatedly because of its high cost as well as union pressure. By taking contemporary sources at their word, Flannery misunderstands the true reasons behind the slow adoption of the Owens Automatic bottle machine. Automation proceeded at a slow pace in the Pittsburgh region not because these old-fashioned manufacturers balked at paying the Owens Bottle Machine company's astronomical licensing fees, but because the Owens company simply refused to sell licenses to all but a handful of companies. Any discussion of the “reluctance” of manufacturers to adopt the Owens Automatic is beside the point. Most producers could not have bought a license at any price.
Flannery does a wonderful job recounting the impossible bind that automation thrust upon the once powerful Glass Bottle-Blowers' Association (GBBA). Unable to fight the introduction of machine production, the GBBA tacitly accepted increasing unemployment of its members as the cost of holding the line on wages and union rules. However, year by year the pressure on union scale and standards increased, and within five years of the introduction of the Owens machine, the GBBA was forced to concede nearly all the demands of the remaining hand-blown firms. By the end of the bottle machine's first decade, GBBA union wages were cut by more than half. The other side of this story, the relationship of unions in the automated bottle companies, remains uncharted here.
The Glass House Boys admirably explodes the myth that the advent of automated glass blowing machinery ended the industry's use of child labor. Flannery correctly points out that while the new automated factories could afford to reduce or even eliminate dependence on children, their hand competitors were forced to take the opposite strategy and intensify the use of children to make up for their competitive disadvantages. Thus, a labor-saving technology had the perverse effect of actually increasing the exploitation of children.
Although progressives, factory managers, and contemporary journalists were all eager to chalk up the strikes and resistance of child laborers to youthful exuberance or fecklessness, Flannery is right to take such actions seriously and to read them as conscious and strategic decisions on the part of boys who knew what they were doing and what they hoped to accomplish. He deftly portrays the shifts in union policy regarding child labor: as the GBBA's open obstruction of child labor reforms intensified, its membership's dependency on child exploitation increased.
The partisan attachments that colored the child-labor controversy raise a rich set of epistemological questions. By what means can the statistics of either the politically appointed state factory inspectors or the crusaders against child labor be trusted? Are there means by which the factual and statistical claims of either side can be checked against other evidence and weighed, or are historians simply doomed whimsically to choose to believe one set of numbers over another? Although Flannery does a fine job of pointing out many places where the data appear to be questionable due to political and ideological influences, he does not seek a solution to this conundrum but instead generally gives more credence to the claims of the progressives.
Flannery's book may spur further research beyond the conflicting claims of progressives and state statisticians in order to better document the realities of the lives of working children and to understand them not just as objects to be reformed or redeemed but as historical actors in their own right.
